Tuesday, June 01, 2004
Off A Cliff
I don't wish to give the impression that this blog is overly concerned with ripping the piss out of the Respect Unity Coalition, and its leading lights George Galloway and the SWP. If it was, it would be a short lived blog, 'cos there will be a bit fall out from within the Respect camp come June 11th when their election results come puffing and wheezing in.
However, I thought I would reproduce below a post written By Paul Flewers, which originally appears on the UK Left Network which I think hits the nail on the head on why today's opportunism becomes tomorrow's recriminations.
I've had to reproduce Paul Flewer's post rather than just posting a link to it because the UK Left Network archiver is closed to non-members. A quick disclaimer - Paul is not, never has been and will never be a member of the SPGB. The disclaimer is for Paul's benefit, not ours.
From: "paul_f_rh"
Date: Tue Jun 1, 2004 1:57 pm
Subject: Re: [UK Left Network] lindsay on tour
"I find that Respect's touting after the Muslim vote very worrying.
Chasing after a religious group's vote, as an undifferentiated mass,
is quite alien to socialist thinking. It contradicts the essence of
class politics, that a person's class position and attitude is the
key factor. It must also mean orienting to the more conservative and
backward elements, as the more modern-thinking people holding
religious beliefs usually do not see those beliefs as the determining
factor in their identity and in their lives.
If we look at the left and Muslims, who are we most likely to attract
to our ranks? The Muslims who are starting to question the tenets of
the mosque and mullahs, who are not particularly observant of Islamic
norms (and who may like the occasional pint or pork banger), and are
largely secular in their day-to-day life -- or the devout types
utterly convinced of the rightness of the Quran and their imam, and
who are extremely observant of Islamic norms, and who like the idea
of Islamic states?
So what does Respect do? In South London, it leaves two places vacant
on its committee to be filled by South London Mosque, thereby
allowing religious affiliation to be the determining factor, and
opening up the committee to infiltration from reactionary religious
elements.
In East London, the local Respect branch tags onto a Muslim march --
a church parade to be precise, marking the birth of Mohammed. Whether
the Respect folk chanted 'Allah Akhbar' as some leftists did in
Teheran in 1979, I do not know.
A Respect flyer aimed at Muslims emphasises that Galloway is a tee-
totaller.
Sheer opportunism, every bit of it. The whole orientation towards
Muslims is based on a momentary convergence between them and the left
over the war in Iraq. It will evaporate as soon as the crisis in Iraq
settles down.
It is acceptable to work with religious organisations in single-issue
campaigns and organising for demonstrations. An intervention in an
election, where one has an extensive political programme and a clear
political vision, is quite different. Lash-ups with religious
organisations in this sort of situation lead directly to confusion,
opportunism and the downplaying of important political tenets.
Say what you like about Tony Cliff, but he knew enough about
organised religion not to get into this sort of pickle.
Paul F"
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
0 comments:
Post a Comment