Comment

Letters to the Editor

Illustration: Cathy Wilcox

The meaning of being 'un-Australian'

What is "un-Australian", Minister Dutton, is to attack the constitution and the rule of law. They are what gives us our very Australian freedom. ("Lawyers representing asylum seekers are 'un-Australian': Peter Dutton", smh.com.au, August 28). Dominic Toomey, SC Annandale

Troubles of age

SMH letters dinkus DO NOT REMOVE TEXT

NAPLAN is stressing out millennials, Gen Y wants their parents' money, and Baby Boomers are living longer than ever and spending the kids' inheritance.

Sir Humphrey would be proud

Illustration: Moir

Lord mayor Clover Moore called the proposed $11.3 million Cloud Arch sculpture "heroic" ("Wider, heavier – and three times the price", August 25). Sir Humphrey Appleby would have been proud of her!

Note to David Jones: Stock the item and they will come

Letters dinkus

I have a suggestion that may help David Jones boss John Dixon entice shoppers into its stores ("DJs faults austerity for drop in sales", August 25). Instead of "exclusive brands" and $100 million grocery shops, why not try stocking a few brands that shoppers might actually want to buy?

No standing still on historic statue debate

Illustration: Cathy Wilcox.

Instead of erasing our history by removing the statues of Cook, Phillip and Macquarie, let's even the balance with statues of Bennelong, Pemulwy, Barangaroo and Colbee ("Second Sydney statue in doubt", August 24).

Australia should ignore Trump's war cry

SMH Letters

The war in Afghanistan is now under the control of an untrustworthy man of limited intelligence, volatile personality and minimal integrity.  Does Australia really want to go down this road?

Water worries as hot, dry summer looms

SMH Letters

Has anyone heard anything about our expensive de-salination plant at Kurnell? Is it working? Is it being regularly turned on to keep it active for the troubles ahead?

Pauline Hanson playing dress-ups

SMH Letters

I have never heard Pauline Hanson championing women's causes. She seems far more interested in stirring up racial hatred.

Improvement wanted on track now not far off down the line

SMH Letters

An impressive list from NSW Transport Minister Andrew Constance (Letters, August 18) of rail services and trains he proposes for the Sydney network. Sure hope he keeps the train drivers onside so they can be delivered.

Watch the gloating on job cuts

SMH Letters

It is beyond galling to see the Transport Minister brag about his plan to use automation to eliminate transport workers.

Is marriage as it stands worth this fight?

SMH Letters

Gay politics has always been about a cultural pride and driving to be accepted for exactly what we are. Not what everyone else wishes we are. But suddenly, or not so suddenly, we seem to have become no longer proud of what we are and have taken to redefining ourselves as failed heterosexuals instead. We seem to have become ashamed of being homosexual.

Motorway debacle must not be repeated

Illustration: Cathy Wilcox

The debacle that is giving western Sydney a $16.8 billion motorway with exorbitant tolls before any commitment to public transport must not be repeated on the north side.

Perfect hostess

SMH letters dinkus DO NOT REMOVE TEXT

I'm looking forward to Annabel Crabbe's TV documentary series The House ("Annabel's our woman about the House", August 6). Who could possibly be better qualified to make a behind-the-scenes documentary about Parliament House than someone who spent her childhood school holidays behind the scenes at Adelaide Zoo?

Best advice is to boycott any plebiscite

SMH Letters

If my gay brothers and sisters are thinking the same way I am today, they will be planning to boycott any plebiscite or postal vote this useless government intends dumping on an increasingly frustrated electorate.

Trust move worthy

SMH letters dinkus DO NOT REMOVE TEXT

It is indeed a brave announcement by Bill Shorten that the ALP will remove the excessive use of family trusts by the wealthy to avoid paying tax ("ALP lines up $17.2b hit on trusts loophole", July 30). Even if the present policy is legal, that does not make it moral or acceptable. Fairness, however, has never been a major concern for those who profit by leaving others, not so unscrupulous, to pay for essential services and social wellbeing. As a large number of our politicians have benefited by manipulating these trusts, I expect  Shorten will have a major fight on his hands.

Education overhaul in order but some restraint needed

SMH Letters

Greg Whitby's analysis into the value of the HSC is forthright and insightful. (" 'HSC had its day': leading educator calls for overhaul", August 4). It is paramount that questions are raised and systems restructured to challenge changing needs and opportunities for our students. The International Baccalaureate is offered as an alternative, but caution is needed. Early this decade Britain, too, realised a need for change and rushed into an alternative English Baccalaureate to appease all concerned interest groups (students seemingly last in interest). The strength of the International version is in its breadth and depth of subject with strong international recognition. Students become engaged and look beyond to the future. The English Baccalaureate falters into rules, regulations and more testing.  The necessity to overhaul the current system is imperative to ensure the NSW system remains respected and internationally well recognised. But rushed change or change to merely appease certain powerful interest groups wreaks havoc on an already overworked and stressed educational community. The change must be considered, directed at children's (and the wider community's) needs for the future and ensuring that staff are trained and in numbers (language and maths, for example) to accommodate.  Mr Whitby has proposed an adequate solution, with funding, additional consultation and adequate teacher training it could happen. But let us not travel the British route and split the educational communities into rival baccalaureates. Our children are too important.  Janice Creenaune Austinmer Â