A Chicken Is Not Pillage

Regulation Is Killing Montana!

Since 2009, it has been a frequent refrain from the TEApeeps in this fine state that Montana is losing jobs and opportunity to our neighbors.  "We are over-taxed", they warn.  "We are over-regulated!" they shout.  "WE ARE OVERBURDENED" is their lament.  "We are rhetorical over-wrought" would be the only true thing they could say, and never will.

Being a denizen of Bozeman, it's been remarkably difficult for me to take such caterwaul at all seriously.  As it happens, one shouldn't take the TEApeep's prognostications seriously.  Not one bit.

Montana is first in the nation for entrepreneurial start ups.   Not Wyoming, not NoDak, not Idaho.  We were 17th in 2011.  That's quite a jump in a year.  If eight years of Schweitzer's bullying and regulatory madness (!) didn't kill opportunity in this state, then it appears we are going to be just fine.

If You Love Montana

Then you would be well served to read Wilder Than A Grizzly's Dream.

Every once in a while you encounter a blog site where the author truly loves what they are writing about.  David Sherman, when writing about Greater Falls,  Prairie Mary, D. Gregory Smith at From Eternity To Here, Boing Boing, Wil Wheaton, some very few political blogs  ...

Even rarer still is encountering the blog where the writer not only loves their subject but writes for those who can't help but love it as well.  Whether the readers love Montana as much as Nameless Range or not doesn't matter.  This author inspires  a love of subject, a love of Montana.  In just several short weeks, I find myself checking the site several times a day, almost desperate for a new post.

This is the really honest and joyful deal.  Wilder Than a Grizzly's Dream.  Please, link it and read it.

This Will End Well

There's a thoroughly enjoyable article in the Missoulian today concerning the atlatl and atlatl hunting.  I suggest that all give it a read.

Smiles and frivolity aside, however, I have a concern here that no one seems to want to address just yet.  No, it isn't that Hinkle's SB 112 is a frivolous waste of the legislature's valuable time.  A great deal of verbiage has already been spent on that score.  My complaint isn't that this bill would only favor the rare hobbyist like Atlatl Bob.  No, my concern is born of a healthy respect for weapons of any kind, and hunting as the killing endeavor that it is.

Sometime about 15 years ago (?), the state of Montana decided that bow hunters needed to attend and pass a bow hunter's safety course before getting a license to hunt.  Yes, I'm quite well aware that bow hunters who had previously had such a license (and could prove it) were grandfathered in.  Unless legally prohibited, any Montana resident above the age of 18 can get a rifle license.  But you have to pass bow's hunter's safety to get your bow license, regardless of hunting experience or experience shooting a bow.  The reasons stated were these.  A bow and arrow, though not as lethal as a rifle at distance, are more difficult to aim and shoot making bow hunting a greater hazard for other hunters.  An arrow, quite physically, does not have the killing capacity of a bullet, which ups the number of wounded and wasted prey animals.  Bow hunting has a private season and thus requires different training, camouflage and the like.  Yeah, I know that last one is kinda silly.  I thought so too at the time.

If one wants to train with a bow, there's plenty of places to do it.   There are archery ranges, stump shooting in National Forests.  Hell, if you have appropriate safety and your squeamish neighbors don't complain, you can probably do it in your back yard.  Atlatls are a different beasty.  They require more room at the point of launch, and they are a much harder weapon to get even an approximation of accuracy with.  That whole "know your target and beyond" thingy goes right out the window with a weapon one is just learning to use.  (For the record, yes, I've used an atlatl.  I wasn't teh awful, but accuracy takes a lot of practice.  I got pretty good at hurling a stick 50 yards with no discernible point of target.  These things require training for the safety of oneself and anyone downrange.) 

Hinkle's bill would allow anyone, novice or otherwise, to buy a rifle license and pick up a spear, dart or sharpened stick.  And you, my hunting friends, get to share the woods with these armed individuals.  The saving grace is that one can only hunt with a spear/dart during rifle season, so they have to wear orange, just like the rest of us.  Most bow hunters I know give up the bow during rifle season, because by the time they've crept within range of the game, some dude or dudette with a .308 has already planted the animal.  Atlatl hunting during rifle season would be at best useless, (unless you're hunting in your own private back 40, and why the hell do we need a law for that?).  At worst, it would be dangerous to those sharing the woods around our modern Neanderthals.

So I really want to know when the state will mandate atlatl hunter's safety ...

Compare And Contrast

This is Kootenai Creek, first week of August, 2006.  Below is Kootenai Creek, first week of July, 2007.  I can sure as hell tell you which is better fishing ...

Taking Montana Back, One Riverbed At A Time

Anyone who knows anything of the history of Montana knows that it was built on the labor of those who live here for the benefit of those who Judy Martz proudly claimed to be a lap-dog for.  Others have come and bought our state and our lives, because ownership here isn't about use but about control and exploitation.

I could not have been more happy to read this story about PacifiCorp settling the lawsuit against them for ownership of the state's lands.  Before anyone starts, please hear me clearly.  I don't don't give one salient shit about the fact that the land is a muddy river bottom.  It's ours, and if you want to profit from it, you ought to have to pay for the privelage.   PacifiCorp  will pay a pittence (really) in order to use our land to generate profit.  I am, honestly, proud of them and of our AG McGrath, for recognizing that our state does not stand alone in offering itself for others to plunder.  It's good to be the Treasure State, but not when others are pillaging the treasure.

PP&L, on the other hand, still have no problem with geographic slavery.  (Yeah, that's probably a bit of hyperbole ... just cope.)  As long as Washington DC told them that they own Montana's ass, they're perfectly happy to use our state at will for their gain.  Their spokes-tool had this to spew:

"We still firmly believe these projects are governed by the federal licenses that have been acquired," spokesman David Hoffman said. "We really do think it's a federal pre-emption issue."

Well, there you have it.  As long as the Feds have said it's okay to rape the state, they're damn well going to do it.  It's a "federal pre-emption issue".  Montana owes the country our land and service, just as it did in the days of the Copper Kings.  Seriously, Montana, haven't we had enough of this shit?

Do I really need to point out that this wouldn't have been an issue under Montana Power?  No, I didn't think so.

The Montana Weblog Awards 2006 - Results

All listed blogs are followed by the number of votes received.  Ties are presented in alphabetical order.  Only weblogs or posts which received votes in any category are presented.  And now,  without commentary save a final "Thank You" to all who participated, the results:

Under the Heading of Political Blogs:

Best Left Leaning Blog:

    A Chicken Is Not Pillage - 22
    4 & 20 Blackbirds - 5
    Left In The West - 4
    Intelligent Discontent -1
    Montana Netroots - 1
    Speedkill - 1

Best Right Leaning Blog:

    MT Politics - 13
    Electric City Weblog - 11
    Montana Misanthrope - 4
    The Hammond Report - 1

Best Independent or Libertarian Blog:

   

    Dave Budge - 13
    The Last Best Place - 10
    Pragmatic Revolt - 9

Best Political Blog:

    Left In The West - 14
    MT Politics - 7
    4 & 20 Blackbirds - 3
    Montana Netroots - 3
    Intelligent Discontent - 2

Blog That Had The Most Impact on the Elections of 2006:

    Electric City Weblog - 18
    Left In The West - 10
     4 & 20 Blackbirds - 2

Under the Heading of Culture:

Montana Blog that best represents popular culture:

    Better Living Through Blogging - 13
    Thoughts From The Middle Of Nowhere - 9
    City Lights - 7
    Bah Weep Grahna Weep Ninny Bon - 3
    Patia Stephens/ A Drivel Runs Through It - 3

Best Montana History Blog:

    A History of Montana By Kodak - 20
    Karbon Kounty Moos - 6
    Prairie Mary - 5
    Electric City Weblog - 2

Blog That Best Represents a Montana Lifestyle:    

    Thoughts From The Middle of Nowhere - 21
    Karbon Kounty Moos - 8
    A Chicken Is Not Pillage - 5
    What I Think (as if you give a damn) - 3
    Pragmatic Revolt - 1

Under the Heading of Creativity:

Most Creative Montana Blog: TIE

    Raven's Nest - 10
    Watermark - 10
    MOTTO - 7
    Patia Stephens/ A Drivel Runs Through It - 5

Best Photography:

   Thoughts From The Middle Of Nowhere - 18
    Bitterroot and Bergamot - 10
    Karbon Kounty Moos - 4
    Land Of Little Rain - 3
    Out There With Tom - 2
    A History Of Montana By Kodak - 1

Best Written Montana Blog:

   

    A Chicken Is Not Pillage - 10
    City Lights - 9
    4 & 20 Blackbirds - 6
    Dave Budge - 3
    Watermark - 3

Most Humorous Montana Blog: 

    A Secular Franciscan Life - 18
    The Monkey Cage - 9
    Bah Weep Grahna Weep Ninny Bon - 3

Best Post:

    You didn't think I Gave it up, Did you?, Great Falls Firefly - 6
    Playground Politics, Rebels Are We - 4
    Truly Tragic, A Chicken Is Not Pillage - 4
    In My Kitchen, Great Falls Firefly - 3
    Do Religious Leaders On The Right Have a Political Agenda?, Wrong Dogs Life Chest - 2
    Electability Revisited, A Chicken Is Not Pillage - 2
    Breaking The 'Cone Of Silence', The Internal Filter - 1
    New Jersey, Gay Marriage and Social Conservatism, 4 & 20 Blackbirds - 1
    The Secret Reason Why Nobody Writes Good War Stories Anymore, Pop Snark Hooligan - 1
    Weekend Coffee, MOTTO - 1
    Wherein OCG Makes A Complete Fool Of Herself At Walmart, One Crue Girl - 1

Best Series Of Posts:

    A History Lesson, Electric City Weblog - 15
    Cece-in-Montana's coverage of the Ballot Initiatives, Cece-in-Montana - 10
    No Mandatory Animal ID, Thoughts From The Middle Of Nowhere   - 3
    The Political Dictionary, Rebels Are We - 1
    The Bischoff Chronicles, MT Politics - 1

I invite commentary about the results in comments or elsewhere.  If you have comments concerning the process or future of the Montana Weblog Awards, please leave them here, or in the comments to this thread below.  I will attempt to keep up with the comments, but it is highly doubtful I will post again before next week.  So, I wish you all the very best NEW YEAR possible.  May 2007 be bright for us all.

Tha Ballots Are In

All ballots for the Montana Weblog Awards 2006 have been received and are now undergoing the officially mandated recount (I double check my work to make certain I didn't do anything stupid).  I should post the results tomorrow.

However, I did want to present a few demographics and thoughts for your contemplation.  There were a total of 49 ballots submitted, a rather substantial increase over the 28 from last year.  Votes were cast from as far away as New Zealand and France.    There were 4 ballots cast from persons who's location I couldn't identify, and 8 from bloggers or readers from other states.  That left 37 ballots coming in from Montanans, with 25 of those coming from Montana bloggers.

This is only a well-founded guess, but the ballots submitted from out of state (and from those in-state by those who do not have blogs) appeared to be  all in response to Montana bloggers who have a wide appeal beyond our borders, and advertised the awards to their readers.  Most of those ballots were rather limited in the number of categories they voted in, and the number of websites that they voted for.  There isn't more that I can state definitively, but it's pretty obvious that Mike, Sharon and a certain Sam from a certain creek have a very broad readership.

There were only 15 ballots that were designated 'full', with votes cast in all 14 categories.  The break down among the 34 partial ballots is a lot harder to get a handle on.  Some of those partial ballots only skipped one or two categories, where others were single-website or single-issue votes.  There were 3 single-issue voters, people who voted for only one website in one category.  To those of you who received votes from those folks, trust me, you got fans!  There were 7 ballots from those who voted for only one website in multiple categories.  The rest of the partials were very disparate in quantity of votes and focus of that voting. 

Note this, however, most of the partial ballots focused far more on the cultural and creative categories than on the political.  Surprisingly (at least to me) was that among those partials that did deal with the 5 political categories, very few of the ballots broke on partisan lines.  With no more than 4 exceptions, people were willing to vote on left-leaning websites and right-leaning websites.  I realize that this is my own bit of projection here, but it is my hope that Montanans tend to be more egalitarian in their reading than many other places.

Many of the people who added comments expressed the difficulty of choosing in some categories.  I couldn't agree more, and the voting reflects that.  We have some terrific websites in this here state, and anyone who was nominated for anything should be justifiably proud of the level of competition.  I personally liked the nomination format used this year, simply because it set a standard of agreement that could be reached.  Honestly, this felt a lot less like herding cats and a lot more like reviewing the best of the best.

To all who were nominated, congratulations!  I extend that especially to the youngest websites on the ballot, sites like MOTTO and Pragmatic Revolt.  To all who voted, I extend my sincerest thanks.  I hope that you all appreciate the creativity and effort of the Montana webloggers, and continue to find the newest, brightest and best to read in the coming year.

My Ballot - 2006

I figured that maybe I'd best get this in before the deadline.  I just want everyone to know that, especially since I've become something of an authority on Montana websites, this was every bit as hard for me as it was for you.  This was one terrific bunch of candidates, and choosing from among them is almost ... painful.  But, here 'goes ...

Under the Heading of Political Blogs:

Best Left Leaning Blog:
 
   Left In The West
    

Best Right Leaning Blog:

    MT Politics
   
(Though I'm quickly becoming a huge fan of The Montana Misanthrope.)
 

Best Independent or Libertarian Blog:

  AHHHG!  This choice burns!   But if I have to choose,

     Pragmatic Revolt
   
Moorcat is just so engaged in the blogging community and Montana life, and writes so personally that he gets the nod this year.

Best Political Blog:

    Left In The West
   
 

Blog That Had The Most Impact on the Elections of 2006:
 
    Electric City Weblog

 

Under the Heading of Culture:

Montana Blog that best represents popular culture:

    Better Living Through Blogging

Best Montana History Blog:
 
    Prairie Mary

Blog That Best Represents a Montana Lifestyle:
 
    What I Think (as if you give a damn)

By a mere whisker over Thoughts From the Middle Of Nowhere.

Under the Heading of Creativity:

Most Creative Montana Blog:
 
    Raven's Nest

Best Photography:
 
    Bitterroot and Bergamot

Best Written Montana Blog:
 
    Dave Budge
 

Most Humorous Montana Blog:
 
    A Secular Franciscan Life

 

Best Post:

    Playground Politics, Rebels Are We
   
Best Series of Posts:

    No Mandatory Animal ID, Thoughts From The Middle Of Nowhere

   

Montana Weblog Awards 2006 - Nominees - Perhaps I Wasn't Clear

Folks, it appears that many of you are logging your final votes early.  Let's not do that, okay?

The call has gone out for nominations.  Many blogs you may have not considered for a category, others have.  We need a range of selections in each category to go head to head in the final count.  Honestly, so far it has been pretty scattergun.  Holding to the standard of three nominations to be viable (and three viable candidates in each category) we have only three  categories that can go forward.  So please, read up on the Montana blogs.  You're allowed to choose up to three candidates for each category.  So please, let me know who shines in each category, and we'll pick the shiniest later.

If you need inspiration, perhaps to read blogs you've never reviewed before, I offer these Montana blog-rolls:

The BigSky Blogroll

Montana Bloggers list (to the right side) on A  History Of Montana By Kodak.

The vote for the best of the websites in the best of the states begins next week, but for that to happen, we need the nominees.  So,  Feed Me, Seymour!

Montana Weblog Awards 2006 - Nominees

I wasn't going to do this.  Seriously, I wasn't.  But I kinda' have to.  Tradition and all that nonsense.  It must be done, so let's do it.

Announcing the Montana Weblog Awards for the year 2006.  Things are a bit different this year, so let me explain.  I have several categories, organized under general headings,  and for the next week, one week only, I am calling for nominees in those categories.  Responses are required in email to [email protected] or  comments at this website.  No category will be displayed for the final vote if there are not more than 3 nominees.  You may nominate up to 3 in each category.  Any submission that nominates more than 3 per category will be dismissed.  Clear enough?  If it's not, then email me, and I will explain.

Heading:  Political

Categories:

Best left leaning blog.
Best right leaning blog.
Best independent or libertarian blog.
Best Political blog.
Blog that had the most impact on the 2006 elections.

Heading: Culture

Categories:

Montana Blog that best represents popular culture.
Best Montana history blog.
Most exemplifies Montana lifestyle.

Heading: Creativity

Categories:

Most creative Montana blog.
Best photographic Montana blog.
Best written Montana blog.
Most humorous Montana blog.

Heading:  Special

Categories:

Best post. (include a link, please.)
Best series of posts relating to given topic.

There.  That's only 14 things that one must nominate for.  One week, and then the real voting begins.  Let's have the nominees, folks.

And just for the record, YES! you may nominate yourself for any category.  No need to be bashful, folks.