A | B | C | D | E | F | G | H | I | J | K | L | M | N | O | P | Q | R | S | T | U | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
1 | Program name | Description of program | Have we recommended one or more grants to support this program? | If we haven't recommended grants to support this program, why not? | Current status | |||||||||||||||||
2 | Cash transfers | Giving cash grants to poor people in low-income countries. (More) | Yes, ongoing support to top charity GiveDirectly (more). We are not prioritizing further grants due to relatively low cost-effectiveness. | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
3 | Combined protocol community-based management of acute malnutrition | Identifying and treating uncomplicated cases of both severe acute malnutrition and moderate acute malnutrition on an outpatient basis. (More) | Yes, we recommended grants to ALIMA in January 2021 (more) and May 2021 (to be published). | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
4 | Conditional cash transfers to increase infant vaccination as run by New Incentives | Providing cash transfers to caregivers who bring their infants to receive routine vaccinations, along with outreach to encourage vaccination and efforts to ensure vaccines are available in clinics. (More on the program; more on the evidence) | Yes, ongoing support to top charity New Incentives (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
5 | Deworming (mass drug administration targeting schistosomiasis and/or soil-transmitted helminths) | Treating all school-aged children with anti-parasitic drugs in areas at risk for schistosomiasis and/or soil-transmitted helminths once or twice per year. (More) | Yes, ongoing support to top charities Evidence Action's Deworm the World Initiative (more), SCI Foundation (more), Sightsavers' deworming program (more), and the END Fund's deworming program (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
6 | Iron fortification | Mass fortification of staple foods, such as wheat flour, to reduce iron deficiency. (More) | Yes, we recommended a grant to Fortify Health in 2019 (more) and 2018 (more). We recognized Food Fortification Initiative (more) and Project Healthy Children (more) as GiveWell standout charities before GiveWell retired that designation. | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
7 | Iron supplementation for school-age children | Distributing iron supplements to school-age children to prevent anemia. (More) | Yes, we recommended grants to Evidence Action Beta (now called Evidence Action Accelerator) in December 2018 (more) and March 2018 (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
8 | Mass distribution of long-lasting insecticide-treated nets | Giving long-lasting insecticide-treated nets (LLINs) to everyone in areas at risk of malaria, generally every three years. (More) | Yes, ongoing support to top charity Against Malaria Foundation (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
9 | Seasonal malaria chemoprevention | Giving children under the age of 5 courses of malaria treatment monthly during the annual period of highest malaria transmission. (More) | Yes, ongoing support to top charity Malaria Consortium (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
10 | Syphilis screening and treatment during pregnancy | Providing rapid point-of-care testing and treatment of syphilis during pregnancy to prevent the complications of syphilis infection for the child and mother. (More) | Yes, we recommended a grant to Evidence Action in 2020 (more). | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
11 | Vitamin A supplementation | Treating all children aged approximately 6-months to 5-years in areas at high-risk for vitamin A deficiency with high-dose vitamin A supplements two or three times per year. (More) | Yes, ongoing support to top charity Helen Keller International's Vitamin A supplementation program (more) | - | Actively supporting | |||||||||||||||||
12 | Breastfeeding promotion | Encouraging mothers to increase breastfeeding exclusivity and duration. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to conduct additional research to better understand its evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
13 | Chlorhexidine for umbilical cord care | Applying chlorhexidine, a widely-used topical antiseptic, to the newborn umbilical cord stump after birth to prevent infection and resulting neonatal death. (More) | No | This program appears promising in some circumstances and we plan to conduct additional research. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
14 | Community-based intervention packages to reduce maternal and neonatal mortality | Providing various interventions to women during and after pregnancy and to newborns via community outreach workers, for example keeping newborns warm immediately after birth, promoting and assisting with breastfeeding, providing vitamin K to newborns, and referring sick infants to clinics. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to conduct additional research to better understand the evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of specific interventions within this category. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
15 | Eyeglasses to improve workers' manual dexterity | Providing free or subsidized eyeglasses to workers whose productivity depends on their manual dexterity. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to continue our investigation. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
16 | Intensive breastfeeding promotion as run by Alive & Thrive | Delivering a package of infant and young child feeding interventions focused on breastfeeding promotion and support, including face-to-face counseling, community mobilization, and mass media communications. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to conduct additional research to better understand its evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
17 | Intermittent preventive treatment in infants (IPTi) for malaria | Providing preventive antimalarial medicine to children aged 1-15 months at routine vaccination visits. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We are actively seeking potential funding opportunities, including by reaching out to organizations who may be positioned to work on scale up of the program. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
18 | Mass distribution of azithromycin to reduce child mortality | Providing an antibiotic to all children in a certain age range once or twice per year. (More) | No | Our review of this program found that the program may be within the range of cost-effectiveness of programs we would consider directing funding to. We plan to do more work to understand whether there are implementation opportunities and whether these mitigate risks of antimicrobial resistance. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
19 | Probiotic supplementation for preterm newborns | Providing probiotic supplements to low-birth-weight or preterm newborns to prevent necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC) and sepsis. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to do more work to understand whether there are implementation opportunities. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
20 | Sayana® Press | Providing an injectable contraceptive in a prefilled single-use package, intended to be easy for community health workers or recipients themselves to administer. (More) | No | This program appears promising, and we plan to conduct additional research. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
21 | SMS reminders for immunization | Sending Short Message Service (SMS) messages to caregivers' cell phones to remind them of young children's upcoming vaccination dates. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We previously recommended grants to Charity Science Health. (More) | See our review of this program and discussion of our exit grant to Charity Science Health. We plan to conduct additional research to better understand the evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
22 | Surgery to repair obstetric fistula | Providing surgery to repair abnormal openings between the vagina and the bladder or rectum that cause leakage of urine and/or feces. (More) | No | This program appears promising. We plan to learn more about several outstanding questions about fistula surgery programs. See our review of this program. | Further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
23 | Targeted azithromycin distribution for children being discharged from the hospital | Providing a course of antibiotics at discharge from the hospital to children with recent severe illness, in order to reduce mortality and morbidity. | No | We have deprioritized due to lack of evidence but expect new evidence to be available in the future. See our short note on this program. | Revisit in 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
24 | Attractive toxic sugar baits for malaria control | Reducing mosquito populations with mixtures of sugar and substances that are lethal to mosquitoes, in order to reduce malaria transmission. | No | We have deprioritized due to lack of evidence but expect new evidence to be available in the future. See our short note on this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
25 | Bridges to Prosperity | Building footbridges in rural areas in sub-Saharan Africa and Latin America to connect isolated households to schools, health clinics, and markets. (More) | No | We believe this program may be in the range of cost-effectiveness of programs we would consider directing funding to. However, we do not have sufficient evidence about effects in settings where Bridges to Prosperity plans to build in the near future. We plan to revisit once results from a large-scale randomized controlled trial in Rwanda are available. See our review of this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
26 | Community health promoters as run by Living Goods | Selling health and household goods door-to-door and providing basic health counseling. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We recognized Living Goods as a GiveWell standout charity before GiveWell retired that designation (more). | We are aware of an ongoing randomized controlled trial that measures the effect of Living Goods’ program at a larger scale. We plan to revisit this program once the results from the larger-scale trial are available. See our review of this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
27 | Community salt substitution | Replacement of normal table salt with a salt substitute, in which potassium chloride replaces a portion of the sodium chloride, for all members of a community (More) | No | Our best guess is that community salt substitution is not as cost-effective as programs we would consider directing funding to. We plan to revisit when the findings of the Salt Substitute and Stroke Study are published. See our review of this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
28 | Eave tubes to control malaria | Installing tubes with insecticide-treated netting into the space between the roof and walls of a house, to kill mosquitoes as they enter or exit. | No | We have deprioritized due to lack of evidence but expect new evidence to be available in the future. See our short note on this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
29 | Educate! Experience program | Mentoring students in their last two years of secondary school, with a focus on developing leadership, preparing to enter the workforce, and entrepreneurship skills. | No | We have deprioritized due to lack of evidence but expect new evidence to be available in the future. See our short note on this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
30 | Electronic partogram | Assisting health facilities to switch from paper-based to electronic partograms for tracking and managing care for women during labor. | No | We have deprioritized due to lack of evidence but expect new evidence to be available in the future. See our short note on this program | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
31 | HPV vaccination to prevent cervical cancer | Providing HPV vaccinations to girls aged 9 to 14, in order to prevent cervical cancer. (More) | No | After a limited investigation, we believe there are probably not substantial funding gaps in HPV vaccination as of 2020. As of 2020, demand for HPV vaccine doses exceeds supply, and we believe it will take several years for industry to substantially increase production of HPV vaccines. See our review of this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
32 | Post-discharge malaria chemoprevention (PMC) for children with severe anemia | Providing antimalarials to children who have been treated in hospitals for severe anemia, after they have been discharged. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program due to our impression that there will be limited funding opportunities. However, our understanding is that WHO may be considering guidance on PMC in the near future, which may open up funding opportunities. See our short note on this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
33 | Vouchers for water treatment | Offering vouchers for free bottles of chlorine treatment to disinfect drinking water. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program because we are currently prioritizing other water chlorination programs that we think have more immediate funding opportunities. We expect to revisit this program once we have investigated these other water chlorination programs. See our short note on this program. | Revisit after 2021 | |||||||||||||||||
34 | Antiretroviral therapy to treat HIV/AIDS | Treating people living with HIV with antiretroviral drugs on an ongoing basis to reduce illness and extend life. (More) | No | Our best guess is that this program is below the level of cost-effectiveness of programs that we would consider directing funding to. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
35 | Artemisia tea | Treating malaria with a tea made from Artemisia plants. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
36 | Aspirin for cardiovascular disease prevention | Providing aspirin to individuals at risk of cardiovascular disease in order to reduce the likelihood of cardiovascular events, such as heart attack and stroke. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program and our impression that giving opportunities will be challenging to identify. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
37 | Bracelets for immunization | Providing infants with bracelets of different colors indicating immunization status as a strategy for increasing immunization rates through social signaling. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program and evidence of its effectiveness in settings outside of Sierra Leone. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
38 | Cataract surgery | Conducting surgery to remedy cataracts (clouding of the lens of the eye which prevents clear vision) involving removal of the eye's natural lens, followed by replacement with an artificial intraocular lens. (More) | No | Based on conversations with several cataract surgery charities, we have been unable to identify opportunities where there is compelling evidence that activities by charities lead to an increase in surgeries and think this information would be challenging to collect. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
39 | Clean cookstoves | Providing or selling cookstoves that are designed to reduce indoor air pollution, relative to open fires fueled by biomass fuels such as firewood or dung. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
40 | Community distribution of polypill for cardiovascular disease prevention | Distribution of polypill, a pill containing fixed doses of several drugs intended to reduce the risk of cardiovascular disease. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
41 | Community-based antibiotic delivery for possible serious bacterial infection (PSBI) management | Providing home-based antibiotics to treat infections in neonates when hospital referrals aren't possible. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program given the lack of evidence on community-based antibiotic delivery by itself. We may revisit if we identify more evidence available on the effects of PSBI management using community-based antibiotic delivery alone. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
42 | Conditional subsidies for seasonal labor migration in northern Bangladesh | Providing cash transfers or limited-liability interest-free loans to support seasonal labor migration in northern Bangladesh. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We supported Evidence Action's No Lean Season program in 2014-2019 (more). Subsequent evidence led to deprioritizing this program. | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness of the program. Our review of this program mentions a 2018 randomized controlled trial. As of December 2020, to our knowledge, results from the 2018 RCT are not yet public. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
43 | Condom promotion and distribution to prevent HIV/AIDS | Encouraging the use of condoms through education, counseling and advertising. and/or providing condoms for free or at highly subsidized prices. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
44 | Cryptococcal antigen testing for people living with HIV | Diagnosing and treating a fungal infection that can cause death, particularly among people living with HIV. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there is a lack of cost-effective room for more funding. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
45 | Diagnosis and treatment for chronic pulmonary aspergillosis | Diagnosing and treating a fungal infection that can cause death, particularly among people who have underlying structural lung disease. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there is limited evidence of its effectiveness in low-resource settings and implementation is challenging in these settings. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
46 | Diagnosis and treatment for disseminated histoplasmosis | Diagnosing and treating a fungal infection that can cause death, particularly among people living with HIV. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program and room for more funding. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
47 | Diagnosis and treatment for pneumocystis pneumonia | Diagnosing and treating a fungal infection that can cause death, particularly among people living with HIV. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the evidence of effectiveness and cost-effectiveness for the program. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
48 | Distribution of eyeglasses to improve academic performance | Providing free or subsidized corrective eyeglasses to students with poor vision to improve academic performance. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness. We are prioritizing work on eyeglasses to improve workers' manual dexterity (listed separately) more highly because we believe that the evidence for effectiveness is stronger for that program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
49 | Early childhood psychosocial stimulation | Training parents to support their child's development through play and other activities, in order to develop children's cognitive and language skills. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of evidence of effectiveness for and cost-effectiveness of the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
50 | Education in developing countries | A wide range of interventions aimed at improving education in developing countries. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on these programs based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for programs of this type. See our review of this category of programs. We may consider individual education interventions in the future. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
51 | Eggs for complementary feeding | Distributing chicken eggs to families to feed to infants in conjunction with breast milk to ensure that the infants receive adequate nutrition. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
52 | Immunization to prevent meningitis A | Conducting meningitis A immunization campaigns, in order to prevent deaths and cases of brain damage and hearing loss. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of room for more funding for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
53 | Integrated community case management | Training community health workers and providing them with the supplies to diagnose and treat uncomplicated cases of pneumonia with antibiotics, malaria with antimalarial drugs, and diarrhea with oral rehydration salts and zinc. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
54 | Intermittent preventive treatment of malaria during pregnancy | Providing antimalarial drugs to pregnant women who are at-risk of malaria in their second and third trimesters. (More) | No | Our review of this program found low cost-effectiveness and weak evidence of effectiveness for this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
55 | Interventions to promote handwashing | Promoting handwashing through education and/or provision of materials, such as soap. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of evidence of effectiveness for and cost-effectiveness of the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
56 | Kangaroo mother care (KMC) | Providing a low-cost alternative to conventional neonatal intensive care for low birth weight infants during their stay at a healthcare facility. (More) | No | After a limited investigation, our impression is that implementation challenges are likely to limit effectiveness of and funding opportunities for this program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
57 | Lymphoedema management to prevent acute adenolymphangitis in podoconiosis | Educating people with podoconiosis about disease management practices and providing them with supplies, such as compression bandages and shoes, with the intention of reducing the incidence of acute adenolymphangitis. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
58 | Mass media to promote behavior change as run by Development Media International | Encouraging people to adopt improved health practices though radio and television programming. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We made a grant to Development Media International in 2020 as part of our grantmaking in response to COVID-19 (more). We recognized Development Media International as a GiveWell standout charity before GiveWell retired that designation (more). | We view this program as having limited evidence of effectiveness, based on a randomized controlled trial of DMI's child mortality programs. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
59 | Microfinance | Providing loans and other financial services (such as savings accounts or insurance) to poor individuals. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. Small Enterprise Foundation was a GiveWell standout charity in 2011 (more). | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
60 | Non-pneumatic anti-shock garments | Using a compression device to stabilize women with postpartum hemorrhage until they are able to receive treatment. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our shallow assessment of room for more funding. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
61 | Oral ivermectin mass drug administration for scabies control | Distributing the oral antiparasitic drug ivermectin to almost all members of a scabies-affected community with the intention of reducing the prevalence of scabies mites | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of its cost-effectiveness and room for more funding. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
62 | Oral Pre-exposure Prophylaxis (PrEP) for HIV | Providing antiretroviral drugs to HIV-negative individuals, in order to prevent HIV acquisition. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
63 | Oral Rehydration Solution | Treating dehydration due to diarrhea with glucose, sodium, and other minerals dissolved in water. (More) | No | Our best guess is that this program is less cost-effective than other programs we would consider directing funding to, though it's possible additional work could change our view. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
64 | Precision Agriculture for Development (PAD) | Providing locally-customized agricultural advice to farmers through their mobile phones. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We recognized PAD as a GiveWell standout charity before GiveWell retired that designation (more). | Our best guess is that this program is below the range of cost-effectiveness of programs we would consider directing funding to and evidence for its effectiveness is limited, though it's possible additional work could change our view. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
65 | Probiotics for gestational diabetes | Providing probiotics to pregnant women with gestational diabetes to improve maternal and neonatal health. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there is limited evidence on its effectiveness. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
66 | Prophylactic antibiotics to reduce infections from caesarean sections | Providing prophylactic antibiotics to women delivering via caesarean section to prevent morbidity and mortality related to maternal peripartum infections. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there will be limited funding opportunities. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
67 | Rapid diagnostic tests and drug therapy for visceral leishmaniasis in East Africa | Providing screening and treatment for a tropical disease that is prevalent in East Africa. | No | We have deprioritized further work based on limited room for more funding. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
68 | Selenium supplementation for neonatal sepsis prevention | Providing selenium supplements to very low birthweight infants in order to prevent sepsis. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there is limited evidence on its effectiveness. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
69 | Soft skills certification | Providing workers with certifications for non-cognitive skills, including traits such as trustworthiness and willingness to help others, in order to increase workers’ earnings by improving their ability to signal soft skills to potential employers. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the evidence of effectiveness for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
70 | Supplementary immunization activities to prevent measles | Identifying gaps in measles vaccination coverage, including through vaccine coverage surveys or case surveillance, and conducting measles immunization campaigns in at-risk areas. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of lack of cost-effective room for more funding for the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
71 | Universal low-dose aspirin during pregnancy | Distributing low-dose aspirin to all pregnant women to reduce the likelihood of preeclampsia. | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our impression that there will be limited funding opportunities. See our short note on this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
72 | Voluntary medical male circumcision | Providing surgery to remove the prepuce (foreskin) of the penis, in order to reduce HIV and HPV (which can lead to cervical cancer) transmission. (More) | No | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on low estimated cost-effectiveness. See our review of this program. | No further work planned | |||||||||||||||||
73 | Zusha! road safety campaign | Placing stickers in public service vehicles that encourage passengers to speak up and urge drivers to drive more safely. (More) | This is not a program we are actively supporting. We recommended a grant to Zusha! in 2017 (more). We recognized Zusha! as a GiveWell standout charity before GiveWell retired that designation (more). | We have deprioritized further work on this program based on our assessment of the cost-effectiveness of the program. See our review of this program. | No further work planned |