Beyond the Canon?
For those of us of a certain vintage, there was something quite disconcerting about identifying selections for the final TNPC poll. After all, we had grown up with the ‘canon’ and we lived out our youth through the latter part of the 20th Century. Much of the music made during that time meant the world to us. But what about the music of the 21st Century? There is a theory that when people reach the age of 33, they give up being interested in new music, and are content to revisit the past, seeking refuge in the familiar, perhaps reliving their adolescence? It’s a gross generalisation of course but there is an irrefutable logic to the claim. The responsibilities of adult life and balancing out work and family commitments, means that for many of us, the latest sounds are skimmed through with little patience. How different it was when we were younger – one had to really live with Trout Mask Replica and Bitches Brew, listening to them day in and day out for months on end in order to cultivate a true appreciation of their merits. And of course those albums – and many others – would prove to reward every ounce of perseverance. So when my early invitations to our contributors began to meet with blank responses (“I haven’t a clue”, “I’ve maybe only listened to ten albums since 2000”, “I reckon no classic record has been made since 1980”) I began to fear the worst.
Not all our contributors are middle-aged of course, but many of those, after their initial reticence, opted to take part in any case. The result? 1437 individual albums were nominated by around 120 contributors. From those,only one album received over 30 votes. If we contrast that with previous Poll-Toppers Forever Changes (45 out of 76) Marquee Moon (65 out of 125) and The Stone Roses (59) it points to a staggering lack of post-millennial consensus, with over 500 titles receiving only one vote. Without question then, the vast majority of our contributors have been listening to – and appreciating – a huge variety of contemporary sounds – far more than I have certainly. For myself, this exercise was always going to be something of an educational experience, overseeing the new list take shape.
The Results?
Block votes inevitably throw up one or two anomalies. Sometimes votes are split: consider the case of Mogwai or Six Organs Of Admittance, both of whom had 7 albums nominated, but neither of whose individual albums managed more than 3 votes – resulting in a frustrating absence from the final 100. More pleasingly, there was a plethora of votes for The Clientele, Low and Broadcast, each of whom is deliciously well represented in the list and rightly so. The most popular artist in terms of the sheer volume of nominations was by some distance, LCD Soundsystem,whose vote was also split very widely.
I’m less surprised about the results than I had anticipated, and know far more of these records than I had expected to know. The poll does not of course claim to be a new canon for the 21st Century, but alongside the other three polls, it should offer a few pointers to those looking to expand their horizons, and if anyone is looking to build a collection of popular music’s greatest 400 albums, they could do a lot worse than start here.
And the winner? Well, it’s somehow fitting that we round off this exercise with pop’s greatest star looking down from the summit, but, fine album though it undoubtedly is, it does somehow feel a little incongruous and unrepresentative – another inevitable consequence of the block vote. Only one person actually placed it as first choice. But there it is. I’m sure many will argue long into the night about its merits, but that’s democracy for you.
Once again, immense thanks to you all for your inspiring recommendations over the last three months. I have been furnished with enough new music to occupy me purposefully for the rest of my life. Now how exactly am I going to find the time to listen to it all? Skim listening just won’t do it. (JJ)
[As is customary, those albums just missing the cut (101-200) are listed in the first Appendix – following the list of contributors. A list of ‘One Vote Wonders’ should appear at the weekend]
………………………………………………..
The Top 100
100. Thunder Lightning Strike – The Go Team (Memphis Industries, 2004)
99. No More Shall We Part – Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (Mute, 2001)
98. The Drift – Scott Walker (4AD, 2006)
97. Any Other City – Life Without Buildings (Tugboat, 2001)
96. mbv – My Bloody Valentine (m b v, 2013)
95. World Music – Goat (Rocket, 2012)
94. Dragging A Dead Deer Up A Hill – Grouper (Type, 2008)
93. Norman Fucking Rockwell – Lana Del Ray (Polydor, 2019)
92. Rounds – Four Tet (Domino, 2003)
91. Donuts – J Dilla (Stones Throw, 2006)
90. The Woods – Sleater-Kinney (Sub Pop, 2005)
89. Up The Bracket – The Libertines (Rough Trade, 2002)
88. Turn On The Bright Lights – Interpol (Matador, 2002)
87. Speakerboxxx / The Love Below – OutKast (LaFace. 2003)
86. Raising Sand – Robert Plant / Alison Krauss (Rounder, 2007)
85. Not The Tremblin’ Kind – Laura Cantrell (Spit & Polish, 2000)
84. Voodoo – D’Angelo (Virgin, 2000)
83. This Is Happening – LCD Soundsystem (DFA, 2005)
82. You Are Free – Cat Power (Matador, 2003)
81. Strange Geometry – The Clientele (Pointy, 2005)
80. Love & Theft – Bob Dylan (Columbia, 2001)
79. Bloom – Beach House (Sub Pop, 2012)
78. Tomorrow’s Harvest – Boards Of Canada (Warp, 2013)
77. Diamond Mine – King Creosote & Jon Hopkins (Domino, 2011)
76. Sometimes I Sit And Think & Sometimes I Just Sit – Courtney Barnett (Milk!, 2015)
75. High Violet – The National (4AD, 2010)
74. Veckatimest – Grizzly Bear (Warp, 2009)
73. Master And Everyone – Bonnie Prince Billy (Drag City, 2003)
72. Lost Souls – Doves (Heavenly, 2000)
71. Time (The Revelator) – Gillian Welch (Acony, 2001)
70. I Love You Honeybear – Fr. John Misty (Bella Union, 2015)
69. The Archandroid – Janelle Monae (Bad Boy, 2010)
68. Kiwanuka – Michael Kiwanuka (Polydor, 2019)
67. The Silver Globe – Jane Weaver (Fire, 2014)
66. Ys – Joanna Newsom (Drag City, 2006)
65. Madvillainy – Madvillain (Stones Throw, 2004)
64. Vespertine – Bjork (One Little Indian, 2001)
63. Skeleton Tree – Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (Bad Seed Ltd, 2016)
62. The Greatest – Cat Power (Matador, 2006)
61. Light Up Gold – Parquet Courts (Dull Tools, 2012)
60. Purple Mountains – Purple Mountains (Drag City, 2019)
59. Party – Aldous Harding (4AD, 2017)
58. Lift Your Skinny Fists Like Antennas To Heaven – Godspeed You! Black Emperor (Constellation, 2000)
57. Good Kid MAAd City – Kendrick Lamar (Top Dawg, 2012)
56. Modern Kosmology – Jane Weaver (Fire, 2017)
55. Sea Change – Beck (Geffen, 2002)
54. Want One – Rufus Wainwright (DreamWorks, 2003)
53. Original Pirate Material – The Streets (Locked On / 679 Recordings, 2002)
52. Haha Sound – Broadcast (Warp, 2003)
51. LCD Soundsystem – LCD Soundsystem (DFA, 2005)
50. Channel Orange – Frank Ocean (Def Jam, 2012)
49. Oracular Spectacular – MGMT (Red Ink, 2007)
48. Tender Buttons – Broadcast (Warp, 2005)
47. Lost In The Dream – The War On Drugs (Secretly Canadian, 2014)
46. Vampire Weekend – Vampire Weekend (XL, 2008)
45. For Emma Forever Ago – Bon Iver (Jagiaguwar, 2007)
44. Oceans Apart – The Go-Betweens (LO-MAX, 2005)
43. Teen Dream – Beach House (Sub Pop, 2010)
42. Since I Left You – The Avalanches (Modular, 2000)
41. Songs For The Deaf – Queens Of The Stone Age (Interscope, 2002)
40. The Noise Made By People – Broadcast (Warp, 2000)
39. Before Today – Ariel Pink’s Haunted Graffiti (4AD, 2010)
38. Rings Around The World – Super Furry Animals (Epic, 2001)
37. Untrue – Burial (Hyperdub, 2007)
36. American IV: The Man Comes Around – Johnny Cash (American Recordings, 2002)
35. Halcyon Digest – Deerhunter (4AD, 2010)
34. Things We Lost In The Fire – Low (Kranky, 2001)
33. Carrie & Lowell – Sufjan Stevens Asthmatic Kitty, 2015)
32. Whatever People Say I Am, That’s What I’m Not – Arctic Monkeys (Domino, 2006)
31. Currents – Tame Impala (Modular, 2015)
30. I Am A Bird Now – Antony & The Johnsons (Secretly Canadian, 2005)
29. White Blood Cells – White Stripes (Sympathy For The Record Industry, 2001)
28. Suburban Light – The Clientele (Pointy, 2000)
27. Yoshimi Battles The Pink Robots – The Flaming Lips (Warner Bros, 2002)
26. Nixon – Lambchop (Merge, 2000)
25. And Then Nothing Turned Itself Inside Out – Yo La Tengo (Matador, 2000)
24. XTRMNTR – Primal Scream (Creation, 2000)
23. Double Negative – Low (Sub Pop, 2018)
22. Elephant – The White Stripes (V2, 2003)
21. Lonerism – Tame Impala (Modular, 2012)
20. Figure 8 – Elliot Smith (DreamWorks, 2000)
19. In Rainbows – Radiohead (self-released, 2007)
18. Push The Sky Away – Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds (Bad Seed Ltd, 2013)
17. Queen Of Denmark – John Grant (Bella Union, 2010)
16. Third – Portishead (Island, 2008)
15. Have You In My Wilderness – Julia Holter (Domino, 2015)
14. Back To Black – Amy Winehouse (Island, 2006)
13. Geogaddi – Boards Of Canada (Warp, 2002)
12. Come On Feel The Illinoise – Sufjan Stevens (Asthmatic Kitty, 2005)
11. The Trials Of Van Occupanther – Midlake (Bella Union, 2006)
10. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea – PJ Harvey (Island, 2000)
9. To Pimp A Butterfly – Kendrick Lamar (Top Dawg, 2015)
8. Kid A – Radiohead (Parlophone, 2000)
7. Is This It? – The Strokes (RCA, 2001)
6. Funeral – Arcade Fire (Merge, 2004)
5. Yankee Hotel Foxtrot – Wilco (Nonesuch, 2001)
4. Sound Of Silver – LCD Soundsystem (DFA, 2007)
3. Fleet Foxes – Fleet Foxes (Bella Union, 2008)
2. Let England Shake – PJ Harvey (Island, 2011)
1. Blackstar – David Bowie (ISO / RCA, 2016)
…………………………………………………..
Contributors:
Bill Ainsworth, Camilla Aisa, Michael Bailey (Soft Hearted Scientists), Andy Barratt, Billy Bell, Caroline Binnie, Nick Blakey (Underground Jukebox), Chris Bounds, Holly Boyd, Stephen Boyd, Johnny Browning, David Bruce, Helen Bull, Kevin Byrne, Julie Campbell (LoneLady / Warp Records), Marc (Captain Howdy), Ben Chasny (Six Organs Of Admittance), Lucy Clifton, Si Cole, Chris Coleman, Mike Convery, Joe Currie, Campbell Davidson, Laura Lee Davies, Steve Davies, Jon Dennis, Mick Derrick, Neil Douglas, Lionel Duffy, Seamus Duggan, Maureen Dunlop, Peter Ferguson, Jim Ferry, Jason Finch, Declan Flanagan, Feargus Flanagan, Paul Gallagher, Carl Goldspink, Ben Graham, Grasshopper (Sean Mackowiak / Mercury Rev), Darren Grayer, Andrew Hall, Jeff Hartley, Mark Hillier, Robert Hodgens, Dan Holway, Jane Hoskyn, Maartje Jansma, Sophie Jay, James Johnstone, Johnnie Johnstone, Martin Johnstone, Peter Johnstone, Allan Jones, David Keller, Harris King, William Knott, Peter Latimer, Julian Francis Lawton, Paul Lowman, John Marcus, Rob Martindell, Leon Massey, Will McAlpine, Jim McCulloch, Alastair Macduff, Douglas McIntyre, Gary McKenzie, Grant McPhee, Fiona McQuarrie, John Medd, Graham Meikle, Thom Moore, Rob Morgan, Tony Mulraney, Paul Murray, Peter Murray, Huw Neill, Brendan O’Leary, Richard Oxley, Jake Palmer, Thomas Patterson, Mark Paytress, Richard Phillips-Jones, Andy Pidluznyi (New Apostles), Nick Portnell, Brian Randall, Steve Rhodes, Don Richmond, Chris Roberts, Matt Rogers, Coinneach Rooney, Marco Rossi, Martin Ruddock, Chris Sawle, Jo Scollin, Paul Scollin, David Sharp, Amy Shaw, Simon Shaw, Angela Slaven, Jonathan Small, Jason A Spence, Arthur David Spota, Iain Stansfield, Theo Stockman, David Stubbs, Daniel Thompson, Terry Tochel, Ben Travers, Paul Turnbull, Iain Wade, Judah Warsky, Richard Waterson, Stevie Watt, Helen Whiteley-McPhee, Dominic Whittingham, Peter Wilson, Winna Ding, Sandy Wishart, David Wright, Jack Young, Bill Zzuka
…………………………………………………….
The Next 100…
101. You Want It Darker – Leonard Cohen
102. Fever To Tell – The Yeah Yeah Yeahs
103. Heartbreaker – Ryan Adams
104. Lesser Matters – The Radio Dept
105. One Day I’m Going To Soar – Dexys
106. Born To Die – Lana Del Ray
107. Sometimes I Wish We Were An Eagle – Bill Callahan
108. I’m New Here – Gil Scott-Heron
109. Quiet Songs – Jessica Pratt
110. Modern Times – Bob Dylan
111. Monomania – Deerhunter
112. The Great Destroyer – Low
113. Yellow House – Grizzly Bear
114. Teens Of Denial – Carseat Headrest
115. The Suburbs – Arcade Fire
116. Insignificance– Jim O’Rourke
117. Chutes Too Narrow – The Shins
118. Relationship Of Command – At The Drive-In
119. Rated R – Queens Of The Stone Age
120. Person Pitch – Panda Bear
121. Let’s Get Out Of This Country– Camera Obscura
122. Shields – Grizzly Bear
123. Brothers – Black Keys
124. Human Performance – Parquet Courts
125. Stay Gold – First Aid Kit
126. Sun Structures – Temples
127. Aerial – Kate Bush
128. Morning Phase – Beck
129. Blonde – Frank Ocean
130. The Next Day – David Bowie
131. Primary Colours – The Horrors
132. Sophtware Slump – Grandaddy
133. On Your Own Love Again – Jessica Pratt
134. The Power Out – Electrelane
135. Riot On An Empty Street – Kings Of Convenience
136. Yeezus– Kanye West
137. Oh Inverted World – Shins
138. The Real New Fall Album (Country On The Click) – The Fall
139. Joy As An Act Of Resistance – Idles
140. Depression Cherry – Beach House
141. Crack Up – Fleet Foxes
142. Abattoir Blues / Lyre Of Orpheus – Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
143. Supreme Clientele – Ghostface Killah
144. Black Messiah– D’Angelo
145. Franz Ferdinand – Franz Ferdinand
146. The Decline Of British Sea Power – British Sea Power
147. Discovery – Daft Punk
148. Post Pop Depression – Iggy Pop
149. Wooden Shjips – Wooden Shjips
150. Hinterland – LoneLady
151. Cole’s Corner – Richard Hawley
152. Campfire Headphase – Boards Of Canada
153. All Mirrors – Angel Olsen
154. We Got It From Here…Thank You For Your Service – A Tribe Called Quest
155. Your Queen Is A Reptile – Sons Of Kemet
156. Want Two – Rufus Wainwright
157. Your Future Our Clutter – The Fall
158. Slowdive – Slowdive
159. Hail To The Thief – Radiohead
160. The Age Of The Understatement – Last Shadow Puppets
161. > – Beak
162. The Life Pursuit – Belle & Sebastian
163. Ease Down The Road – Bonnie Prince Billy
164. Ghosteen – Nick Cave & The Bad Seeds
165. Sung Tongs – Animal Collective
166. Stankonia – OutKast
167. Takk – Sigur Ros
168. Helplessness Blues – Fleet Foxes
169. Bisch Bosch – Scott Walker
170. Real Gone – Tom Waits
171. Hot Shots 2 – The Beta Band
172. The xx – The xx
173. A Ghost Is Born – Wilco
174. The Coral – The Coral
175. Tanglewood Numbers – Silver Jews
176. Margerine Eclipse – Stereolab
177. Devotion– Beach House
178. Bravery Repetition & Noise – Brian Jonestown Massacre
179. Beet Maize & Corn – High Llamas
180. Transfiguration Of Vincent – M Ward
181. White Chalk – PJ Harvey
182. The Epic – Kamasi Washington
183. Merriweather Post Pavilion – Animal Collective
184. Cucumber – Sexual Objects
185. Arular – MIA
186. Dongs Of Sevotion – Smog
187. My Maudlin Career – Camera Obscura
188. Designer – Aldous Harding
189. Ghosts Of The Great Highway – Sun Kil Moon
190. Let It Come Down – Spiritualized
191. Bavarian Fruit Bread – Hope Sandoval & The Warm Inventions
192. Titanic Rising – Weyes Blood
193. Rest – Charlotte Gainsbourg
194. Slow Summits – The Pastels
195. The Age Of Adz – Sufjan Stevens
196. Do Hollywood – Lemon Twigs
197. Kaputt – Destroyer
198. Ballad Of The Broken Seas – Isobel Campbell / Mark Lanegan
199. Bon Iver – Bon Iver
200. The English Riviera – Metronomy
……………………………….
And now for something completely different…
One Vote Wonders
Over 500 titles received only one vote. Here are 100 of the more interesting nominations…
Hinterland – Aim
Always – Anti-Socialites
Drukqs – Aphex Twin
Citrus – Asobi Seksu
Moo You Bloody Choir – Augie March
David Axelrod– David Axelrod
Jackleg Devotional To The Heart – Baptist Generals
Disintegration Loops – William Basinski
Every Step’s A Yes – The Bees
The Owl’s Map – Belbury Poly (Jim Jupp)
Antlers And The Sun And All The Things That Grow Old And Pass Away – Bird By Snow
A Sea Of Trees – The Blue Angel Lounge
Childqueen – Khadja Bonet
Hunter – Anna Calvi
Transverse – Carter Tutti Void
Popcorn Doublefish – Malcolm Catto
The Longest River – Olivia Chaney
X-Pianos – Chassol
The Cherry Blossoms – The Cherry Blossoms
Cheval Sombre – Cheval Sombre
Black Ships Ate The Sky – Current 93
Working Class Woman – Marie Davidson
You’re A Woman, I’m A Machine – Death From Above 1979
A Long Losing Battle With Eloquence & Intimance – Dredd Foole
Runout Groove – Stephen Duffy & The Lilac Time
Here’s My Song, You Can Have It, I Don’t Want It Anymore / Yours 4-Ever – Nicolai Dunger
Allegranza! – El Guincho
We Are All From Somewhere Else – Exploding Star Orchestra
Devin Dazzle & The Neon Fever – Felix da Housecat
La Reproduction – Arnaud Fleurent-Didier
Record Collector – The Foreign Films
Insides – Fort Romeau
Personal Record – Eleanor Freidberger
Cabinet Of Curiosities – Jacco Gardner
Pop – Gas
Ghost Dog (The Way Of The Samurai) – Original Soundtrack
Underdog World Strike – Gogol Bordello
The Days Of Mars – Delia Gonzalez & Gavin Russon
Symphony Of Sorrowful Songs – Henry Gorecki / Beth Gibbons
The Art Of Funerary Violin – The Guild Of Funerary Violinists
Y Dydd Olaf – Gwenno
In The Pink Of Condition – H. Hawkline
Fletcher Moss Park – Matthew Halsall
Black Blues – Keiji Hano
Excavation – The Haxan Cloak
Bright Penny – Liam Hayes & Plush
Health – The Heavy Blinkers
Chiaroscuro – Arve Henriksen
Proto – Holly Herndon
Human Don’t Be Angry – Human Don’t Be Angry
Edge Of A Dream – Bert Jansch
Black Origami – Jlin
Orpheé – Johann Johannson
100 Days, 100 Nights – Sharon Jones & The Dap-Kings
Take Me Apart – Kelela
Dracula Boots – Kid Congo Powers & The Monkey Birds
Kite – Steven Lindsay
Nerve Up – LoneLady
Hoverance- Raleigh Long
I Trawl The Megahertz– Paddy McAloon
Something For The Weakened – Meursault
MM Food – MF Doom
Les Revenants – Mogwai
The Moldy Peaches – The Moldy Peaches
Morgan Delt – Morgan Delt
Nichts Muss – Barbara Morgenstern
Entranced Earth – The Myrrors
Songs III: Bird On The Water – Marissa Nadler
Variations On A Theme – Om
Forroleidescope – Orquestra do Fuba
Heavy Rain – Lee ‘Scratch’ Perry
Reachy Prints – Plaid
Music For Small’s Lighthouse – Plinth
Moses On A Snail – Robert Pollard
Your Mind Is A Box (Let Us Fill It With Wonder) – Poltergeist
Paranoic Critical – Port Sulphur
The Two Worlds – Brigid Mae Power
1992 – Princess Nokia
The Dark Realities Of The Moment – Professor Brian Oblivion
Matador Singles ’08 – Jay Reatard
Because Her Beauty Is Raw & Wild – Jonathan Richman
The Colossus – RJD2
A Wonder Working Stone – Alasdair Roberts & Friends
Hope Downs – Rolling Blackouts Coastal Fever
How To Live With A Phantom – Shintaro Sakamoto
Live In The Earth: In Dub Chapter 2 – Sandoz
Coping Mechanisms – Si Schroeder
The Bells Of 1 2 – Sol Seppy
Whorl – Simian Mobile Disco
Ascent – Six Organs Of Admittance
EARS – Kaitlyn Aurelia Smith
Beyond The Wizard’s Sleeve – The Soft Bounce
His Hands – Candi Staton
Funeral Mariachi – Sun City Girls
Pyroclasts – Sunn O)))
Bastard – Tyler The Creator
Thing Of The Past – Vetiver
Turning To The Rooster – Vibracathedral Orchestra
Also In White – Bill Wells Trio
Briarwood – Wooden Wand
Songbook – Woodpigeon