‘Like a civil war’: The real Battle of Brisbane that pitted allies against each other
By Tony Moore
When the Broncos played the Dolphins at Suncorp Stadium two weeks ago, the contest was dubbed “the Battle of Brisbane”.
For those who know something about the city’s local history, those words have a different meaning.
The real-life Battle of Brisbane – what’s been described as a two-day civil war – began when tens of thousands of US troops were stationed in the Queensland capital during the Second World War.
A leaflet produced as Japanese propaganda to stoke division between Australian and US troops.
On November 26, 1942, most of the Americans were thinking about the Thanksgiving holiday – not starting a fight with frustrated, poorly paid, brow-beaten Australian counterparts.
But over two days, both sides ended up using batons, broken furniture, knives, guns, broken bottles and fists to settle scores.
By the end, one Australian serviceman, gunner Edward Webster, was killed. Six US and Australian troops had been sent to hospital, and simmering “Digger/Yank” tension remained, which the Japanese used to taunt Australian troops for the rest of World War II.
Sue Norman explains how the battle began on the intersection of Adelaide and Creek streets, where in 1942 luxury goods could be bought from the building over her shoulder.Credit: Tony Moore
This week, as Queenslanders turned out in the Brisbane CBD to pay their respects on Anzac Day, volunteer Brisbane Greeter Sue Norman gave a walking tour to explain key moments in this history.
As Norman explained, the story began at the intersection of Adelaide and Creek streets, as pubs closed on Thanksgiving Day, 1942.
The American Red Cross Service Club on one corner had roasted 200 turkeys, which were taken across Creek Street to Primac House.
In that brick building was the US post military exchange – including a luxury goods store with alcohol, stockings, chocolates, hot chicken and cigarettes for US troops only.
The American Red Cross Service Club on the corner of Adelaide and Creek streets in 1942.Credit: Brisbane City Council
Not far away on Adelaide Street, in a brick building with white stripes now known as Desmond Chambers, was the “Australian Wet Mess” – essentially a wartime pub for Australian troops.
Australian troops were paid half what Americans were paid. The “Yanks” were viewed by Australian women as more sophisticated and more polite. The Diggers hated this, deriding the Americans as “overpaid, over-sexed, and over here”.
“They were very jealous, and it just erupted,” Norman said.
The incident that sparked the violence involved an American military policeman, or MP, asking a US serviceman, which military records name as Private James R Stein, to show his pass.
US military police guard Brisbane’s Central Hotel during the Second World War.Credit: John Oxley Library
Stein, who had been drinking, fumbled to find his pass, and two or three Australian soldiers hassled the MP, who thought Stein was AWOL – absent without leave – and arrested him.
“A group of Australian soldiers who witnessed the event defended Stein by shouting, ‘Leave our mate alone. Give him back his pass. Provo bastards!’” military history authors Peter Thompson and Robert Macklin wrote.
“As the MP raised his baton to threaten them, the Australian soldiers rush him, inciting a brawl between American MPs and Australian troops.”
More US military police arrived, and used batons to beat the Australians who had besieged the Adelaide and Creek street entrance to Primac House.
Australian war correspondent John Hinde described it as “the most furious battle I ever saw during the war … it was like a civil war”.
War historian Dudley McCarthy believes the events highlighted differences in the culture of the two countries, whose alliance has nevertheless survived the years since then.
“It is probably a fair generalisation to say that in the United States, the display of batons and firearms in the hands of police is an effective way of quelling a riot, whereas in Australia it is an effective way of starting one.”