Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Log In
Found the internet!
r/AmericanHorrorStory
118
Posted by6 days ago

So I have finally finished binge watching all 11 seasons of American Horror Story, and this is my scandalous ranking

  1. NYC

  2. Cult

  3. Freak Show

  4. Asylum

  5. 1984

  6. Roanoke

  7. Murder House

  8. Coven

  9. Hotel

  10. Double Feature

  11. Apocalypse

118 comments
79% Upvoted
|
level 1

Respectfully, I hated this ranking 😂

301
level 2

At least it was respectfully <3

34
level 2

I concur.

4
level 2

Me too - however, I've yet to watch NYC. I put it on and was soooo disappointed it was 'procedural cop show' format I noped out waiting for a time I could bear to push through (as I generally hate those programmes).

3
level 1
· 6 days ago · edited 6 days ago

10) Double Feature 11) Apocalypse

saying double feature is better then anything is pretty scandalous.

111
level 2

So I liked the first half of double feature, but the second half was so terrible it ruined for the first half in rankings I lol

24
level 2
· 6 days ago
Venable

It’s blasphemous

4
level 2

My thought exactly! I haven’t gotten to NYC yet, and while Apocalypse has prob been my favorite so far, idk how anything can be below Double lol

6
level 2

To be fair I’m pretty sure the second half of double feature was intentionally bad and I did like the first half.

2
level 2
· 6 days ago
I gotta look out the window and cry while I masturbate.

This!

6
level 1

The fact murder house is 7 is criminal

12
level 1

My gf and I binged 1-10 (haven’t seen NYC yet) in a little over a week (we were both out sick lol) and while I disagree with most of your rankings, I genuinely don’t know how in the world anything is below double feature, and especially how that one could be apocalypse lol

28
level 1

Yessss I’m glad you liked NYC! People were very torn on it.

43
level 2

I understand I’ll get hate for it but it felt like the show really grounded itself and matured for the better. Gino is my favorite character of the show and that devastating ending haunts me. I was also obsessed with the aesthetic.

I kind of hope they keep the show in this sort of direction, even if they do add supernatural elements.

38
level 2

I think the reason I didn't like it that much, other than the fact it was extremely light on horror this season, was it's basically the story of "The Normal Heart." The whole season, I got the feeling something felt eerily familiar, and then it came to me.

You should watch "The Normal Heart" (2014). Also directed and co-written by Ryan Murphy.

1
level 1

Interesting because NYC up there for me (#2) but Hotel is my #1 and Cult is one of my least favorites.

18
level 2

Hotel has an amazing aesthetic, along with Liz Taylor, but I was very burnt out on ghosts at that point, especially the way AHS does them. I love the twist with the killer but didn’t like the wife character at all. My biggest turn off was there were so many sex scenes and, like, I got it. Move along.

11
level 1

You’ve convinced me to watch NYC! I fell off after Cult (though I loved Red Sea, nothing else since then). Agree with your rankings a lot, except I’m a witchy girl in my 20s so I like Coven a lot lol

5

About Community

Fan subreddit for the hit TV franchise American Horror Story. Visit r/AmericanHorrorStories for the Hulu exclusive spin-off.
Created Aug 6, 2011

239k

Members

199

Online

Top 1%

Ranked by Size