It's NBA awards season!
Since 2017 I've tracked the media voters and votes for the NBA Awards in a publicly available Google spreadsheet. Each year it has produced a conclusive outcome of who will win the NBA MVP before the award was handed out.
For those familiar with this project... Hi, we're back! Yes, even if the awards seem a bit anticlimactic this year.
In this post you'll find:
History on this project dating back to 2017
Summary of 2024 NBA awards ballot changes as we know them
Prediction of who the 2024 awards voters are
How you can help
**View the 2024 NBA MVP & Awards Tracker Here**
History:
2023 was a banner year for vote tracking amidst a very public MVP race. Through crowdsourcing we identified 46 of the 100 NBA first place MVP votes with a 100% accuracy rate of both the ballots and votes in the tracker. We tracked 159 total MVP votes cast for first through fifth place and had 100% accuracy in the tracker. See the archived 2023 NBA MVP tracker here
Each of the individual award winners in the lead on the tracker took home the trophy.
Voters know who they are, but the league does not publicly disclose the voters for the awards. So I work to remove the mystery. We take voters at their word from podcasts, interviews, articles, and TV hits the same they would any interview or source.
I am a Rockets fan and this project started in 2017 when Westbrook prevailed over Harden in the MVP race. That year was particularly interesting because the league reformed how awards balloting worked without being very public about the changes. In the end I determined Westbrook's win through publicly available votes weeks ahead of the now defunct NBA Awards Show.
The tracker follows these awards:
While there are other awards. There are generally not enough public vote disclosures for defensive teams, rookie teams, or clutch player to track them with any meaning.
Summary of 2024 awards changes as we know them:
This is a list of the changes to the awards ballot and process this year as we know them. Very possible there are more changes which will not be publicly announced. We may be learning as we go. Including some of the exceptions below...
To be eligible for awards a player must have 65 games played. This has been widely reported, but has a few exceptions according to voter Rob Mahoney, from The Ringer NBA Show (April 10, 2024):
All-NBA is positionless now. This was announced last year. It seems to be a response to the Jokic and Embiid at center issue.
Howard Beck Tweeted there will be some changes to how the ballots are cast.
@HowardBeck NBA awards wrinkle, just sent by the league:
* bc of new 65-game rule, we are not receiving the ballot links today.
* Ernst & Young, which runs process, will send electronic ballots sometime after season concludes (Sunday), so they can determine player eligibility first.
* Voting will take place sometime between April 16-19.
11:59 AM · Apr 8, 2024 · 56.3K Views
On games played : In practice the official awards ballot is filled out online and has used dropdown menus. The league will be able to remove ineligible players from the menu preventing voters from breaking these rules. Beck also says Ernst & Young will rule on eligibility before ballots go out.
On ballots : Tracking this year will be more difficult than past seasons. The extra time means there may be more volatility and voter movement. I expect to see more preliminary vote declarations than past years. Folks may do something different in a close race than what they said before the season ended. Last year's example: Jalen Rose announced he was Giannis on April 9th. Then switched to Embiid publicly on April 10th. Again, we track voters for what they've said publicly.
I do expect to get some things wrong this year because of this.
Prediction of who the 2024 awards voters are
The voters have already been notified and agreed to vote this year. There's no mystery for the voters themselves, the NBA and likely the teams lobbying them who they are.
I'm a guy compiling lists with the best stuff I've got. And I don't have that list. That said...
The greatest predictor of who votes for the NBA MVP and awards is who voted for NBA All-Star starters that season:
In 2020: 95% of the All-Star media voters also voted for NBA MVP
In 2021: 97% of the All-Star media voters also voted for NBA MVP
In 2022: 97% of the All-Star media voters also voted for NBA MVP
In 2023: 96% of the All-Star media voters also voted for NBA MVP
The lowest this percentage has gone since 2017 is 93%. So we can generally assume 90% of the voting pool will come from the All-Star starters media voters. They make some changes between then and now. I'd expect that to happen again. Doris Burke didn't cast an All-Star ballot this year, but I'd be surprised if she didn't cast a vote for end of season awards. And if you got an All-Star ballot then get bumped by Doris Burke I assume you understand.
Just linking to that list of voters isn't enough fun though. It doesn't give me the chance to show how much time I've spent staring at this stuff (think of all the things I could have done instead, yikes).
Each year I will include voters in the tracker under two conditions.
Option One: A voter says they have a ballot. Easy. But, we're looking for them to confirm they have an official ballot. Not "my ballot." Example: Ben Golliver wrote an article for the Washington Post today "Jokic is undoubtably the MVP and more NBA awards picks." The catch, the Washington Post doesn't allow writers to vote on awards. Ben is absolutely qualified and voted with Sports Illustrated in the past, but he's not one of the one hundred. A fact he includes in the article.
Option Two: A voter has consistent recent voting history and is with the same publication. Over the years I have surmised that votes often go to publications, not writers. So even some of the most esteemed folks drop out of the voting pool when they move jobs.
I personally refer to this option as "good standing" and will include a voter if...
The media member voted for the 2024 NBA All-Star Starters
The media member voted for the 2023 NBA MVP & Awards
The media member voted for the 2023 NBA All-Star Starters
The media member is at the same publication/has the same employer currently as when they cast the three ballots listed above
If someone meets those requirements they're almost assuredly a ballot holder.
So let's look at a list of the folks who qualify for this metric...
Sam Amick The Athletic
Zach Harper The Athletic
Chris Mannix Sports Illustrated
Dave McMenamin ESPN
Kevin O'Connor The Ringer
Kendrick Perkins ESPN
JJ Redick ESPN
Bill Reiter CBSSports.com
Stephen A. Smith ESPN
Chris Broussard Fox
Vince Goodwill Yahoo!
Cassidy Hubbarth ESPN
Frank Isola Sirus Radio
Duane Rankin Arizona Republic
Josh Robbins The Athletic DC
Ryen Russillo The Ringer
Ramona Shelburne ESPN
David Aldridge The Athletic
Maxime Aubin L'Equipe
Tim Bontemps ESPN
Roderick Boone Charlotte Observer
Ric Bucher FS1
Shams Charania The Athletic/Stadium
Anthony Chiang Miami Herald
Demichael Cole Memphis Commerical Appeal
Antoni Daimiel Movistar+
Michael Grange Rogers Sportsnet
Mike Greenberg ESPN
Will Guillory The Athletic NO
Kurt Helin NBCSports.com
Adam Himmelsbach Boston Globe
Kelly Iko The Athletic HOU
Marc Kestecher ESPN
Jeff McDonald San Antonio Express-News
Yoav Modai Sport 5
Dave Pasch ESPN
Keith Pompey Phildelphia Inquirer & Daily News
Shaun Powell NBA.com
Melissa Rohlin Fox Sports
Taylor Rooks Bleacher Report
Dennis Scott Warner Bros. Discovery
Bill Simmons The Ringer
Anthony Slater The Athletic
Doug Smith The Toronto Star
Steve Smith Warner Bros. Discovery
Seerat Sohi The Ringer
Justin Termine SiriusXM Radio
Joe Vardon The Athletic
David Villafranca EFE News
Chris Fedor Cleveland.com
Brian Mahoney Associated Press
Kevin Pelton ESPN
Stephanie Ready Warner Bros. Discovery
Tim Reynolds Associated Press
Stan Van Gundy Warner Bros. Discovery
Chao Meng ESPN China
Greg Anthony Warner Bros. Discovery
Ernie Johnson Warner Bros. Discovery
Jared Greenberg Warner Bros. Discovery
Michael Pina The Ringer
Dan Devine Yahoo! Sports
Rob Mahoney The Ringer
Steve Aschburner NBA.com
John Schuhmann NBA.com
Michael Wright NBA.com
Matt Winer Warner Bros. Discovery
Jeff Zillgitt USA Today
Michael Wilbon ESPN
Gary Washburn Boston Globe
Ohm Youngmisuk ESPN
Brian Windhorst ESPN
Yoko Miyaji Sports Graphic Number
That's 72 probable voters. It would be a surprise if any of these folks were not voters in 2024.
Then without going through all the additional names, the remainder of the 2024 All-Star pool included:
9 reinstated voters. These were media members who have cast an awards vote in the past, but did not get a ballot either last year or for a few years. The most high profile name in this group is Candace Parker. Several of these are local writers who represent the regional portion of the voting pool.
12 new voters. These were media members who cast their first vote of any type with the 2024 NBA All-Star ballot. Richard Jefferson and Chiney Ogwumike are the most known names in this group.
This pool includes several international voters, who generally makeup 10 - 12 total voters. The list of voters in good standing includes six international voters. So there's likely 4 - 6 international media voters in addition to them. This does not include Canada-based media members who I consider to be voters representing the Toronto media market or the same as a media member working for an American outlet covering the NBA at large.
3 voters who moved outlets and that is their own disqualifier from my list above: Howard Beck, Chris Herring and Khobi Price.
A few peculiarities. Rachel Nichols and Adam Lefkoe didn't cast 2023 All-Star ballots. But did cast 2023 MVP votes and 2024 All-Star votes.
Some notable missing names (who may still have ballots):
Zach Lowe - He publicly declared he wanted a break from voting and did not cast an NBA All-Star ballot. I don't know if he extended that to the end of year awards, but have removed him.
Doris Burke - She didn't cast an All-Star vote this year. I believe she has voted on everything since 2018. This was a surprise.
Lastly, the local markets have change and turnover. The NBA hinted in 2017 they would have one voter from every media market. Some years they've missed that goal. Sometimes that local vote is passed between different publications (Salt Lake City) or within a newsroom (Dallas). There will be turnover in a place like Denver where longtime Denver Post writer Mike Singer is no longer with the paper after being a consistent voter.
How You Can Help:
If you find any media member saying they have an official NBA Awards ballot, even if they don't say who they vote for, send it my way!
Include a link or timestamp to anything you find. I include primary sourcing in all tracking efforts. If a Mike Breen says his vote in the third quarter of an NBA broadcast send me a note saying what game and what minute he shared his ballot.
Lastly, I'm a single person with no editor who does this for fun. I'll always correct stuff I get wrong. I err on the side of caution and am pretty proud of how this has held up over the years. This year may be more difficult than past years because the ballot deadline has been extended.
If you read all of this you're a sicko and I'm right there with you.