Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Log In
Found the internet!
r/DCcomics
26
Posted by2 months ago

[Discussion] Why does Captain Atom have a different design on Earth 4? It seems like they’re going for the classic designs but the list at the end states that it’s still Pax Americana. [Dark Crisis: Big Bang]

[Dark Crisis: Big Bang]
9 comments
100% Upvoted
|
level 1
· 2 mo. ago
Legion of Superheroes

My meta-assumption is that Mark Waid decided that if DC is willing to use the Watchmen characters now, that having a "Like Watchmen, only using the original characters" universe no longer made as much sense, and reverted the Charlton characters back to their default forms.

23
level 1

One possibility is that it’s a miscommunication about what designs they’re using.

17
level 1

I don't know wrong coloring or maybey something happened on his earth that we will discover in a Elsworld

8
level 1

Probably just a mistake or them deciding that after the multiversity story earth 4 becomes closer to the classic earth 4

7
level 1

Given the nature of his power, he might just look however he wants.

6
level 1
· 2 mo. ago
Comics Theory Poster

Could just be a mistake. Or it’s the same Earth but (anti-)rebooted/altered to its classic self, just like Earth 0.

Alternatively, the Manhattan-esque Allen Adam disappeared/died in Pax Americana. This could be a new Captain Atom.

5
level 1

Flash was simultaneously traveling through time and arrived on Earth 4 at a time before Captain Atom evolved into his final form, problem solved!

3
level 1
· 2 mo. ago · edited 2 mo. ago
"What a lucky man I was."

Let's face it, like the Watchmen story it so heavily riffs on before it, Pax Americana is really self-contained. I feel like not much cam be meaningfully added to it.

So to me, it makes sense that Pax would get a throwaway reference in a list, while remaining a firmly tertiary influence on most writers' approach to the Charlton Action Heroes.

Er, especially as the actual Watchmen characters are running around DC now, to my chagrin.

3
level 1

My guess is the earth 4 design is based on dr Manhattan from watchmen, who was inspired by Captain Atom. I could be completely wrong though.

2

About Community

The unofficial DC Comics Subreddit A place for fans of DC's comics, graphic novels, movies, and anything else related to one of the largest comic book publishers in the world and home of the World's Greatest Superheroes! Featuring weekly comic release discussions, creator AMAs, a friendly and helpful userbase, and much more!
Created Aug 26, 2008

961k

Justice League Members

1.2k

On Patrol

Top 1%

Ranked by Size