Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts
Showing posts with label reviews. Show all posts

Friday, March 20, 2015

Raul Zelik, review for raulzelik.net - (German-language) reviews NO. 3 of German translation ("Schwarze Flamme. Revolutionäre Klassenpolitik des Anarchismus und Syndikalismus")

Source: here

"Syndikalistische Klassenpolitik? - Schmidts / van der Walts Buch 'Schwarze Flamme'" (Rezension WDR 3 / WOZ November 2013)

schwarze flammeBeitrag für die Sendung "Klasse Kommunisten" von Ulrich Hufen (Gutenbergs Welt, WDR 3) (zum Nachhören der ganzen Sendung)
Seit dem Ende des Staatssozialismus wird von kritischen Beobachtern immer mal wieder eine Renaissance des Anarchismus prognostiziert – so zuletzt etwa bei dem Hype um den US-Ethnologen David Graeber. Schließlich, so heißt es, hätten anarchistische DenkerInnen die Staats- und Herrschaftsorientierung des Mainstream-Marxismus schon im 19. Jahrhundert kritisiert und auf den Widerspruch zwischen politischer Machtergreifung und sozialer Emanzipation verwiesen.

Auch Lucien van der Walts und Michael Schmidts Buch „Schwarze Flamme“ argumentiert in diese Richtung. Den südafrikanischen Akademikern geht es darum, die radikaldemokratische und sozialistische Essenz des Anarchismus herauszuarbeiten und dieser Geltung zu verschaffen. Ihre Ausgangsthese lautet dabei, dass der Anarchismus-Begriff in der Regel viel zu diffus verwendet wird. Staatskritik, wie sie etwa von den rechten US-amerikanischen Libertarians geübt wird, habe – so Van der Walt und Schmidt – mit Anarchismus wenig zu tun. Erst aus der Verbindung antikapitalistischer und antistaatlicher Positionen ergebe sich die spezifische Emanzipationsperspektive des Anarchismus.

In diesem Sinne handelt es sich bei der broad anarchist tradition, wie sie die plurale anarchistische Theorie bezeichnen, um eine Strömung der Arbeiterbewegung,

Philipp Schnee, review for Deutschlandradio Kultur - (German-language) reviews NO. 2 of German translation ("Schwarze Flamme. Revolutionäre Klassenpolitik des Anarchismus und Syndikalismus")

Source: here

Buchkritik / Archiv | Beitrag vom 23.10.2013

Ohne Klassenkampf zählt es nicht

Lucien van der Walt/Michael Schmidt: "Schwarze Flamme", Editon Nautilus, Hamburg 2013, 560 Seiten
Tief in der sozialistischen Tradition möchten die Autoren Lucien van der Walt und Michael Schmidt den Anarchismus verankern. Ihr Versuch, damit ein neues Standardwerk zur Geschichte des Anarchismus zu schreiben, scheitert allerdings an einseitigen und oberflächlichen Analysen.

Dass Anarchismus kein Synonym für Chaos ist, muss heute zum Glück nur noch selten erklärt werden. Lucien van der Walt und Michael Schmidt gehen aber noch viel weiter: Auch "Keine Macht für Niemand" ist in ihren Augen kein hinreichender Slogan für das, was sie unter Anarchismus verstehen. Ihr Buch "Schwarze Flamme" wurde vom Verlag vollmundig als "Standardwerk anarchistischer Geschichtsschreibung" angekündigt. Das legt die Latte hoch.

Zumindest in puncto

Dieter Nelles, review for H-Soz-Kult - (German-language) reviews NO. 1 of German translation ("Schwarze Flamme. Revolutionäre Klassenpolitik des Anarchismus und Syndikalismus")

Dieter Nelles, review for H-Soz-Kult 
(HUMANITIES - SOZIAL- UND KULTURGESCHICHTE / H-SOZ-U-KULT@H-NET.MSU.EDU
(http://www.hsozkult.de)
 
Date: Thu, 19 Mar 2015 21:05:00 +0100
From: "HSK (Michael Wildt)" <...>

From:    Dieter Nelles <...>
Date:    20.03.2015
Subject: Rez. NS: M. Schmidt u. a.: Schwarze Flamme
------------------------------------------------------------------------

Schmidt, Michael; van der Walt, Lucien: Schwarze Flamme. Revolutionäre
Klassenpolitik des Anarchismus und Syndikalismus [Aus dem Englischen
übersetzt und mit einem Nachwort versehen von Andreas Förster und Holger
Marcks]. Hamburg: Edition Nautilus / Verlag Lutz Schulenburg 2013. ISBN
978-3-89401-783-5; Broschur; 557 S.; EUR 39,90.

Rezensiert für H-Soz-Kult von:
Dieter Nelles, Fakultät für Sozialwissenschaft, Ruhr-Universität Bochum
E-Mail: <...>

In einem Artikel über Pierre-Joseph Proudhon schrieb der Journalist
Jakob Schulz kürzlich in der Süddeutschen Zeitung: "Proudhons
Überzeugungen haben letztlich keinen bleibenden Einfluss auf den
Sozialismus. Anfang des 20. Jahrhunderts finden anarchistische Ideen
fast nur noch in intellektuellen Kreisen statt."[1] Es sind solche
Fehlurteile, die den Anarchismus fälschlicherweise als gesellschaftliche
Randerscheinung abqualifizieren oder ihn "mit Chaos, Desorganisation und
Zerstörung" (S. 14) gleichsetzen, gegen die sich der Soziologe Lucien
van der Walt und der Journalist Michael Schmidt richten. Das 2009 auf
Englisch erschienene Werk wird sowohl in politischen als auch in
wissenschaftlichen Kreisen kontrovers diskutiert, wobei die Debatte
insgesamt, schreiben die Übersetzer im Nachwort, "vor allem kraft
politischer Überzeugungen geführt" werde "und kaum als wissenschaftliche
Auseinandersetzung" (S. 431).

Das dem so ist, hat aber auch damit zu tun, dass es sich bei Schwarze
Flamme, so die Autoren, "nicht bloß um die archäologische Studie einer
altertümlichen, heute begrabenen Bewegung" handele, sondern um eine
Bewegung, die "inmitten der globalisierungskritischen und

Saturday, January 16, 2010

"Black Flame" Review, in German, Gabriel Kuhn for "Direkte Aktion"

The January/ February 2010 issue of Direkte Aktion (no. 196) includes a review of Black Flame. Direkte Aktion is published by the German anarcho-syndicalist group, the Free Workers Union (Freien ArbeiterInnen-Union, FAU). The reviewer, Gabriel Kuhn, is editor of the forthcoming Gustav Landauer, Revolution and Other Writings: a political reader (PM Press, 2010).

Here are some translated quotes:
"With its more than 400 pages, Black Flame is a remarkable study of (social) anarchism's international history, and a reflection on key issues of organization, strategy, and tactics ...

"Considering the range and scope of the collected material, the book must count as a milestone, and it will without doubt claim its place in the canon of anarchist historiography. This is certainly well deserved. The book's international reach ... is exceptional and can only be compared to Max Nettlau's notes, with two main differences: van der Walt and Schmidt were able to collect much more material on Latin America, Asia, and Africa, and they had the time to work their data into an immaculately structured and highly readable narrative...

"In conclusion, the virtues of Black Flame are without question: it is an outstanding study, and highly recommended to all anarchists! Those who agree with the authors' definition of anarchism will rejoice. Those who don't will be challenged to assess their understanding of anarchism in relation to the syndicalist, anarcho-communist, and platformist traditions."

Another glowing review

"... a corrective to the previous histories of anarchism by the likes of Peter Marshall and George Woodcock ... clearly written and well-presented and the arguments well put ... AK Press have done an excellent job with the book, there's enough illustrations to show the human face of anarchism and the international coverage is exemplary. The price should be within range of most libraries ... and even many comrades should be able to afford a copy ... I look forward to seeing the second volume!" - Richard Alexander, in Black Flag no. 230, 2009.

Monday, January 11, 2010

KDVS Interview with Lucien van der Walt, co-author of "Black Flame: The Revolutionary Class Politics of Anarchism and Syndicalism"

Richard Estes and Ron Glick interviewed Lucien van der Walt, co-author of Black Flame: The Revolutionary Class Politics of Anarchism and Syndicalism, on their show “Speaking In Tongues,” KDVS, 90.3 FM, University Of California, Davis. The interview took place on September 25, 2009.

The transcript (which I’ve edited slightly for clarity- Charles Wiegl) is below. If you’d like an audio recording of the interview, go here or here. For a higher quality recording of the entire show, go here.

And thanks to Richard and Ron, who have interviewed several AK authors and collective members on their show.

The interview is wide-ranging, covering issues like anarchism and trade unionism today, globalisation, immigration, race, and of course, Black Flame.

The full interview is here.

Monday, November 16, 2009

More reviewers' praise for 'Black Flame'

"... one of its distinctive contributions is its global scope. Further, the book's intellectual exploration goes deep, and, most importantly, the whole project is carried out with remarkable independence of thought ... their book is brilliant and thought-provoking. I think Black Flame is a valuable study for activists, students and academics alike. I am inspired by the independent thinking that Schmidt and van der Walt employed in carrying out this project. This is the proper way to pay homage to the anarchist history and anarchist tradition..." - Mandisi Majavu, Africa Project for Participatory Society, in ZNET.

"... an important contribution to labour radicalism and the potential for building global worker movements bottom up ... a great book!" - Immanuel Ness, coordinating editor, International Encyclopedia of Revolution and Protest.

Reviewers' praise for 'Black Flame'

What people say:

Black Flame: the revolutionary class politics of anarchism and syndicalism, has scored good reviews from academics and activists (and academic activists) alike:

* "A book with a deeply impressive quality of research, analysis and writing, this very important and much-needed work is an unexpected delight and an excellent piece of work". - Mark Leier, Simon Fraser University, author of Bakunin: the creative passion

* "... one of its distinctive contributions is its global scope. Further, the book's intellectual exploration goes deep, and, "An enjoyable read, from which I have learnt a great deal - fascinating, revealing and often startling. Thanks to both and each of you". - Alan Lipman, anti-apartheid activist and exile, winner of South African Institute of Architecture's 'Award for Excellence' for the Workers Library and Museum (Johannesburg), author of On the Outside Looking In: colliding with apartheid and other authorities

* "A useful and insightful treatment of one of the most fascinating alternatives to industrial capitalism and the modern nation state. At the heart of their scholarship is an effort to provide clarity to a much maligned and misunderstood movement and also to examine it as a social history of ideas that percolated from below as well as directed from above by intellectual giants. The authors are careful to present their analysis in a jargon-free language. Readers will be introduced to influential historical actors from across the globe. A grand work of synthesis. An excellent starting point". - Greg Hall, Western Illinois University, author of Harvest Wobblies: The Industrial Workers of the World and Agricultural Laborers in the American West, 1905-1930, in WorkingUSA

* "Brilliant, a really wonderful book and an outstanding contribution to anarchist theory and history. What does Black Flame get right? Well, almost everything! It is comprehensive, discussing all important issues, people and movements, and the authors do a great job in discussing the ins and outs of our movement and theory, using history to illuminate the ideas and show how they were applied in practice. Do yourself a favour and buy it now! You won't be disappointed".- Iain McKay, author of The Anarchist FAQ, volume 1

* "This highly worthwhile book represents the fruit of considerable scholarship and deep reflection. The authors have done a remarkable job in drawing together a vast international body of literature, showing convincingly that anarchism and syndicalism were far more significant political forces than historians have generally given them credit for, and providing excellent accounts of the movement's global political reach. Van der Walt and Schmidt also make a powerful and lucidly written case for anarchism as a serious and coherent political philosophy".- Jonathan Hyslop, University of the Witwatersrand, author of The Notorious Syndicalist : JT Bain, a Scottish rebel in colonial South Africa

* "Black Flame is an outstanding contribution to a modern anarchist perspective. Its view is focused on the working class but also supportive of every struggle against oppression. Besides covering the major controversies within historical anarchism in a fair way, it is particularly unique in examining anarchism from a worldwide perspective instead of looking at it only from a west European angle. I learned a good deal from reading it, and think others will also".- Wayne Price, author of The Abolition of the State: anarchist and Marxist perspectives

* "This book fulfils a daunting task. Covering anarchism in all parts of the world and emphatically tying it to class struggle, the authors present a highly original and challenging account of the movement, its actions and ideas. This work is a must for everybody interested in nonauthoritarian social movements".- Bert Altena, Rotterdam University, author of Piet Honig, Herinneringen van een Rotterdamse revolutionair

* "A well-thought out and nuanced study of the intellectual, political, and social history of anarchism".- Steven J. Hirsch, University of Pittsburgh, contributing editor, Handbook of Latin American Studies

* "The first in a two-volume mega-work called Counterpower ... the authors ... use their conceptual rubric to demonstrate conclusively the coherent international character of the Anarchist movement, a welcome antidote to Eurocentric accounts of the movement and its history. We can't wait for volume 2!" - Red Emma's Bookstore Coffee House, Baltimore