Capitol Riots
-
2/21/2021
Must the Capitol Riots be Included in the Legacy of American Dissent?
by Ralph Young
Teachers of history might feel a disconnect between praising American traditions of dissent and condemning the Capitol riots. They shouldn't. Historical evaluation of the grievances of dissenters, whatever their methods, finds real grievances, not lies, at the root of dissent.
-
SOURCE: Washington Post
2/18/2021
The 150-Year-Old Ku Klux Klan Act Being Used Against Trump In Capitol Attack
Ulysses S. Grant championed legislation to apply the power of the federal government against armed conspiracies to prevent the exercise of the vote. A Mississippi Congressman is now suing Donald Trump and Rudy Giuliani under a provision of the law that allows victims to file civil lawsuits against conspirators.
-
SOURCE: Daily Kos
2/13/2021
Assassination, Secession, Insurrection: The Crimes of John Wilkes Booth, Jefferson Davis, and Trump
The use of force to thwart democracy is a thread connecting Confederate secession, Booth's assassination of Lincoln, and the Capitol riots against the certification of Trump's electoral defeat.
-
2/7/2021
Not the First Mob Attack on the Government in D.C.
by Stan M. Haynes
An angry mob threatened John Tyler and his family in the White House and burnt him in effigy on the grounds after he vetoed the Whig Party's bill for a second Bank of the United States in 1841, leading Congress to authorize a night police patrol for the District of Columbia.
-
2/7/2021
To Save Democracy, We Need Historical Memory to be "Hot"
by Shannon Bontrager
Historical memory can run hot or cold; hot memory, when we make ourselves vulnerable to the pain of the past, is a force that will ensure America doesn't just move on from the needless death of the COVID pandemic or the violence of the Capitol insurrection without committing to justice and accountability.
-
2/7/2021
Weaponized Whiteness: Invisible Hand and Iron Fist
by Fran Shor
There is a link between the summer's BLM protests and the Capitol riots. Both reflect a crisis of a political order based on the maintenance of white supremacy and nonwhite subordination through the "invisible hand" of institutions.
-
SOURCE: Just Security
2/4/2021
Movie at the Ellipse: A Study in Fascist Propaganda
by Jason Stanley
Not enough attention has been paid to the video shown to spectators at Donald Trump's January 6th "Save America" rally. A close look shows it to be a work of propaganda firmly in the tradition of fascism.
-
1/31/2021
Democracy, Violence, and the Legacy of the American Revolution
by David W. Houpt
Although many of the Capitol rioters claimed to defend the Constitution, their actions reflect ideas derived from the Revolutionary period that the people have the right to resist tyranny by force. The Constitution sought to check that impulse by establishing a representative republic and a cultural bargain to live by the results of elections, but the two ideas have never been resolved.
-
SOURCE: Age of Revolutions
1/22/2021
4 Cautionary Tales from the French Revolution
by Christine Adams
A historian of revolutionary France argues that the period presents cautions about the prevalence of disinformation, the potential of rhetoric to incite, the folly of blaming singular figures for broad trends and movements, and the cynicism that flows from efforts to undermine the legitimacy of democratic institutions.
-
SOURCE: New York Times
1/25/2021
After the Capitol Was Stormed, Teachers Try Explaining History in Real Time
The eruption of political violence at the US Capitol has challenged teachers of history and civics at all grade levels and pushed teachers of other subjects to respond to their students' experience of confusion, anger, or sadness.
-
SOURCE: NPR
1/15/2021
When White Extremism Seeps Into The Mainstream
Historian Kathleen Belew discusses the history of the far right and the work of separating the hard core of the movement from its fringes and those who might be persuaded to join it.
-
SOURCE: CNN
1/24/2021
Trump is Not a Fascist. But that Didn't Make Him any Less Dangerous to Our Democracy
by Thomas Weber
Hitler and Trump, along with fascism and Trumpism, are all destructive to liberal democracy but in fundamentally different ways.
-
SOURCE: Vox
1/14/2021
What the History of the Ku Klux Klan Can Teach Us about the Capitol Riot
Historian Linda Gordon urges readers to recognize that the Klan has always drawn from "respectable" members of white society, giving it a dangerous ability to claim to represent real American values.
-
SOURCE: Vox
1/15/2021
White Women’s Role In White Supremacy, Explained
Historian Stephanie Jones-Rogers and author Seyward Darby explain why the presence of women among the Capitol rioters should not be surprising.
-
SOURCE: Washington Post
1/12/2021
New Revelations about Trump’s Cruelty Demand a Bigger Response
Eric Foner discusses the application of the 14th Amendment to prevent Trump or any other officials implicated in inciting the attack on the Capitol from holding public office in Post commentator Greg Sargent's column.
-
SOURCE: Conference on Faith & History
1/13/2020
Resolution of the Conference on Faith and History: Executive Board Response to the Assault on the U.S. Capitol
The global organization of scholars of the relationship between Christian faith and history has issued a statement condemning the Capitol riots as "a gross violation of the principles of the gospel of Jesus Christ."
-
1/14/2021
Banana Republic or Nut Country? January 6 Put American Exceptionalism in Perspective
by Frank P. Barajas
American political elites have responsed to the Capitol riot by comparing it unfavorably to something that would happen in a "banana republic." The historical record of American interference in Latin America and of our own domestic tumults shows that we may not be bananas, but have had our fair share of nuts.
-
SOURCE: Hechinger Report
1/13/2020
A U.S. History Teacher Scrambles to Explain Unprecedented Attacks and Desecration of Democracy
by Jim Cullen
"Our job as educators is to make and model good, conscious choices about what we believe, and to make that necessarily fallible belief system as transparent as we can for students without insisting that they share it."
-
SOURCE: Washington Post
11/12/2021
Impeachment May Not Work. Here’s the Next Best Way to Dump Trump
by Eric Foner
The 14th Amendment empowers Congress to bar persons involved in insurrection against the United States from holding office. This can't remove Trump, but it can stop him (and anyone found to have plotted the Capitol rioting) from returning to office.
-
SOURCE: New York Times
1/7/2020
"Sedition": A Complicated History
Joanne Freeman, Annette Gordon-Reed, Manisha Sinha and Gregory Downs offer insight into the history of the term "sedition," the relationship between speech and deed, and the specific context of white supremacy that has accompanied discussions of sedition since the overthrow of reconstruction.