Skip to main content

Get the Reddit app

Scan this QR code to download the app now
Or check it out in the app stores

r/TheoryOfReddit

members
online

Blast From The Past Weekly Feature - Testing Reddit's new block feature and its effects on spreading misinformation and propaganda - Jan 26 2022

Hi all, based on some of the feedback from the State of the Subreddit discussion, we're going to try some weekly discussions. Instead of a list of topics to focus on each week, we're revisiting the top posts in r/TheoryOfReddit's history. This subreddit has officially entered its teenage years, and it can be quite interesting to look back on the top issues from a decade ago, both to see how Reddit (the site) and Reddit (the community) have changed, as well as how maybe things aren't as different as we'd think.

This week we're starting with by far the most popular post in our history, Testing Reddit's new block feature and its effects on spreading misinformation and propaganda. The author, u/ConversationCold8641, looked at Reddit's new implementation of the block feature and how it could be misused, including a fairly extensive experiment on the matter. Unfortunately, while I'd love to bring in original authors to "check in" years later, that account was created just for this one post, so we're out of luck here.

Two years later, the block feature remains relatively unchanged - users you block are unable to see, engage with, and vote on your content. Has that had Reddit's intended effect of reducing stalking and harassment? Do the second order effects outweigh the supposed benefit? How would you prefer to handle blocking and stalking, if not this system?


What's the deal with the new Achievements? What's the deal with the new Achievements?

I just got a notification that I got an achievement, one of my comments had ten upvotes. Well, over forty, but ten since achievements went online today, I guess. I see I also got one for joining reddit, and one for verifying my email. The former is backdated, the latter dated today.

Obviously this a ploy to drive engagement, since it gives out achievements for daily streaks, joining subs (since when are they called "communities", btw?) and sharing reddit links outside the app.

But what is / is there anything else going on, here?

Edit: so just checked, and it has neither expanded nor supplanted the older "trophy" / badge system. It's completely separate.


Want to do even more for your career and your country? Then get ready.


Why do comments agreeing with another often have an inverse score? Why do comments agreeing with another often have an inverse score?
https://preview.redd.it/why-do-comments-agreeing-with-another-often-have-an-inverse-v0-3a09nr2fgbzc1.png

Forget the subject, it can be about anything, the thing I'm so confused about is why this phenomenon keeps happening.

Common scenario 1:

User 1 will say something controversial and get downvoted.

User 2 will agree with User 1 but they get upvoted.

Common scenario 2:

User 1 will say something positive and get upvoted.

User 2 will say they agree but they get downvoted.

Isn't this counterintuitive and shouldn't User 1 and User 2's scores align?