A recent issue of
Upping the Anti: A Journal of Theory and Action (no. 9, November 2009, Toronto, Canada: www.uppingtheanti.org) has a fine (and carefully considered)
Black Flame review by Sean Benjamin. Its entitled "Fanning the Flames" (p. 159 onwards). Some quotes:
"... Schmidt and van der Walt avoid the 'great thinkers' approach to historical research instead focusing on excavating the histories of largely unknown individuals and movements in order to analyze various strategies and tactics among these groups. They devote less attention to individual thinkers and focus instead on anarchist ideas and the movements they informed ... "
"While most historical studies of anarchism have focused on Western Europe and North America,
Black Flame counters this Eurocentric approach. As the authors explain, 'the broad anarchist tradition was an international movement that cannot be adequately understood through the focus on Western anarchism that typifies most existing accounts' (8). Anarchist movements in Africa, East Asia, Latin America, Eastern Europe, and (to a lesser extent) the Middle East are amply documented."
"In recent years, there has been an upsurge in class struggle anarchism, or social anarchism ... In these circumstances, there is a need for a clear and more forceful theoretical statement of principles, and
Black Flame serves as an excellent opening statement of the relevance of class struggle anarchism in a twenty-first century context. Whether or not one accepts all of the components of the authors’ analysis
of the broad anarchist tradition, this book is an impressive introduction to the history of anarchist theory and anarchist movements.
"It radically reframes the debate over anarchism and how it is perceived by both its advocates and the world at large, and successfully argues for anarchism’s relevance in contemporary struggles. Their forthcoming second volume,
Global Fire: 150 Fighting Years of International Anarchism and Syndicalism, will focus on the history of the global anarchist movement to complement the theoretical focus of
Black Flame. If the second volume is as good as the first, they will stand together as a truly significant contribution to both anarchist theory and history."