Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Found the internet!
Vote

So I just re-read the first book, and I began to wonder what lead up to the decision to move the stone to hogwarts in the first place... And I have some questions... Lets play follow the stone...

We know that Quirrell, with the help of Voldemort who was at the time possessing Quirrell, made an attempt to steal the stone from Gringotts. This attempt failed due to Hagrid taking the stone out of its vault before Quirrell could get to it, on Dumbledore order to do so.

  1. What prompted Dumbledore to think of moving the stone? What piece of evidence or intelligence did he receive to make him think Gringotts was no longer a safe place?

  2. How did Dumbledore know someone was after the stone in the first place? What events took place to tell both Dumbledore and Flamel that the stone was no longer safe in France? Was there an attempt at stealing the stone earlier? Why did Flamel make the choice to move it to Gringotts? Was there an early indication that it was Voldemort, or was that only revealed once Harry faced him at the end of the book?

  3. Did the Mirror of Erised contain the Stone the first time Harry encountered the mirror? Or was there yet another prompting for Dumbledore to enhance the stone's protection? Was Dumbledore simply on his way to retrieve the mirror, for the purpose of hiding the stone within it, when he ran into Harry using the mirror?

We know the Guardians had already been set up by Halloween as evidence of the troll and Fluffy. But if the Mirror was not down there at the time, as proof by Harry finding the mirror after Christmas, where was the stone, really the first half of the book? Dumbledore's office? Somewhere else safe?

Vote
0 comments

About Community

Welcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression.
1.1m

Witches & Wizards

1.5k

on The Marauder's Map


Created Jun 12, 2008

Related Communities

r/HarryPotterBooks

35,569 members

r/HPfanfiction

73,771 members

r/dresdenfiles

50,151 members

r/Dramione

8,873 members

r/HarryPotterMemes

126,711 members

r/shadowhunters

15,568 members

r/camphalfblood

74,823 members

r/HarryPotterGame

27,537 members

r/harrypotterwu

40,502 members

r/Eragon

29,093 members

r/harrypotter Rules

1.
Rule #1: Don't be a jerk
2.
Rule #2: No modern politics
3.
Rule #3: No enabling piracy
4.
Rule #4: Posts must be Wizarding World related
5.
Rule #5: No sharing private information
6.
Rule #6: No monetary exchanges
7.
Rule #7: No ticket sales
8.
Rule #8: No outside chatrooms
9.
Rule #9: No pornographic images of any kind
10.
Rule #10: Follow Reddit's Rules and Reddiquette
11.
Rule #11: Violates Discussion Week
12.
Rule #12: Spoilers

Moderators

Moderator list hidden.Â?Learn More