Press J to jump to the feed. Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts
Found the internet!
28
pinned by moderators
Posted by6 days ago
28
61 comments
324
Posted by2 days ago
324
237 comments
1.2k
Posted by13 hours ago

I was watching Band of Brothers, in particular the attack on Brècourt and I've always wondered how high ranking officers such as Majors / Colonels / X Generals got past the beaches on D-Day. I noticed that Lieutenant Winter's had been issued commands from a Lieutenant Colonel (I think) at the rallying point and I wondered how such a high ranking officer got to his geographical position without having to face some action?

My understanding is that you generally wouldn't see action if you were a Battalion XO or above, I'm curious how that dynamic worked on D-Day since they were storming the front?

I believe there was a story of a general (Norman Cota) who stormed the beaches, but I always thought that was just a once off to help moralize the troops. It would be interesting to know how your every day high ranking officer experienced D-Day.

1.2k
350 comments
Vote
promoted
Helpful2Wholesome3Silver
View Comments
Play
0:00
0:00
Settings
Fullscreen
Vote
0 comments
159
Posted by21 hours ago

I grew up in the fairly conservative educational environment of Zel Miller's Georgia in the 90s. During Georgia History, in the module on Cherokee history, the focus was on Andrew Jackson being an all around bad guy with no redeeming qualities, who was responsible for the trail of tears. Later in US history we were taught about how it was even worse because the Creek and Cherokee tribes helped him defeat the the English in the war of 1812. His success against the English helped him to gain wealth, and later to win the presidency and that him forcing all but a small few who sold out their kin off of the land was a personal betrayal to the very people who had put him in power.

Going off of these notions I figured it would be easy to find lots of examples of how he was a really bad president, and I was surprised that I'd never heard that:

  1. He almost sent the US to war with France because they refused to pay off debts they owed, and they backed down after England begged them not to start another war with the US.

  2. He won the election of 1824 against the secretary of state John Quincy Adams, the Speaker of the House Henry Clay, and a Georgian named William Crawford in the popular vote and in the electoral college, but didn't get enough electoral votes to get the Majority. the House of Representatives would have to vote for president with a single vote for each state. Adams won the vote and made Clay his Secretary of State, and Jackson claimed that Clay had approached him and offered to back him and have his supporters back him if he agreed to make him "Secy", and when he declined, Clay threw his support behind Adams, winning him the presidency. As a result of this he had a career long goal of abolishing the electoral college and setting up US elections as a popular vote.

  3. He believed that Adams had fumbled agreements with the Spanish and given Texas to them despite it being part of the Louisiana Purchase and he wanted Texas badly. He was opposed to violating the US treaty with Mexico and fired his Mexican ambassador for trying to bribe Mexican officials into giving the land to the US without using the proper channels to get it. He was angry with Sam Houston, who he called a "former friend" after the fact, and Stephen Austin for taking Texas by force, and refused to aid them against Mexican soldiers and ships afterward. He was adamant about proving to Santa Anna that the US did not support or recognize the independence of Texas and did not aid them.

  4. After the nation of Texas was more well established, he refused to annex or admit it into the US out of fears that another pro-slave state would cause uproar and possibly lead to a civil war, despite being the orphan of poor Irish immigrants who got rich selling and trading slaves, who was known for being especially brutal to slaves.

  5. His primary work while in office was to oppose the Second Bank of the United States which was their equivalent of the federal reserve at the time. He was a populist who claimed the Bank’s charter gave the institution too much power over the nation’s financial markets, he argued—power that enabled it to generate huge profits for its stockholders, most of whom were “foreigners” and “our own opulent citizens.” “If we must have a bank with private stockholders, every consideration of sound policy and every impulse of American feeling admonishes that it should be purely American,” Jackson wrote. Daniel Webster and Henry Clay fought hard to protect the bank and Clay ran in opposition of Jackson for his second term expressly to protect its interests. He wrote that “It is to be regretted that the rich and powerful too often bend the acts of government to their selfish purposes,” and that "This was unjust and dangerous to the humble members of society—the farmers, mechanics and laborers—who have neither the time nor the means of securing like favors to themselves.”

After learning all this I am surprised more about him isn't common knowledge, I've never even heard Texans talk about his negative attitude towards their beloved fight for independence.

Does anyone think the Fed put him on the $20 bill out of spite?

159
112 comments
1.1k
Posted by1 day ago

From my limited knowledge, cooking and baking began in most civilizations as a trade that not every family was required or had the technology/resources to prepare on their own. At what point (per civilization) were the majority of meals prepared and consumed inside the home?

Also, any information about a particular civilizations would be greatly appreciated. It's near impossible to imagine anyone having an answer for every human civilization on the planet, any and all information is greatly appreciated! However, if certain areas of the world still predominantly eat outside the home based on competitive pricing from street vendors, please feel free to clarify as well.

1.1k
224 comments
19.4k
Posted by4 days ago
GoldWholesome
19.4k
431 comments

About Community

/r/History is a place for discussions about history. Feel free to submit interesting articles, tell us about this cool book you just read, or start a discussion about who everyone's favorite figure of minor French nobility is! ------------------------------------------------------------ This is a somewhat more serious subreddit compared to many others. Make sure to familiarize yourself with our rules and guidelines before participating. Thanks!
16.9m

Members

1.5k

Online


Created Jan 25, 2008
r/history topics

Related Communities

r/noveltranslations

100,006 members

r/badhistory

275,181 members

r/bookclub

138,928 members

r/suggestmeabook

2,161,529 members

r/booksuggestions

603,583 members

r/books

21,135,327 members

r/literature

1,887,171 members

r/AskHistory

96,906 members

r/solotravel

2,303,605 members

r/CriticalTheory

113,943 members

Mod applications

We are looking for new moderators, click the button for more information.

Introduction

/r/History is a place for discussions about history. Feel free to submit interesting articles, tell us about this cool book you just read, or start a discussion about who everyone's favorite figure of minor French nobility is!

Moderation policy

All posts will be reviewed by a human moderator first before they become visible to all subscribers on the subreddit.

The full rules and guidelines for /r/history can be found here

AMAs & Events

r/history Rules

1.
Rule 1: Keep it civil!
2.
Rule 2: No current politics or soapboxing
3.
Rule3: No historical negationism or denialism
4.
Rule 4: Comments should be on-topic and contribute to the conversation in a meaningful way
5.
Rule 5: Discussions limited to events over 20 years ago
6.
Rule 6: Post in the right subreddit
7.
Rule 7: Follow the rules and guidelines of reddit
8.
Rule 8: Post from the original site.
9.
Rule 9: Text posts require a descriptive body text
10.
Rule 10: Titles of links should accurately describe the content not be sensationalized or misleading
11.
No Atrocity Olympics
12.
No Memorabilia, Family History, or Genealogy.
13.
This is an actively moderated subreddit and calls will be made at the moderator's discretion
14.
A full set of our rules and guidelines can be found on our wiki

Moderators

Moderator list hidden. Learn More