[Cross-posted at Crooks and Liars.]
Donald Trump was interviewed by phone by Greta Van Susteren yesterday and doubled down yet again on
his Birtherism:
TRUMP: What does this have to do with race? This has
absolutely nothing to do with race. The fact is that if you look at
what's happened with respect to this birth certificate issue, he doesn't
have it, he's spent millions of dollars on lawyers trying to get out of
the issue, they give what's called a certificate of live birth, which
doesn't even have a signature on it -- and anybody can get a certificate
of live birth -- it's nothing to do with a birth certificate. And they
are really reeling!
Now, they talk all sorts of things. You don't have a doctor or a
nurse -- this is the president of the United States, and no doctor, no
nurse, nobody's come forward saying, 'I delivered that beautiful baby.'
There's so many things!
Even if you look at the newspaper, the so-called newspaper article in
Hawaii -- that was days after he was born! So, that wasn't like when he
was born! And if you really think about a couple of things -- whoever
took a newspaper advertisement -- now these were poor people. These
aren't rich people. Whoever took a newspaper advertisement to announce
the birth of your baby? Now, I don't think you know of anybody, and I
know of nobody -- and I know poor people and rich people, but I've never
heard of taking a newspaper ad to advertise that you have a baby.
All Trump is really doing is proving his stupidity and gullibility --
not exactly desirable qualities in a president. At the very least, he's
demonstrating how clueless and out of touch a rich guy he really is.
Here's the newspaper birth announcement in question:
This is from
FactCheck.org,
which explains that a pro-Hillary/anti-Obama blogger first dug this up
from the Honolulu Advertiser's archives of Sunday, Aug. 31, 1961.
This isn't an advertisement -- rather, this is a standard newspaper
birth announcement. You see, in the old days, before large corporations
took over newspapers and forced them to gradually eviscerate their
newsgathering functions, newspapers sent out their cops-and-courts
reporters about once a week to collect all the previous week's birth
listings from local hospitals. (This practice has long since fallen by
numerous newsroom-budget-cutting waysides.) In other words, the
Advertiser
announcement was collected by the paper itself and stands as
independent corroboration that Obama was born in a Honolulu hospital.
The fact that Trump doesn't know of anyone who has their birth listed
in the paper by anything other than an ad indicates how out of touch
this rich man really is.
And while we're mentioning the young couple's poverty ... does Trump
really believe that both Barack Obama Sr. and a very pregnant Stanley
Ann Dunham-Obama were able to make what was in 1961 a long and difficult
and expensive journey to Kenya for young Barack's birth, and then
return in time for Barack Sr. to resume his fall classes in Hawaii?
As for why no doctor has turned up claiming to have overseen Obama's
birth, well, that would be because he is dead. The doctor in question
was Dr. Rodney T. West, a since-deceased obstetrician who
told his friends about Obama's birth at the time in a memorable fashion -- memorable enough that they wrote it down, like his friend Barbara Nelson:
“I may be the only person left who specifically remembers
his birth. His parents are gone, his grandmother is gone, the
obstetrician who delivered him is gone,” said Nelson, referring to Dr.
Rodney T. West, who died in February at the age of 98. Here’s the story:
Nelson was having dinner at the Outrigger Canoe Club on Waikiki Beach
with Dr. West, the father of her college friend, Jo-Anne. Making
conversation, Nelson turned to Dr. West and said: “‘So, tell me
something interesting that happened this week,’” she recalls.
His response: “Well, today, Stanley had a baby. Now that’s something to write home about.”
The new mother was Stanley (later referred to by her middle name of Ann) Dunham, and the baby was Barack Hussein Obama.
“I penned the name on a napkin, and I did write home about it,” said
Nelson, knowing that her father, Stanley A. Czurles, director of the Art
Education Department at Buffalo State College, would be interested in
the “Stanley” connection.
She also remembers Dr. West mentioning that the baby’s father was the
first black student at the University of Hawaii and how taken he was by
the baby’s name.
“I remember Dr. West saying ‘Barack Hussein Obama, now that’s a
musical name,’” said Nelson, who grew up in Kenmore and went to Hawaii
in 1959 to be in Jo-Anne’s wedding party. When Nelson was offered a job
as a newspaper reporter and photographer at her friend’s wedding
reception, it led to her living in Hawaii for 47 years. She returned to
Kenmore in 2006.
As for the "Certificate of Live Birth" Obama has presented since
2008, Trump is simply lying when he claims that "anybody can get" one;
the state of Hawaii, in fact, only hands them out to people it can
certify were born there. (The lack of a signature is utterly
insignificant; many -- in fact, most -- states feature no signatures on
their birth certificates.)
As we
explained to Sean Hannity:
3. This birth certificate is the same birth certificate anyone born in Hawaii would present as proof of citizenship.
"Our Certificate of Live Birth is the standard form,
which was modeled after national standards that are acceptable by
federal agencies and organizations," Okubo said. "With that form, you
can get your passport or your soccer registration or your driver's
license."
4. The director of Hawaii’s Department of Health confirmed that Obama was born in Honolulu.
“There have been numerous requests for Sen. Barack
Hussein Obama’s official birth certificate. State law (Hawaii Revised
Statutes §338-18) prohibits the release of a certified birth certificate
to persons who do not have a tangible interest in the vital record.
“Therefore, I as Director of Health for the State of Hawaii, along
with the Registrar of Vital Statistics who has statutory authority to
oversee and maintain these type of vital records, have personally seen
and verified that the Hawaii State Department of Health has Sen. Obama’s
original birth certificate on record in accordance with state policies
and procedures.
“No state official, including Governor Linda Lingle, has ever
instructed that this vital record be handled in a manner different from
any other vital record in the possession of the State of Hawaii.”
The continued dispute that Hannity and Trump seem to think is so
significant is so important, in fact, is over the privacy-protected
medical records of Obama's birth -- what the Birthers are calling his
"long form birth certificate," but are in fact the private medical
records of his birth kept at the hospital, containing large amounts of
personal medical information about Obama's mother, including
gynecological data.
And as Hawaii officials have explained numerous times, these records are protected by privacy laws, and for perfectly sound reasons:
Hawai'i's disclosure law (Hawai'i Revised Statutes
338-18) states that "it shall be unlawful for any person to permit
inspection of, or to disclose information contained in vital statistics
records, or to copy or issue a copy of all or part on any such record
... "
The law further states that the Health Department "shall not permit
inspection of public health statistics records, or issue a certified
copy of any such record or part thereof, unless it is satisfied that the
applicant has a direct and tangible interest in the record."
Those who have "direct and tangible interest" are generally limited
to the person named in the record, the spouse, parent, descendant, or
personal representative, or by someone who is involved in marital,
parental or death litigation involving the named person's vital record
or other legal reason established by a court order, and various official
agency or organization representatives, including the state director of
health, according to the law.
This, ultimately, is where we get into the question of race. As we already asked of Trump:
Is a birth certificate acceptable to every known
authority for every other citizen of that state somehow unacceptable
proof of citizenship for presidential candidates?
Or do they believe that every candidate for president should have to
release for public review the private medical records, including
personal medical information about their late mothers, of their own
births?
Once again: If the answer to either of these is "no," then why are
they demanding it only of Barack Obama -- while simultaneously talking
about his five years spent in Indonesia?
Because that's when it becomes obvious that the problem isn't where Obama was born. It's his racial heritage.
And the utter mendaciousness of the attack -- not to mention the fact
that Fox is blithely providing Trump a platform for this nonsense --
reeks of a Swift Boat attack to me. That may be why we're seeing this.