Why we commemorate D-Day 80 years on

When I look back as a historian, like most of my peers, I can see that the odds on D-Day overwhelmingly favoured allied success: the Americans and British deployed an awesome superiority of planes, tanks, warships and men.

Many of the “Germans” manning the coastal defences were, in reality, Poles, Russians and Ukrainians dressed in Wehrmacht uniform.

Had it not been for the ironclad determination of the US chiefs of staff, there would have been no D-Day until 1945.

Steven Spielberg’s terrific D-Day movie Saving Private Ryan depicts Hitler’s forces deploying their biggest Panzers against American troops, yet during the first battles ashore, the only German tanks then on the western flank were recycled French and Czech models.

So successful were allied deception operations – much more influential than the air attacks on French railways – that into July Hitler kept some of his best formations in the Pas de Calais, about 300 kilometres north, awaiting a second invasion.

But all this wasn’t known back then to allied warlords and their soldiers, so fearful of the huge prospective consequences of failure.

“Why are we trying to do this?” cried Winston Churchill in a February 1944 spasm of alarm about the planned invasion, which caused him momentarily to propose an alternative landing in Portugal.

I have always believed that, had it not been for the ironclad determination of the US chiefs of staff, there would have been no D-Day until 1945.

As it was, minutes after midnight on June 6, one British and two American airborne divisions began to jump into Normandy, and almost immediately to fight.

Paratrooper James Byrom spoke French and was thus tasked by comrades to knock on the front door of the first house they reached: “At the sight of the motherly, middle-aged peasant, the gulf of the years disappeared and I might have been back in 1939, an English tourist on a walking tour dropping in to ask for a glass of cider and some camembert: ‘Excusez-nous, Madame. Nous sommes les parachustistes Anglais faisant partie de Débarquement Allié.’

“There was a moment of scrutiny, then the woman folded me in her arms. The tears streamed down her face, and in between kisses, she was shouting for her husband, for lamps, for wine…We found ourselves – an evil-looking group of camouflaged cutthroats – surrounded and overwhelmed by the pent-up emotion of four years.”

‘Bloody Omaha’

Two hours after dawn the infantry stormed ashore, on five beaches across a 80 kilometre front. The American “Bloody Omaha,” where the invaders encountered the toughest resistance from Germans entrenched on bluffs above, still commands much of the popular attention, influenced by the aforesaid Spielberg portrayal.

But we should never forget that overall allied casualties on the day – including those on Omaha – proved to be only a fraction of what the planners had feared.

Though one National Guard unit, A Company of the 116th Infantry, lost 100 men, American dead in the first 24 hours totalled 1465, including losses to the 82nd and 101st Airborne.

The overall allied figure was around 3000 killed, about the same number of fatalities as allied bombs and shells inflicted upon French civilians on June 6.

The generals were naive about the inevitable grogginess of most of the tens of thousands who waded ashore, weakened by seasickness. Commando Finlay Campbell recalled that his legs continued to feel “wobbly” for two days.

French commando Robert Piage, 24, whose mother lived in the coastal town of Ouistreham, hurled himself into water that proved chest high, in his eagerness to lead.

He had advanced only 10 yards up the beach when a mortar bomb exploded, killing his closest mate and riddling Piage with fragments which he carried to his grave: “I began to cry. Not out of sorrow for myself, nor because of my wounds, but at the great joy that I felt at being back on French soil.”

Not for long: he slept that night in an English hospital.

One of the romantic legends of D-Day was created by a local French teenage girl, who moved around Sword beach attempting to succour the wounded, accompanied by wolf-whistles from the invaders around her.

She had bicycled from her home to fetch a swimsuit that she had carelessly left by the sea on the previous day. Her name was Jacqueline Noel, and she married a British soldier whom she met a few days later.

Her D-Day experience was shadowed by family tragedy, because her sister was killed by RAF bombs falling on nearby Caen.

She cherished a kaleidoscope of memories: “The sea with all the boats was something that you just can’t imagine if you have not seen it. It was boats, boats, boats and more boats, boats everywhere. If I had been a German, I would have looked at this, put my weapon down and said: ‘That’s it. Finished.’”

One of Hitler’s defenders who surrendered, indeed, said later: “At first I was rather depressed. I, an old soldier, was a prisoner after a few hours of invasion. But when I saw the matériel behind the enemy front, I could only say, ‘Old man, how lucky you have been!’”

Supreme event of World War II

Despite the carnage that seemed so terrible to those in its midst, the invasion had succeeded: a secure beachhead was established, and in the days and weeks that followed, far more men died than the 3000 who perished in the landings.

Our parents’ and grandparents’ generations viewed D-Day as the supreme event of World War II, and the struggle for northwest Europe as the decisive campaign.

My father, an eyewitness, sincerely believed that Britain won the war, with the Americans supplying the chewing-gum, the Russians somewhere in Eastern remoteness doing heaven-knew-what.

Modern historians, no longer nationalist fantasists, recognise that the Red Army did most of the dying and killing necessary to smash Hitler’s Wehrmacht.

They were sustained by American rations and equipment: the Russians marched to Berlin wearing US-made boots.

Yet, D-Day was assuredly the decisive military event of war in the West. Moreover, for the British people it represented the moment of redemption after suffering so much and enduring so many defeats and humiliations on the long road since the war began on September 3, 1939.

The Normandy landings constituted a supreme feat of organisation, planning, skills and courage.

We are right this week to commemorate the towering achievement, while the last handful of its survivors remain alive to share the memories.

Max Hastings is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist. His books include Overlord: D-Day and the Battle for Normandy.

Bloomberg Opinion