Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores
r/Music icon
r/Music icon

r/Music

members
online







Bands with an established genre that made one "different" album? • Bands with an established genre that made one "different" album?
discussion

A couple examples:

Motley Crue - Generation Swine (had more of an industrial/punk sound)

Metallica - St Anger (no guitar solos, raw gritty sound, and of course the world's most criticized snare drum)

With both of those albums, they tried experimenting with a different style, which polarized their fans. Personally, I really like both of those albums. I don't know why, but I find myself drawn to the music when the band tries something different, even if it wasn't well received by fans/critics.

I'm trying to think of more examples, but of course when I want to make this post, I'm drawing a blank. Here's a couple more though:

Powerman 5000 - Destroy What You Enjoy (almost completely abandoned the industrial sound in favor of punk)

Linkin Park - One More Light (more pop, less rock)

(yes I know that Linkin Park is known for trying out different genres, but that album was the most drastic change that polarized fans at the time)

So, what are some other bands that made "that" album that really threw off their fans because they didn't like the change or experimentation?