A Silent Voice

-

I hope you enjoyed the movie and I hope we will have an interesting/fun discussion.

Interesting questions

These questions can help you write your comment. Feel free to answer any, all or none of these questions.

• Do you have any experience with disabilities, depression or bullying yourself?

• What was your (least) favorite scene/arch?

• What is your (least) favorite character?

• What did you think of the pacing of the story?

• What is your opinion on the audio/music/visuals?

• Do you recognize the direction style of Naoko Yamada?

• If you have watched both, do you prefer the Japanese or English dub (or maybe the 'Silent' version)?

Spoilers

We have all now seen the movie but I understand that some of you also want to partially discuss the manga. If you do please tag any manga spoilers:

[A Silent Voice manga](/s "Shouko is deaf")

which becomes:

Details and links

Anime databases:

Legal watching:

• You can also buy the blu-ray

This was only the second time I was able to convince my parents to watch an anime with me. The first was Spirited Away with the entire family, and so naturally I knew this time I was in for a very different experience.

My mom was the only one willing to sit through it with me. I tried to warn her that it would be a heavy movie that dealt with some pretty serious topics, but I don't think she was really prepared for what she was about to see. She definitely still had some of that "animation is for kids bias", although I could tell she was trying to be open minded.

Anyway, here are some takeaways from the experience:

• First off, I just wanted to say I was really touched by the level of attention she gave it. Usually she only half pays attention to the movies we watch, but this time she stayed off her phone with eyes glued to the screen. I'm willing to guess part of it was because it's an incredible movie, but most of it was probably because she knew how much watching it with her meant to me.

• She's used to watching shows and movies in other languages, so we watched it subbed. I was very happy about this, not because I hate dubs or anything, but because it would have been really weird for me, having originally seen it subbed.

• As a teacher, she was absolutely horrified by all the bullying. Every time someone would make a cruel comment or obnoxiously mimic Shouko, she would breath in really sharply then look over at me in alarm. This continued for the entire span of the movie.

• She laughed a surprising amount, especially with Nagatsuka. She thought the kid was absolutely hilarious!

• She did not like Ueno, and kept asking how someone could be so cruel.

• She loves learning about different places and cultures, and so was fascinated by so many different things shown in the movie, from something as simple as the chalkboards in the classrooms to the more obvious stuff like the frequent bowing that occurred throughout.

• I had forgotten about the scene where Sahara jokes about checking Shouko's cup size, and got really scared for a second. Surprisingly, my mom thought this was so ridiculous that it came back around to being funny to her. For days after she would makes jokes about "us girls, just casually checking our cup sizes." I have to say, I agree with her on this one. I'm sorry to say, but as a girl myself, that is not something that ever happens. I'm just glad she found it funny instead of horribly offensive or something.

• I was frequently told throughout the movie how much all the characters need to get therapy, and I can't agree more.

• She was really shocked by all the almost casual suicide attempts and mentions in the movie. I thought I had warned her, but I don't think I did a good enough job conveying how dark it would get. And I didn't know this at the time, but a family member of a person she works with had committed suicide, and it had been really heavily weighing on her. Obviously this was not exactly the movie to take her mind off this. It was probably too much for her at one time, I still feel bad about that, but I hope that it at least helped her process her thoughts about the situation.

• In that vein, she really appreciated the overall "value your life" message of the movie, and how it condemned suicide, but did so without shaming the victims.

• After the movie, we had a long, open discussion about depression and suicide, which was meaningful to me, and I could tell how much it meant to her as well.

Overall, it was an incredibly valuable experience for both of us, and I hope to do it again, albeit with a lighter movie.

Edit: You people seem to be on a mission to emotionally destroy my mother with all these depressing movie recommendations, but I can’t say I’m not on board with it.

I watched the movie yesterday and thought it was a Masterpiece. Meaning, yes, I thought it was better than Kimi No Na Wa.

Onto the topic, if you're planning to watch the movie, please read Volume One of the manga (Chapter 1-5 + Sidestory) first, as I did.

Since about 30%-50% of Volume One was either cut or put into a Montage. Character development wasn't much of a problem but it'll certainly make you have an easier time understanding Ishida better.

Maybe I phrased it wrong but it'll definitely give you a better time at the Cinema.

All in All, I gave it a 10/10, would watch again.

It has good reviews so I knew I had to see it, but like with many things, I'm late to the party. Today I felt like watching something different, and started to watch it off of a blind whim, forgetting entirely what it was about.

And now I will be recommending this to everybody I know. I thought Your Name was overhyped to biblical proportions. Don't get me wrong, it was great, but the story was a bit lacking. The story and the characters in A Silent Voice is so compelling that it got me to shed some tears and watch it again IMMEDIATELY AFTER watching it the first time. Now that is something that very few movies have been able to do to me.

This is as of right now my best movie of 2017, and perhaps the best animated movie I've ever seen. I'll get flack, because Studio Ghibli make some damn fine movies as well; but for me, this correlated with me on so many levels, and was exactly what I needed without even knowing.

If you haven't seen it yet, be ready for an emotional rollarcoaster. It is a god tier animation.

I'm so glad we have Madman. I'm going to book a ticket for tonight section.