Russian Revolution – book reviews | Jura Books
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/system/system.base.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/system/system.menus.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/system/system.messages.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/system/system.theme.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/aggregator/aggregator.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/calendar/css/calendar_multiday.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/comment/comment.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/date/date_api/date.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/date/date_popup/themes/datepicker.1.7.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/date/date_repeat_field/date_repeat_field.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/field/theme/field.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/node/node.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/search/search.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/user/user.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/modules/forum/forum.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/views/css/views.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/ctools/ctools/css/ctools.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/modules/taxonomy_access/taxonomy_access.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/themes/bealestreet/style.css?oa3l5d");
@import url("http://web.archive.org./web/20170902223050cs_/http://jura.org.au/sites/all/themes/bealestreet/css/red.css?oa3l5d");
#page {
width: 95%;
}
.topBlock, .bottomBlock, .middleWrapper, #loginWrapper {
width : 95%;
}
#sidebar-left, .region-sidebar-first {
width : 210px;
}
#sidebar-right, .region-sidebar-second {
width : 210px;
}
body {
font-family : Arial, Verdana, sans-serif;
}
Skip to main content
Welcome Visitor: Login/Register
Search
Search
About
Bookshop
Library
Blog
Images
Audio
Events
Contact
Donate
Links
Upcoming events
Concert: Hinterland and No Mandate at Jura
03/09/2017 - 6:00pm to 8:30pm
more
Jura blog
Jura Books: Forty Years and Now
Russian Revolution book reviews
The Egyptians: A Radical Story - the book that Noam Chomsky couldn't stop reading
The Case for Anarchism or why Hierarchy should be Abolished
Don't vote your life away!
More
New books
New titles from a new publisher: OR Books
17 hours 1 min ago
Intersting New Titles at Jura Books
3 weeks 15 hours ago
A couple of new titles
1 month 3 weeks ago
New AK Press books this week
2 months 3 days ago
Latest books at Jura from AK Press
3 months 3 weeks ago
New books from PM Press, one of our favourite anarchist publishers...
4 months 6 days ago
New titles
4 months 2 weeks ago
New titles this week - come on in to Jura...
4 months 3 weeks ago
New titles at Jura Books this week
5 months 2 weeks ago
New titles at Jura this week.
5 months 3 weeks ago
more
Russian Revolution – book reviews
Submitted by Sid on Thu, 09/03/2017 - 9:47pm
This week saw not only International Women's Day on March 8th, but also its connection to the Russian Revolution of 1917, which celebrates its 100th anniversary. One hundred years ago, women in the cold on the bread lines began protests and riots that led to the overthrow of the 300 year Romanov monarchy. Now, before history-phobia sets in, remember that the events that those women initiated, along with the larger revolution which was initiated, affected hundreds of millions of people and have huge lessons for revolutionaries of today. Those events show as much about what shouldn't be done as what could be done to live on this planet in a peaceful, creative, fulfilling, sustainable way.
Here are some short reviews of books that are relevant to exploring those events which still resonate today. The first is by an overt marxist (Murphy), the second by an academic who is more critical and presents a more realistic view (Pirani). The next group of authors are anarchists, the first a participant in the revolution (Makhno), the other an historian with a cultural background in the area he writes about (Skirda) and the third by an anarchist/libertarian-socialist/councilist and neurologist, (Brinton), should have been read and adsorbed by Murphy, and even Pirani.
Kevin Murphy's Revolution and Counterrevolution: Class struggle in a Moscow metal factory has many fine features, including using recently opened Russian archival material, and attempting to bring women into the revolutionary story. One of the strongest features of the book is in bringing the reader into many of the struggles and arguments on the factory floor during the revolutionary period and the 1920s to early 1930s. Like the next book reviewed, by Pirani, this is a marvelous window into the past, and includes aspects of the social life of the workers and bureaucrats as well as into the factory floor meetings. However, Murphy's main theme is to show how the life of workers was so much better during the era when Trotsky was around as compared to Stalin's rule. What he does not do is recognise how the repression of the Russian people started with the beginning of Bolshevik rule, and certainly may have accelerated under Stalin, but Trotsky, Lenin and the rest were just as complicit in the silencing dissent. Stalin merely built his machine on the foundations of the previous rulers. Much of evidence that the author presents is based on the Bolshevik/Communist Party's meeting minutes, thus a biased account is inevitable. Murhpy just seems sour that Stalin gained the crown instead of Trotsky: there is no evidence to say that Trotsky would have behaved any better, and much to say the opposite. On a positive note, the attempt to look at what was happening 'on the factory floor' is a bonus. Just keep your eyes open as you walk with the author, or you may trip over a litter of 'the party directed' and the 'the party committee expelled x' – accepting the party records as an almost solely valid account of worker reality leaves me with wanting a fuller, more accurate account.
Simon Pirani's The Russian Revolution in Retreat, 1920-1924: Soviet workers and the new communist elite is along similar lines as Kevin Murphy's book, reviewed above, however it is a vast improvement. The main strength is in not having a seemingly ulterior motive, an inherent bias that clouds the narrative. Pirani does take us onto the factory floor, but uses a wider range of evidence and has a far more refined analytical capacity. Here we read an honest attempt to examine the relationship between the Bolshevik/Communist Party and the working class in the factories, not merely examine the arguments between one set of authoritarians within the Party and other sets of would-be bosses, each set wanting to take over the reigns of power via that very same Party. While Pirani uses similar archival material from Party and Secret Police records, his aim is to find out why and how the growing bureaucratic machine succeeded in destroying worker's power, democratic worker decision-making structures, and the increasing terror used to maintain control over the population, although focusing on this process in the working class factories and districts. Given the focus on the period 1920-1924, the author misses analysing the previous period, 1917-1920, when the foundations for the revolutionary retreat began and the tactics used to repress dissent within the Party were formulated to repress those revolutionaries outside the Party. Good book, though.
Nestor Makhno wrote an autobiography, now published in English in three volumes by Black Cat Press in Canada, The Russian Revolution in Ukraine, Under the Blows of the Counterrevolution (April-June 1918), and The Ukrainian Revolution. These books tell the story of Makhno, a peasant/proletarian's role in building a huge voluntary army in 1917 to fight the invading armies after Lenin ceded the Ukraine to the German & Austro Hungarians in order to end Russia's involvement in World War One. The Ukrainians didn't like the deal and Makhno, the former factory worker, with a small band of supporters, took up a guerilla campaign to free the predominantly agricultural region from the new oppressors. Not only was it a struggle against invaders, but also a fight to establish a revolutionary society that was based on anarchist principles. Within a few months a large area was liberated and new social systems developed by the peasants on the land and the workers in the towns. This is an exciting account of the ups and downs of four years of struggle, not only against foreign invaders, but also against local would-be rulers who wanted to crush the Ukrainian Revolution. Well worth reading this original history.
Alexandre Skirda has written an authoritative account of the Makhnovist movement during the Russian Revolution, Nestor Makhno: Anarchy's Cossack. The Struggle for Free Soviets in the Ukraine, 1917-1921. In one book, this historian has used more recently available material, as well as primary sources, such as Makhno's autobiography and those of others in the Makhno Insurrectionary Army. Skirda examines not only the brilliant military tactics of Makhno and the strategists who fought along side him, but the politics and the revolutionary principles they fought for and the revolutionary structures that were put in place, not only among the anarchist troops, but also by the Ukrainian people that had been liberated. Often missed is that the Makhnovists fought some of the greatest and last of the world's cavalry battles – against the invading Austro-Hungarian and German armies, the reactionary White Russian armies, and finally the Bolshevik troops. Stirring stuff, an exciting and fast paced read.
Maurice Brinton (aka Chris Pallis) wrote The Bolsheviks and Workers' Control, 1917-1921: The state and counter-revolution in 1970, but don't let that date put you off, as it hasn't really been surpassed for sharp critical analysis of the facts that happened on the factory floor during the Russian Revolution. Importantly, he firstly untangles the notion of 'workers' control' and notes that many political tendencies have trumpeted that as a slogan, from social democrats, Trotskyists, libertarian Marxists and anarcho-syndicalists. But what do they mean, and what does the concept sensibly mean at all. If the Bolsheviks said that they had installed workers control in, say, 1918, when they began dismantling the original Factory Committees that workers themselves build, and replaced them with Party controlled 'factory committees', is that the same idea? Can it be the same beast? Can it lead to the same sort of worker-controlled decision making? And ultimately, the same sort of society? Crucial questions, and ones that we still need to consider, mull over, argue around and come to conclusions about. A must read for any revolutionary, or aspiring change agent in the current times.
The Russian Revolution may have begun 100 years ago, but the challenges that it posed, not only to the monarchy of the time, to the growing capitalism, but to authoritarianism of any sort, and are as relevant today as they were then.
» Sid's blog
Opening hours