INCLUDES (in this order):
-
Before we begin, a key detail is
that ‘lesbian’ originally was a synonym for ‘tribade’, meaning any woman who
was intimate with another woman. Lesbianism was something someone did. You
could have been ‘a lesbian’ and be romantically involved with a boy. Think of
‘lesbian’ and ‘lesbianism’ in these early times as being a synonym for ‘WLW’
(women loving women); a blanket term. It wasn’t until 1892 that neurologists
used bisexual. And even then, it wasn’t until the 1960s (and no sooner) that the usage of ‘bi’ became common in a
non-academic context. It wasn’t until 1988 that bisexual women and lesbians
were ‘officially’ separated (though the movement to separate them began
beforehand), and it was also this time that ‘lesbian’ began to mean ‘a woman
exclusively attracted to women.’
The coining of the term ‘femme’ is often
accredited to historical lesbian, Anne Lister. However, what is often left out
of this statement is that the original use of ‘femme’ in the context of describing
her partner, Marianna Lawton, who was also involved with a man. It wasn’t even
Anne Lister saying it; rather, it was a woman friend who said to Anne about
Marianna, ‘Plus femme que moi,’ which translates to, ‘She is more womanly than
me.’ If one is saying that ‘femme’ was coined by Anne Lister, they are also
saying that ‘femme’ was originally directed at and used to describe a woman who
had some sort of romantic relationship with a man.
Butch was a term coined by gay
men to mean ‘masculine’ in a type of slang called Polari, otherwise known as
Palare. Whilest the exact timeframe of this phrase becoming popularized is
unclear, it was popular before the radical feminist movement had separated
lesbians and bisexual women, meaning that, even if it did mean ‘masculine
lesbian’, it would refer to all WLW, as that is what ‘lesbian’ meant at the
time. Butch came into common use with lesbians in the 1940s; again, before the
separationist movement came to split up the WLW community into ‘lesbians’ and
‘bisexuals’. There were plenty of butch non-monosexuals (which was the term
back then for what we now know as bisexuality).
Some sources also say that
‘femme’ and ‘butch’ arose, not from Anne Lister or Polari, but from
lesbian-only gay bars, starting around the 1940s. However, ‘lesbian’, at this
point in time, was still just a term meaning ‘WLW’, which means that lesbian
bars were frequented by women exclusively attracted to women and women
attracted to multiple genders. This means that not only were bi women there
during yet another situation often accredited to coining these terms but, since
these terms would have been born from bars where bi women would have been, that
would have literally meant that bi women also helped to coin these terms, as
well.
It wasn’t until the 1960s (and no
sooner) that the word ‘lesbian’ began known as being exclusively attracted to
women, and not to men whatsoever. This part of history can be largely
attributed to TERF Shelia Jeffery’s manifesto. It says, rather bluntly, ‘Our
definition of a political lesbian is a woman-identified woman who does not
(want to be intimate with) men,’ and describes bisexual women as ‘collaborating
with the enemy’. Women who took this stance on being attracted to only women as
a political statement are often referred to as ‘political lesbians’. By the
80’s, there was a firm split between bi women and lesbians, who proceeded to ignore
the fact that the ‘traitorous’ bi women had ever been there at all. They
successfully erased bi women’s history. After all, all of their history and
culture had ‘LESBIAN’ written in big, bold, capital letters! This is why now,
people can easily think that ‘femme’ and ‘butch’ are lesbian-exclusive; because
radical feminists were purposefully trying to erase bisexual women’s part in
their history.
It is worth noting here, as well,
that, when femme and butch fell out of popular use in the 70s (the idea that
masculinity harms women, and the idea that femmes wanted to reap the benefits
of heterosexuality whilest still toying with women became popular during this
time, and androgyny was portrayed as the ideal for ‘political lesbians’), it
was kept alive by ball culture. Ball culture had been around since the 60s,
whereas it was used by lesbians and nonlesbians alike, and it is attributed
largely to LGBT+ youth of color. In this historical context, ‘femme queen’ means
‘transwoman,’ and a ‘butch queen’ means ‘gay man’. This further shows historical use
of ‘femme’ and ‘butch’ in LGBT history, outside of women exclusively attracted
to women.
And, again, on usage of ‘femme’ outside of women exclusively being attracted to women; James McDoland’s Dictionary of Obscenity, Taboo and Euphemism, published in 1988, defines ‘fem’ like this:
“Fem (col.) A passive homosexual.
The
term may be applied to both men and women, but more usually to men. It
Australia it is generally applied only to men.
It is based upon the French word
for women, femme, and indeed, in English, this
spelling is sometimes used for passive lesbians, in preference to fem.”
That’s why the claim ‘butch and
femme arose from the LESBIAN community for LESBIANS exclusively about the
LESBIAN experience’ is misleading; lesbian communities were shared with
bisexuals from the very beginning. ‘Lesbian’ meant all WLW. So, that means that
butch and femme arose from the WLW community for WLW exclusively about the WLW
experience. Heck, with ball culture and Polari in mind, it can be argued that
it isn’t even exclusively a WLW term, historically. Bi women who are attracted
to women and lesbians share the exact same history; the same history which
created these terms.
SOURCES:
(Source 1) (Source 2) (Source 3) (Source 4) (Source 5) (Source 6) (Source 7) (Source 8) (Source 9) (Source 10)
And now, a FAQ, to debunk
misinformation and common biphobic sentiments!
Q: I heard that bi women called
themselves a part of the LGBT community when they were in a relationship with a
woman, but called themselves straight when with a man.
A: This is misinformation. As I
said before, ‘lesbian’ was not an identity; it was something you did. If you
ever were in a relationship with or had attraction to a woman, you were a
lesbian. They didn’t consider themselves a lesbian at some point, or straight
at another; much more common was the phrase ‘non-monosexual lesbian’, if they
even bothered to make a distinction at all. Again, I feel like I must compare
how ‘lesbian’ was used to the term ‘WLW’ nowadays; even bi women nowadays who
are in relationships with men are WLW. That’s how the term ‘lesbian’ worked.
Q: Uhhh, ‘doe’ and ‘stag’ were
LITERALLY made for this reason. Use your OWN terms.
A: Yes, you’re right. ‘Doe’ and
‘stag’ WERE made out of pressure put on bi women to not ‘steal lesbian
culture’. But do you realize how insanely dehumanizing it is to say, ‘You’re
not allowed to identify as these terms with your history behind them, go
identify as an animal instead’? Many WOC are uncomfortable with these terms,
because they are animal terms. Plus, we never should have had to make those
terms. ‘Femme’ and ‘butch’ belong to us, too. And we shouldn’t have to make up
new terms with no history behind them just so people won’t bully us for using
our terms. Bi women can identify as a stag or doe IF THEY WANT. It is not your
place to tell them how to identify.
On this subject, the creators of the
term ‘doe’ had this to say: “Why is there a perceived divide between ‘bi’ and
‘lesbian’ history? We share history. We run in the same circles. Usually
kissing!… It (doe
and tomcat discourse) exists within a framework that already posits bi women
and lesbians as exclusive circles that sometimes overlapped, when really we
have always been one circle, and radical feminism warped us… I created it (doe) as an alternative to
femme because lesbians voiced discomfort with bi women using their
self-identifiers. But what is yours and what is ours? Why are we inventing new
language when we should be consolidating, reuniting, and celebrating one
another?” (Source)
While I do not agree with everything that is said in that post, it is important
to note that even one of the creators of these terms seems to be upset about
having to create whole new terms for the bisexual community when bi women and
lesbians share so much history.
Q: Why can’t lesbians have
something to themselves for once?!
A: Please, don’t pull the
oppression competition card on me. All LGBT+ people are oppressed. It shouldn’t
be a race of who is ‘the MOST oppressed’. Lesbians have a lot to themselves, and so do bi women. This not a matter of ‘letting a group have something for themselves’, or ‘we’re the most oppressed, you take everything from us’.
This is a matter of taking back something that was purposefully and maliciously
taken away from us by biphobic radical feminists.
Q: History doesn’t matter, it’s
the NEW definition that matters, and the NEW definition means it’s a LESBIAN
identity.
A: When bi women say that they
want to identify as femme or butch, people pull out the ‘it’s always been a
lesbian term, historically’ card. When we show said people the historical
facts, people pull the, ‘it’s the NEW definition that matters’ card. Please
choose one. Besides, if the definition changed one (from all WLW to lesbians),
then it can change again, if you allow it. Plus, it’s really crappy to say, ‘I
know you used to use these terms too, and they’re a part of your history, but,
you can’t use them because we decided we don’t want you to. These are ours
now.’
Q: But you are inherently
available to men! You can’t be a butch or femme if you can be in a straight
relationship!
A: Please, think about your
wording. ‘Inherently available to men’ is a term many bi women detest. It makes
us sound like an item for men to consume whenever they wish. Bi women cannot,
by definition, be in a ‘straight relationship’, because, by her being in it,
one of the parties is not cishet. Besides, some bi women aren’t even attracted
to men (I’ve met women who are attracted to nonbinary people and women and call
themselves bi). Even if a bi woman is currently in or looking for a
relationship with a man, bi women (who didn’t have that term at the time) who
were “available to men” identified as a femme or butch, when the terms were
created and popularized.
Q: But if a man is with a woman
who says she’s a butch or femme, that’ll perpetuate the stereotype that
lesbians can be with men!
A: If a lesbian is telling a man they
wouldn’t want to be with him, they wouldn’t just say, “I am a femme/butch.” They
would say, “I am a femme/butch lesbian.” And if a man still tries to be with them
after learning they are a lesbian, he is lesbophobic. That is not bi women’s
faults. Besides, ‘femme’ and ‘butch’ are terms meant to define ourselves in our own community, not to straight men.
Q: You can’t understand what
butch and femme REALLY mean unless you’re a lesbian.
A: So, we are ‘less WLW’ than you
because we may or may not be attracted to men, so we cannot understand, is what
you are saying? Or, more so that we aren’t able to understand it, but if we
identified as lesbians, we would magically gain the ability to understand,
because we’re lesbians? Definitions of words aren’t that hard to understand. We
don’t use them because they’re ‘cool’. Bi women are not too stupid to
understand, and it’s patronizing and INCREDIBLY rude to treat us like we’re too
dumb to understand terms we helped to create.
Q: You kept talking about bi
women in that essay. What about other women who like women?
A: I talked specifically about bi
women, because that is what I am and what this blog is about. However, I
believe all WLW should be able to use butch and femme. There are also
historical contexts whereas it was used for non-WLWs (see ball culture), but,
for the most part, it has its history mostly in the WLW community.
Q: Just say you hate lesbians and
go, lesbophobe!
A: Okay, so we’re going to try
and claim that one is bigoted for literally just knowing their history now?
Nowhere here did I say lesbians COULDN’T use these terms, either, which is,
ironically, better than what femme/butch gatekeepers are trying to do. So, by
this logic, maybe I should just reply to every femme/butch gatekeeper with
‘just say you hate bi women and go’!
Q: You’re not a femme or butch if
you’re not a lesbian, no matter how much you say you are.
A: Ah, I see, we’re deciding
other’s identities for them now? Alright. What if someone decided to say that
all gay people are actually bi? By this logic, if someone decided to say, ‘Gay
people are actually bi, no matter how much they say they are gay, so nobody can
identify as gay or a lesbian anymore,’ that must make them correct!
No. It doesn’t make them correct.
Just because you decide to say ‘you can’t be this thing no matter how much you
say you are’ doesn’t mean that anybody has to listen to you, or change their
label. And, before someone attempts to take this out of context; no, I don’t
believe in my example statement. I was trying to make a comparison of a
biphobic statement to what would be a lesbophobic/homophobic statement.
Q: I didn’t read this whole thing
because it’s too long and because I think you’re wrong, and I’m not going to
try and read obviously incorrect information.
A: I’ve gotten this response
multiple times. I can’t force you to read this, but I must say that refusing to
read historical facts because you can’t stand to be provided with evidence that
you may be incorrect is extremely telling to your state of mind involving this
topic. That’s basically just covering your ears, closing your eyes, and
screaming, “LALALALA! I’M RIGHT! I CAN’T HEAR YOUUU, LALALA!”
Q: But I-
A: I’m sorry, but ‘but’ nothing.
Even if I hadn’t supplied you with a humongous essay about the history of
bisexual women and how they helped to create the culture around the words
you’re trying to keep from us, you still wouldn’t try to control how bisexual
women experience femininity or the lack thereof. Our history was purposefully
erased by radical feminists who considered us traitors. We’re taking our
history AND our terms back, and there is nothing that anyone can do to stop us.