Brexit: Hundreds of gagging orders taken out by government

(c) Sky News 2019: <a href="http://news.sky.com/story/brexit-hundreds-of-gagging-orders-taken-out-by-government-11671933">Brexit: Hundreds of gagging orders taken out by government</a>
 

Sky News can reveal that the government has taken out hundreds of gagging orders as part of its preparations for a no-deal Brexit.

The orders, formerly known as non-disclosure agreements (NDAs), are legally binding contracts to stop confidential conversations being talked about in public.

They are typically used to maintain secrecy around corporate deals or to protect intellectual property.

However, we have discovered that the use of these NDAs has become prevalent across great swathes of the UK government.

Using freedom of information requests, Sky News asked departments to reveal how many NDAs each had taken out as part of their preparations for Brexit.

All responded, although not all of them actually answered the question.

The Department for Transport (DfT) told us it had 79 separate NDAs by the end of February. Of these, we understand that around 50 had been signed in the preceding three months, at an average of around four per week.

Although the names of those involved have obviously not been made public, we understand that the DfT's gagging orders involve hauliers, public transport companies, infrastructure operators and petrol retailers.

Some told us they felt frustrated that a government "obsession with secrecy" had hindered constructive debate and exchange of information.

The Department of Health and Social Care revealed it had taken out 26 gagging orders, while the Department for Exiting the European Union confirmed it had taken out seven.

The Department for Digital, Culture, Media & Sport has fewer than five.

The Home Office refused to answer the question, saying that it would be too burdensome to research the answer.

However, Sky News has since confirmed that the Home Office has taken out at least 100 gagging orders, simply in relation to ports. It is unclear how many gagging orders it has in relation to the rest of its work.

Chief executive of the British Ports Association, Richard Ballantyne, told us: "Signing NDAs can disrupt the necessary flow of information with the wider logistics industry, who we often work very closely with, as well as with colleagues in Europe.

"We have found it difficult to share some information that may have helped smooth preparations with ports and customs authorities in Ireland and mainland Europe, who until relatively recently had reported little direct contact with authorities in the UK on this matter."

Nine departments, including the Department of Work and Pensions, the Ministry of Defence and the Department for Education, said had not taken out any NDAs in relation to Brexit.

Several others told us that the information "was not held centrally", while the Department for Business said that it was "not in the public interest" for the information to be revealed, even though the same details had been provided by every other section of government.

Others, though, were more evasive. Both the Treasury and the Department for the Environment, Fisheries and Rural Affairs, told Sky News that they had signed NDAs, but refused to elaborate on the numbers they had signed.

They said that it would be too burdensome to calculate, suggesting that it would take a worker more than two days of work to collate the information.

We spoke to many in British business who said that Whitehall's use of these gagging orders had frustrated their Brexit plans.

The Food and Drink Federation said: "One of our frustrations throughout the process of no-deal planning has been an inconsistent approach to confidentiality across government.

"Documents are often shown to us, but we're then told we cannot take them away from meetings and share them with members and more widely. This limits our ability to provide high-quality feedback.

"Where NDAs have been employed this clearly creates a two-tier relationship with industry, with some businesses being insiders and others kept out of the loop. Quite apart from the practical consequences, it is no way to build trust."

Rod McKenzie, managing director of the Road Haulage Association, said that the use of non-disclosure agreements had "hindered and frustrated" his industry.

He said: "NDAs have been used far, far too much. It is not fair and it is simply wrong to use them in this way. They are gagging trade associations like ours from telling our members about the effect of Brexit.

"I understand that government doesn't want its plans for a no-deal Brexit to end up in newspapers, but there comes a point when we have to tell our members what is actually going on, and we have been gagged from doing that on a continual basis."

The Department for Transport told Sky News: "Good government relies on practical decisions being informed by the best advice available and requires the opportunity to make a full consideration of all the available options, without threat of premature disclosure during this live process.

"The decisions involved will have wide implications for the UK, and it is absolutely vital that the process is able to proceed in a safe space, and that officials and ministers are able to have those discussions, and raise potential options and risks, necessary to fully inform the best possible policy decisions."

  • Tyson Fury set to fight undefeated Tom Schwarz in Las Vegas this summer
    News
    Evening Standard

    Tyson Fury set to fight undefeated Tom Schwarz in Las Vegas this summer

    Tyson Fury’s next fight is set to be against little-known German prospect Tom Schwarz in Las Vegas this summer. The first date of former world heavyweight champion Fury’s lucrative five-fight deal with US broadcasting giants ESPN is to take place on June 15 at the boxing capital’s Thomas and Mack Center. Schwarz is unbeaten and ranked second by the WBO organisation but is outside the top 15 with both the WBA and the WBC and is ninth with the IBF.

  • The Color Purple actress dropped from musical over homophobic comments
    News
    The Independent

    The Color Purple actress dropped from musical over homophobic comments

    UPDATE: Seyi Omooba has been dropped from The Color Purple‘s UK revival after she came under fire for an anti-gay post she made in 2014. “Following careful reflection it has been decided that Seyi will no longer be involved with the production.

  • UK 'has prime responsibility for protecting Good Friday Agreement'
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    UK 'has prime responsibility for protecting Good Friday Agreement'

    Simon Coveney's comments came after a request from German Chancellor Angela Merkel that the EU ramp up its plans to avoid a hard border

  • Porsche Cayenne Coupe shows unusual shape in videos, live pics
    News
    motor1

    Porsche Cayenne Coupe shows unusual shape in videos, live pics

    Watch 30 minutes of footage with the unconventionally styled SUV.

  • Home and Away's Tori makes baby confession in 20 new pics
    Digital Spy

    Home and Away's Tori makes baby confession in 20 new pics

    How will Robbo react? From Digital Spy

  • News
    Sky News

    Sainsbury's and Asda offer to sell off up to 150 stores in merger bid

    Sainsbury's and Asda have offered to sell up to 150 stores in an attempt to address concerns raised by competition authorities over their planned merger. Britain's second and third biggest supermarkets are battling to keep the tie-up alive after findings by the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) identified "extensive" concerns that it could lead to higher prices and lower quality. The sell-offs could represent about 1 in 8 of the more than 1,200 supermarkets Sainsbury's and Asda have between them.

  • Girlfriend Didn't Know She Was Going to Meet Her Favorite Band... Until Now!
    Storyful

    Girlfriend Didn't Know She Was Going to Meet Her Favorite Band... Until Now!

    When Christopher Konya and his girlfriend, Meredith, started dating, she told him her “bucket list band” was Third Eye Blind. Christopher duly bought concert tickets. And here, he delivers a bonus surprise: Meredith will be meeting the band too! The news is all too much for Meredith, who bursts into tears when she realizes Christopher is not kidding. Credit: Christopher Konya via Storyful

  • Diarrhoea kills more children in war zones than war itself – Unicef
    News
    The Guardian

    Diarrhoea kills more children in war zones than war itself – Unicef

    A displaced child carries water at a camp in Yemen. Photograph: Essa Ahmed/AFP/Getty Images Diarrhoea and other diseases related to poor sanitation are bigger killers of children in areas of conflict than violence and war itself, a report has found, highlighting the need for improved infrastructure as a way of helping civilian populations afflicted by warfare. Children under five are more than 20 times more likely to die from diarrhoeal diseases than from direct violence, according to Unicef. Henrietta Fore, the organisation’s executive director, said: “The reality is there are more children who die from lack of access to safe water than by bullets.” Women and children, who tend to be responsible for fetching water, are often unable to reach clean water sources in situations of conflict, while sometimes armed forces deliberately target water supplies and sanitation as weapons of war. Forces can also cut off the power that keeps vital infrastructure such as water pumps working, and conflict prevents maintenance personnel from making repairs. War also makes it harder for supplies of products needed to purify water or used in sanitation, such as chlorine and other cleaners, to get through to where they are needed. These factors add up to often neglected disasters that accompany protracted conflicts, with children bearing the brunt, according to a Unicef report, Water Under Fire, published on Friday to coincide with World Water Day. The report examined in detail 16 countries undergoing long civil wars and other conflicts. Fore called for an end to the deliberate targeting of water infrastructure, including attacks by governments, and for the international community to prioritise water and sanitation in its response to conflicts. “The odds are already stacked against children living through prolonged conflicts, with many unable to reach a safe water source,” she said. “Deliberate attacks on water and sanitation are attacks on vulnerable children. Water is a basic right. It is a necessity for life.” The report drew on countries including Afghanistan, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Mali, Somalia, Sudan, Syria and Yemen. Children aged up to 15 were found to be more likely to die from water-related diseases than as a result of direct violence in all the countries studied except for Libya, Iraq and Syria. Megan Wilson-Jones, a senior policy analyst for health and hygiene at the charity WaterAid, said: “The findings of the report are tragic. Diarrhoea caused by dirty water and a lack of sanitation contributes to the death of a child under five every two minutes. “Ensuring good water, sanitation and hygiene is essential to the health of children in every setting, including as part of humanitarian emergency responses.” At least 4 billion people live in water-scarce areas, where for at least part of the year demand outstrips supply, and 844 million lack access to safe water close to home. Water scarcity is no longer just a problem for developing countries, as climate change, population increases, water wastage and increasing demand from agriculture and industry mean water supplies in large areas of the developed world are also coming under pressure. Earlier this week, the head of the UK’s environment agency warned England would face “the jaws of death”, running out of water within 25 years if nothing were done to halt demand growth and waste. Unicef’s findings came as a separate report, also focused on World Water Day, showed international businesses are continuing to drain global water supplies, even as they acknowledge the risks and potential negative impacts of doing so. CDP, an organisation focusing on measuring companies’ environmental impacts, looked at some of the world’s 300 biggest publicly listed companies and found roughly one-third are using more water than three years ago. Cate Lamb, the director of water security at CDP, said more companies must show leadership if the world is not to face a worsening problem. “The world is not on track to meet our global water goal [under the UN’s sustainable development goals] of ensuring access to sustainable water and sanitation for all,” she said. “The companies reporting to CDP are responsible for a huge proportion of global water use and pollution. While many of their practices and procedures currently contribute to the depletion of freshwater resources, these companies could also hold the key to a water-secure future.” WaterAid also pointed to the indirect use of water, which many people are unaware of, as key to solving the world’s water and sanitation crises. Although 4 billion people globally live in water-scarce areas, a number expected to rise to 5 billion by the middle of this century, many of these regions effectively export water in the form of agricultural goods from avocados to cotton. High consumption of these goods in buyer countries can lead to worsening problems for people in the exporting countries.

  • ScotRail to spend £18m to improve its performance for passengers
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    ScotRail to spend £18m to improve its performance for passengers

    The rail operator is to recruit more staff and focus on the reliability of services after criticism from the First Minister.

  • Garuda Indonesia scraps order for 49 Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets after crashes
    News
    Sky News

    Garuda Indonesia scraps order for 49 Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets after crashes

    Indonesia's national carrier Garuda has cancelled a multibillion-dollar order for 49 Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets after two fatal crashes involving the plane. Garuda spokesman Ikhsan Rosan said the company had sent a letter to Boeing "requesting that the order be cancelled". The Indonesian airline ordered 50 Boeing 737 MAX 8 jets in 2014 for $4.9bn (£3.7bn).

  • What Fleabag gets right about mental health that a hundred serious dramas don't
    News
    Digital Spy

    What Fleabag gets right about mental health that a hundred serious dramas don't

    "Just a girl with no friends and an empty heart."

  • O2 resolves fault which left customers unable to make calls
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    O2 resolves fault which left customers unable to make calls

    The incident came after a major outage affected millions of the company's customers in December.

  • Jaguar Land Rover wins Chinese court case over copy of Range Rover Evoque
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    Jaguar Land Rover wins Chinese court case over copy of Range Rover Evoque

    JLR said it was the first case of its kind to support a foreign company in the car industry.

  • Link with China must be two-way street, says Italian president
    News
    PA Ready News World

    Link with China must be two-way street, says Italian president

    Italy is expected to become the first major democracy to sign a memorandum of understanding to join China’s ‘Belt and Road’ initiative.

  • Labour MPs must forget 'common market 2.0' – and back May's deal
    News
    The Guardian

    Labour MPs must forget 'common market 2.0' – and back May's deal

    ‘Anger with May is not a good enough reason for voting down her deal – a draft treaty that has been negotiated and agreed by every single EU member state.’ Photograph: Dan Kitwood/Getty Images Next week, MPs will most likely be asked to vote for a third time on Theresa May’s Brexit deal. So far, the prime minister has failed to convince more than three Labour MPs to back her deal. And yet there are many Labour parliamentarians who are publicly committed to respecting the referendum result and who oppose any move to a so-called people’s vote. Ironically, this group has no issue with any of the legally binding bits of the withdrawal agreement. Some of these MPs favour a close relationship with the EU, perhaps based on Norway’s membership of the European Economic Area (EEA). This “Norway” or “Norway Plus” option has been cleverly branded “common market 2.0”. But that’s a slogan, not an actual deal. It’s a shorthand for describing a relationship that would keep the UK in a close EU orbit – as a member of the single market – and probably in a customs union as well, or something close to that. All of that would have to be agreed once we are out, not least because Brussels has interpreted article 50 to mean we cannot negotiate our future until we are formally divorced. We often hear complaints that the government is leading us to a blind Brexit – there’s some truth in that, although the backstop does offer an insurance policy to protect our trading relationship. But it’s the EU that has refused to negotiate the future until post-Brexit. Some EU members might be happy to keep the UK hugged close. But many recognise that we couldn’t have exactly the same relationship as Norway, not least as that wouldn’t resolve the issue of the Irish border. There would also be concerns that we are too big an economy to get that level of market access without far greater obligations. An Élysée source shared my concerns that if the UK became “Norway”, we would, in time, either break the agreement by pushing back on new rules, or end up crashing out and demanding a new deal. The simple truth is that “common market 2.0” is an aspiration not a destination. It’s not the off-the-shelf model some claim. To get to it, you would need to agree protocols or derogations to the EEA agreement and possibly with the EFTA too. This would mean painstaking negotiations with all the EU27 plus Norway, Liechtenstein and Iceland. Along the way we could well lose some of the advantages that “Norway” offers. Expect the French to come for our fish, Spain for Gibraltar, and pretty much everyone to demand more money and more rigorous oversight via the European court of justice. I cannot see how this sort of deal would be politically sustainable in the long term. Even its proponents accept that it would mean only limited control over EU free movement, other than in truly exceptional circumstances. Are MPs really ready to tell their constituents that Brexit won’t give us control over migration and will mean what many see as broad-spectrum rule-taking? Although Norway has more influence over EU’s rules than the silly “fax machine democracy” characterisation, the reality is that we would have to accept most new regulations across our wider economy. As Mark Carney has said, “it is highly undesirable to be a rule-taker” on financial services, which this sort of relationship would entail. Nonetheless there are many MPs in several political parties who sincerely believe this is the best long-term option for the UK. I don’t doubt their good faith and applaud them for seeking compromise. On the Labour side this group includes the highly effective Stephen Kinnock and Lucy Powell. It’s perfectly legitimate to want a close relationship with the EU after Brexit – indeed many Eurosceptics would have bitten off David Cameron’s arm if he had offered them Norway or Switzerland five years ago. Lots of those same Eurosceptics have since lost all sense of perspective, failing to recognise any of the positives of May’s deal and preposterously denying that it delivers Brexit at all. The debate on our future can – and must – be had the other side of Brexit. We are just days from our scheduled departure date. The Labour common market 2.0 advocates are happy with every word of the legally binding divorce treaty with the EU. What they seek are changes to the political declaration, the aspirational document setting out what sort of relationship the UK and EU will negotiate. Yet the EU has pointed out that nothing in the declaration rules out “Norway” or “Norway Plus”. Michel Barnier has gone further, and promised that the EU would welcome the opportunity to negotiate a close relationship at any point during the transition after we have left. I accept that many Labour MPs are furious that May has failed to reach across the House of Commons to find consensus on Brexit. She should have worked across party lines from the very start, especially after the general election in 2017 delivered a hung parliament. Rather than bringing the country and MPs together, she has often sharpened divisions. Her speech on Wednesday night only exacerbated that feeling. But anger with May is not a good enough reason for voting down her deal. After all, it’s not just her deal but a draft treaty that has been negotiated and agreed by every single EU member state. It is the only deal available and it leaves the possibility of a future relationship with the EU that keeps the Irish border open. MPs of all parties who want to see Brexit delivered in an orderly fashion should back this deal. What they need is the surety that the next stages of the negotiations will be handled in a way that brings parliament and the country together around a consensus for our future. • Henry Newman is the director of Open Europe. He has worked in the Cabinet Office and Ministry of Justice.

  • It's time for my Conservative party to root out Islamophobia for good
    News
    The Guardian

    It's time for my Conservative party to root out Islamophobia for good

    ‘It is the duty of leaders on the political right to demystify the debate, not pander to people’s cheap fear of ‘the other’.’ Photograph: Leon Neal/Getty ImagesFor better or worse, it’s in our nature to avoid difficult conversations. And no wonder: a tough conversation poorly held can hurt more than it heals.But avoidance only takes you so far. From my time as a youth worker I know that difficult conversations don’t become easier the longer you put them off. That’s why I know it’s time for Conservatives to have a proper conversation about Islamophobia. There is simply too much hate floating around online these days and too much of it is appearing (intentionally or not) under our banner. We must root it out, now.Whether we like it or not, there is a subculture of Conservative supporters that place Islam at the centre of much that’s wrong with our society. And I think they’re wrong. This Tommy Robinson brigade appears to place ignorance ahead of understanding and does a disservice to British Muslims and the vast majority of Conservatives who bear absolutely no ill will toward the Muslim community. As a political movement we do ourselves no favours by tolerating or ignoring this hateful fringe.This isn’t an argument to exclude radical Islam from scrutiny or debate. But we don’t honour that debate by indulging the unfounded fears spread by Islamophobes whipping each other into a frenzy online. It is the duty of leaders on the political right to demystify the debate, not pander to people’s cheap fear of “the other”.Having grown up amid a strong Muslim community in Ladbroke Grove, west London, I’ve never been afraid of Islam. We were all striving toward the same goal – to succeed and make something better for ourselves. Our skin colour or religion weren’t a part of the conversation. I admired and envied the Muslim boys on the estate; most of my Moroccan mates came from strong families, something this black boy who grew up without his father wished he had experienced.The local mosques were very receptive to my youth work when others weren’t. The local imams knew my job was to help keep their wayward boys in school and plug them into mainstream opportunities. Being in such close contact over this common cause helped us to understand each other better. We need more of that spirit of togetherness.I’ve always known there was a problem with some of the more extreme views on the far right of the political spectrum. I’m a black man – I could hardly ignore it. When I was growing up, the BNP types on the estate used to go around looking for black boys to rough up. I was grateful to any and all who spoke out against their hatred. But watching the fallout from Christchurch and seeing the unearthing of the far-right websites and communities that helped enable it, it’s clear the problem is much deeper and broader than it was back in my day. Contrary to some powerful political voices, there aren’t “very fine people” on “both sides” of this debate.These vicious attacks on minority communities will keep happening unless we bust the myths behind their hatred. In the Conservative party, we cannot give cover in any way to those Islamophobes, even if they vote for us. We need to crack down on hate at the source and expel it from our midst. We must set clear guidelines as to what is acceptable and then enforce them with 100% effectiveness. Full stop.This will demonstrate solidarity with Muslim communities. And while we should also take practical measures, such as offering protection to places of worship should it be requested, our response should go much deeper. It should be Conservatives who drain the online swamp by holding tech companies’ feet to the fire. They must not be allowed to shirk their responsibility in allowing any hatred to spread.No hateful supporters will be welcomed in my camp. This pledge is the least I can do for my Muslim brothers and sisters.• Shaun Bailey is the Conservative London mayoral candidate

  • CBE honour for Emmeline Pankhurst's great-granddaughter
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    CBE honour for Emmeline Pankhurst's great-granddaughter

    Dr Helen Pankhurst was honoured for her campaigning on gender equality.

  • Press freedom is crucial in dealing with terrorism
    News
    Evening Standard

    Press freedom is crucial in dealing with terrorism

    Responsible media also have the right to make an ethical decision within the Editors’ Code of Practice as to what they should publish. The Prime Minister of New Zealand has been very dignified in saying that she is not going to name the perpetrator of the Christchurch attack.

  • Tributes paid to Libby Squire after university student's body found in estuary
    News
    PA Ready News UK

    Tributes paid to Libby Squire after university student's body found in estuary

    'We are all absolutely devastated by the loss of our student,' the vice-chancellor at the University of Hull said.

  • Suspicious package found in Irish post office linked to London parcel bombs
    News
    Evening Standard

    Suspicious package found in Irish post office linked to London parcel bombs

    The Irish justice minister said police are investigating a link between a suspicious package found at a post depot in Ireland, and the four parcel bombs detected in London and Glasgow earlier this month. Staff working in the An Post sorting office in Limerick were evacuated following the discovery of a suspicious package around 6am on Friday. An army bomb squad was deployed to the scene and gardai are now investigating the post stamp similarities to the previously uncovered letter bombs.

  • Mass brawl between 400 rival supporters of social media influencers broken up by police in Berlin
    News
    The Independent

    Mass brawl between 400 rival supporters of social media influencers broken up by police in Berlin

    Police in Berlin had to break up a mass brawl of more than 400 people – after fans of two rival social media influencers clashed in Germany. Nine arrests were made and multiple knives confiscated as officers were forced to use tear gas to break up the organised dust-up in the city’s famous Alexanderplatz. Rocks were also thrown as the violence spilled into the square’s underground station.

  • Sean Penn explains why A Star is Born is one of his favourite movies
    Entertainment news

    Sean Penn explains why A Star is Born is one of his favourite movies

    He told Jimmy Kimmel why he loved the film so much

  • Northern Lights could be visible from the UK on Saturday night, say forecasters
    News
    PA Science

    Northern Lights could be visible from the UK on Saturday night, say forecasters

    A solar storm will shift the aurora borealis south over Scotland for one night only.

  • Celebs Go Dating fans left with one big question after the finale
    News
    Digital Spy

    Celebs Go Dating fans left with one big question after the finale

    But do we really want the answer?

  • The Voice Kids Germany: Two young contestants STUN with performance of Radiohead's Creep
    News
    Evening Standard

    The Voice Kids Germany: Two young contestants STUN with performance of Radiohead's Creep

    Two young contestants on The Voice Kids Germany left everyone gobsmacked after they completely owned their cover of Radiohead classic Creep, during their blind audition. The pair secured an all-four chair turn leaving coaches Lena Mayer-Landrut, Mark Forster, Stefanie Kloß and The BossHoss duo Boss Burns and Hoss Power, baffled when they turned to face them. The performance proved such a hit that the pair secured a standing ovation and were asked to perform it for a second time in front of an awestruck panel of coaches.