Conjunctivitis |
Virchow et al. (2011)[73] | Observational | 1009 | Adults | study to assess extra burden associated with ocular symptoms | Ocular symptoms reduces quality of life and work productivity |
Bozkurt et al. (2010)[74] | Prospective ENTexamination in children with VKC | 26 males 1 female | 12±4.4 | AR prevalence in children with VKC | 37% of children with VKC suffer from AR. Median IgE in AR +ve was 262.5 Ku/L vs 40.2 in non- AR Patients with VKC should see an ophthalmologist and an allergist |
Ibanez et al. (2010)[75] | Multicentre study | 1275 recruited from 271 centres | 6-12 | AR (60.7% seasonal and 39.3% perennial) conjunctivitis co-morbidities | Persistent/Severe AR has more co-morbidities. The most frequent is conjunctivitis (53%) |
Bertelesen et al. (2010)[76] | Parental interviews of 1019 cohort | 254 with rhinitis (=25%) | Children | Prevalence of rhinitis co-morbidities | 87.4% had at least one rhinitis co-morbidity. Conjunctivitis was present in 75.6% (11.8% of them also had asthma & eczema) |
Kim et al. (2013)[77] | ISAAC Questionnaire (12 mo evaluation) | 615 | 3-6 | Prevalence of rhinitis in children with conjunctivitis and conjunctivitis in children with rhinitis | Prevalence of rhinitis in children with conjunctivitis was 64.8%. Prevalence of conjunctivitis in children with rhinitis was 23.6% |
Williams et al. (2013)[90] | Questionnaire and direct question | 187 | Adults | To identify the incidence of allergic conjunctivitis in patients with allergic rhinitis | 55% of patients with AR were identified as having AC by direct questioning and the use of the TOSS questionnaire. A further 41% were identifiable by asking additional questions and performing therapeutic challenge with olopadatine |
Otitis media with effusion |
Umapathy et al. (2007)[78] | Questionnaire | 332 | Primary school children | To evaluate the association between symptoms suggestive of otitis media with effusion (OME), rhinitis and asthma in an unselected population of primary school children | 32.8% OME 36.6% Rhinitis 24% asthma |
Ibanez et al. (2013)[79] | Multi centre prospective | 1275 271 centres | 6-12 | Evaluation of ear co-morbidities in AR | 23.8% of AR had OME; 17.3% of AR had adenoidal hypertrophy |
Singh et al. (2011)[80] | Prospective | 30 patients 20 controls | Adults | Audiological and ontological status in AR | All patients had sensorineural hearing loss >high frequency & otoacoustic emission abnormalities |
Bozkurt et al. (2010)[74] | Prospective | 26 males 1 female | 12.1±4.4 | Prevalence of Eustachian tube dysfunction (ETD) in VKC and AR | Patients with AR and VKC have 3x more abnormal tympanograms and suffer from ETD more than controls |
Depression/ADHD/ Altered sleeping patterns/anxiety in families |
Chen et al. (2013)[81] | Nationwide Prospective | 1673 | 12-15 | Association AR and depression after 10 y FU | Severe depression 2.5% vs 1.2% Any other depression 4.9% vs 2.8% |
Tsai et al. (2011)[82] | Nationwide on Taiwan National Health Research Database | 226 550 | <18 | Prevalence & risk of ADH in AR children | Increased ADH rate P<.001 (eczema & asthma do not carry the same risk) |
Kalpakliglu et al. (2009)[83] | Observational study on sleeping symptoms | 48 | Adults | Prevalence of OSA in AR vs NAR | OSA 36% in AR vs 83% in NAR (OSA OR in NAR 6.4). AR & NAR subjects were snorers |
Emin et al. (2009)[84] | Prospective | 82 vs 70 mothers of AR | 7-15 | Anxiety parameters scores in mothers of AR children vs controls | Anxiety scores significantly higher in mothers with AR children P<.02 |
Lavigne et al. (2013)[85] | Prospective for 12/wk | 34 AR 21 NAR | Adults | Effects of mometasone on sleep parameters & upper airway inflammation on biopsies | Significant improvement on sleeping parameters &reduction of eosinophils in AR only |
Messias et al. (2010)[86] | National co-morbidity survey | 5692 | Adults | Association of seasonal allergie with suicidal ideation | Significant association (OR 1.27) but not with suicide attempts |
Vuurman et al. (2014)[87] | Double blind randomized cross-over following nasal provocation with pollen extract and during the season | 19 (9 females/10 men) | Adults | Effect of untreated AR on driving performance compared with treated AR | Magnitude of impairment (evaluated on standard deviation of lateral position of performance) comparable to that seen driving with 0.03% alcohol. Rx with anti H1 or steroids reduces the effects on driving performance |
Rhinosinusitis/anosmia |
Ibanez et al. (2013)[79] | Multi centre prospective | 1275 271 centres | Children | Co-morbidities in children with AR | 26.1% of AR had rhinosinusitis |
Guss et al. (2009)[88] | Prospective | 51 (80% allergic) | Adults | Investigate the olfactory function in AR (with Smell Identification Test and also CT scan) | 50% of AR with normal CT scored in the 30th percentile on olfactory test. 50% of allergic patients had hyposmia |
Asthma |
Shaaban et al. (2008)[55] | Longitudinal population based study | 6461 | Adults | Development of new asthma | RR of asthma development: 1.63 atopy, 2.71 NAR, 3.53 AR |
Leynaret et al. (2004)[53] | Cross sectional study | 3000 (1500 male and 1500 female) | Young adults | Identification of sensitization, BHR, asthma | 74%-81% had asthma, BHR (OR 3.02) and asthma (OR 6.63) more frequent in rhinitics. Asthma risk 2% without rhinitis, 6.7% with pollen rhinitis, 11.9% with animal rhinitis, 18.8% both. Strong association between asthma and rhinitis not fully explained by atopy |
Settipane et al. (2000)[89] | Questionnaire | 1601 | Adults | Asthma and rhinitis/AR improvement associated with a resolution of asthma symptoms | Asthma and rhinitis present in 85.7% of asthmatics, asthma in 21.3% of rhinitics. In 44.8% of those with both rhinitis appeared first, in 20.7% at the same time |
Magnan et al. (2008)[91] | Cross sectional French study, Questionnaire | 14 703 | Adults | Questionnaire in asthma patients | 81% of asthma patients treated for rhinitis. Severity of rhinitis and of asthma corresponded. AR associated with more severe asthma, more difficult to control asthma and substantial quality of life impairment |
Ciprandi et al. (2011)[92] | Prospective | 89 AR 940 controls | Adults | Follow up of patients with AR every 2 y for 8 y to investigate spirometric abnormalities /BHR | 34/89 AR patients develop BHR after 8 y Sensitization for mite, birch, parietaria as well as rhinitis duration are risk factors |
Yilmaz et al. (2014)[93] | Prospective | 57 | Children with asthma ex'ion | Evaluate the risk factors for recovery of lung function tests after moderate/severe asthma exacerbation | AR is a significant factor affecting the recovery time of pulmonary function tests and impacts asthma management |
Ibanez et al. (2013)[79] | Prospective multicentre | 1275 | Children From 271 centres | Evaluation of comorbidities for AR in a Spanish population | 49.5% co-morbidity with asthma: allergy is a systemic disease |
Navarro et al. (2008)[94] | Epidemiologic prospective Multi centre | 942 with asthma | Mean age 35.5 63% female | Investigate the link between the upper and lower airways | 89.5% had AR Correlation between severity of rhinitis and asthma (P<.001) |
de Andrade et al. (2008)[95] | Cross sectional study using ISAAC questionnaire | 3083 students (47.3% males) | 13-14 y old, 47.3% male | Evaluation of Asthma and AR co-morbidity | Comorbidity of asthma and rhinitis symptoms was 8.4% Among asthmatic adolescents, AR symptoms were reported in 46.5% |
Ko et al. (2010)[96] | Cross sectional on questionnaire | 600 (with asthma) | 267 male 333 female | Evaluation of prevalence of AR in asthma | 77% of asthmatic had rhinitis in the past 12 mo (of whom 96% were previously diagnosed with AR) Patients with asthma and rhinitis: nasal steroid usage (49%) had <ED visits 13% vs 25%) and <hospitalization for asthma (5% vs 13%) |
Eriksson et al. (2011)[97] | Postal Questionnaire on respiratory health | 18 087 (62% responded) | Adults | Evaluation between rhinitis phenotypes and symptoms presentation and risk factor patterns in asthma | Prevalence of asthma in AR was 19.8% Prevalence of AR in asthma was 63.9% Asthma with chronic rhinitis had more asthma symptoms and bronchitis (P<.01) FH of allergy has a higher OR for asthma and AR than for asthma and CRS |
Bertelasan R | Parental interviews | 254 | Children with rhinitis | Evaluation of co morbidities of rhinitis | 87.4% had at least one allergy related co-morbidity Children with rhinitis and allergic sensitization (72.8%) had >BHR, severe BHR (7.5% vs 5.8%) and conjuntivitis |
Valero et al. (2009)[98] | Cross sectional international population study based on questionnaire | 3225 (one +ve skin test) | 10-50 53% Male | Evaluation on the link between AR, asthma and skin test sensitization | Asthma was present in 49% of AR Asthma severity was associated with longer time since the onset and allergic rhinitis severity. Patients with asthma have higher number of allergen sensitization and sensitization intensity than those without asthma (P<.01) |
Kim et al. (2013)[77] | Cross sectional Study using ISAAC questionnaire | 615 | Children (306) | Evaluation of allergic co-morbidities in pre-school children | Prevalence of AR in children with asthma was 64.3% Prevalence of asthma in children with R was 21.6% |
Oral allergy syndrome/food pollen syndrome/food allergy |
Westman et al. (2012)[99] | Prospective | 2024 | Children IgE tested (inhalants) at 4 and 8 y | Natural course of AR and co-morbidities in children | Increase AR from 5% to 14% from 4 to 8 y; decrease of NAR from 8% to 6%. 4 y sensitized but not allergic had AR at 8 y in 56% of cases 25% of 8 y with AR has also OAS |
Caliskaner et al. (2011)[100] | Prospective | 111 78 men 33 women | Adults | Clinical parameters comparison between AR with OAS and without | OAS >in women (P=.01) (OR M/F3.80). OAS relates to nasal itching (P<.05). OAS >IgE (ns) Regression analysis: association with asthma, age and severity of nasal symptom score |
Sahin-yilmaz et al. (2010)[101] | Retrospective | 283 | | Peanut, shrimp and milk IgE and rhinitis | 23.4% peanut IgE +ve and 22.2% IgE+ shrimp in inhalant +patients Peanut and shrimp were the >common sensitivities in rhinitis patients |
Laryngeal symptoms |
Verguts MM et al. (2011)[102] | Observational prospective | 6 control 6 AR adult singers | 4 females 2 men | Effects of nasal provocation with pollen extracts and during the HF on Laryngeal parameters | Rapid induction of laryngeal irritation/globus (no objective laryngeal changes on provocation and during the season) |
Rhinitis/atopic disease and migraine |
Munoz-Jarena et al. (2011)[103] | Retrospective study FU for 6 mo | 216 | 5-15 | Prevalence of atopy in children with migraine | Prevalence of rhinoconjunctivitis, asthma and atopic dermatitis are statistically significant in children with migraine (OR 7.3; P<.01 for rhinoconjunctivitis; OR 4.69: P<.01 for asthma; OR 7.1; P<.01 for atopic dermatitis |