The government of Nauru has labelled the ABC "an embarrassment to journalism" following a Four Corners report on the island's regional processing system, accusing the broadcaster of racism, political activism and insulting residents.
Notoriously sensitive to criticism, the Nauruan government asserted Australia was in fact the more violent nation and said the ABC should instead campaign for "no refugees to be allowed into such a violent society as Australia".
More News Videos
- Video duration
- 01:58
Turnbull rejects Nauru torture claims
- Video duration
- 01:32
Turnbull defends guns stance
- Video duration
- 01:17
The best of Penny Wong
- Video duration
- 02:02
Australia accused of torture
- Video duration
- 01:40
Turnbull battle ready
- Video duration
- 01:58
Controversial new Labor Senator
- Video duration
- 02:49
WhatsApp security concerns
Turnbull rejects Nauru torture claims
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull has rejected Amnesty Internationalâs claims that the treatment of refugees on Nauru amounts to deliberate and systematic torture. Vision courtesy ABC News 24.
The Four Corners program was informed by a major Amnesty International report, released on Monday night, that claimed Australia's regional processing regime on Nauru amounted to the intentional torture of refugees.
Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull strongly denied the accusation on Tuesday. "I reject that claim totally. It is absolutely false. The Australian government's commitment is compassionate and it's strong," he told ABC radio.
In its statement, the Republic of Nauru's "media and public information" unit claimed the children who appeared in the program were "coached" and the interview process "stage-managed". Despite this, "viewers could clearly see that the refugees featured were well dressed, well-groomed and healthy", the statement said.
No children were in detention on Nauru, the government said. This is technically true because the processing facility is designated as an "open centre" and asylum seekers are free to move around the 21 square kilometre island. The government said children generally lived with their families in safe accommodation close to shops, and that Nauru was less violent than Australia.
"There are fights in Australian schools on a daily basis and there is crime in Australia. The Australian news shows acts of crime each night that are far more violent that anything Nauru has experienced," the statement said.
"So on this basis, Four Corners should be campaigning for no refugees to be allowed into such a violent society as Australia. Clearly they would not advocate this because it would – in context – be incorrect, yet they are willing to falsely portray Nauru as an unsafe nation, which it is not."
The program also used footage of a now-defunct hospital and failed to mention the "new $27 million state-of-the-art medical facility to which refugees have unrestricted and free access" or the newly-constructed school, the Nauruan government said.
"Last night's Four Corners program on the ABC was yet another example of the ABC's biased political propaganda and lies, and was an insult to the people of Nauru," the statement said. "This report was an embarrassment to journalism. From start to finish it was denigrating, racist, false and pure political activism."
In a statement, the ABC said it stands by the Four Corners report and rejects Nauru's claims.
"It was an important story of obvious public interest," the statement said. The ABC also noted interviews with children were conducted remotely because Nauru "routinely refuses journalists access to report on offshore processing".
The Australian news shows acts of crime each night that are far more violent that anything Nauru has experienced
Nauru regularly accuses its critics of following a political agenda and doing the bidding of advocates. It routinely refuses access to the regional processing centre and denies journalists visas to Nauru, but in a note penned in August, President Baron Waqa said media outlets should not be surprised.
"After their dishonest campaign against us, they expect us to open our arms and allow them to visit and create more trouble within our borders!" he wrote.
For the record, #4Corners requested an IV with @PeterDutton_MP. He would only come on live. We explained that we don't do live IVs. #auspol
— Sally Neighbour (@neighbour_s) October 17, 2016
One of the main arguments of the Amnesty International report was that Australia, rather than Nauru, was primarily responsible for the conditions inside the regional processing centre and the systemic problems in health, education and justice faced by asylum seekers and refugees on the island.
Mr Turnbull acknowledged there were sad stories on Nauru but indicated the government would not be dissuaded from its harsh policies to deter boat people. "There are 1200 people … from whom we can never hear because they drowned at sea [under Labor's policy settings]," he told ABC radio.
Under questioning at a Senate estimates hearing on Monday night, Department of Immigration and Border Protection secretary Michael Pezzullo also denied Amnesty International's allegations.
"I refute categorically, both on behalf of my own department, and by way of explaining government policy in this regard, that it's not the Australian government's position, more the position of this department, that we flout any laws, international or otherwise," he said.
"As to the notion, inference or implication that we use torture as some sort of instrument of state policy, I personally find it to be offensive but, in any event, what I find to be offensive is not relevant. It's objectively in our view not true."
365 comments
Comment are now closed