AFL

ANALYSIS
Save
Print
License article

Sydney Swans' Kurt Tippett can still silence critics with big finish to 2017

Lance Franklin, Sam Reid and Kurt Tippett: at their best it's a trio that should make any opposition defence sweat – but it's far from set in stone that will be the combination Sydney will take into the finals.

The Swans have an imposing record when all three are up and going, but it has not been a common occurrence in the near four seasons they have been in the red and white.

Up Next

Scott reflects on wily Stevie J

null
Video duration
00:41

More AFL Real Footy Videos

FootyFix: Top four battle for fellow felines

Sam McClure previews all the footy action ahead of round 21 in the AFL.

They have featured in just one September campaign together – in 2014 when the Swans made the grand final – and played just 33 of a possible 93 games together, for 24 wins and nine losses.

As the numbers suggest, it is a formula that works. Franklin's speed and skill, combined with Reid's sticky hands and athleticism, and Tippett's ability to push forward to take big marks. The big if, however, is Tippett.

Barring a late run of injuries, it's unlikely the settled Swans will make many changes in the coming weeks, but the ruck spot is still up for grabs.

It is a three-way battle between project player Sam Naismith, back-up Callum Sinclair and Tippett, comfortably the most accomplished of the three, but who has spent much of the season rotating from the casualty ward to the NEAFL.

Advertisement

The Swans could well show their hand at the selection table for this week's game against Fremantle if Naismith, their first-choice ruck for much of the year, proves his fitness at training on Thursday, giving them all three to pick from.

With Dockers behemoth Aaron Sandilands injured, the Swans have scope to experiment, but the clash next week against Adelaide's Sam Jacobs looms as a potential D-Day.

Naismith is the purest ruckman of the three with his tap work but, having yet to kick a goal this year, does not offer as much in attack or around the ground as the more mobile Sinclair or the high-marking Tippett.

Sinclair started the year as the third seed but has played well in two of his three games back. His marking has improved considerably but there remains a big gap between his best and worst.

When fit and firing, Tippett is one of the best ruck-forwards in the competition as he showed in the back half of 2015 and the first half of last year before being sidelined by a serious hamstring injury. The Swans know they are a better team when Tippett is at his best.

As forgettable as his season has been, the maligned big man has seven weeks to silence the critics who feel his on-field deeds have not justified his massive pay packet.

Tippett's 2017 campaign has been cruelled by ankle and hip injuries, which have affected his training and not allowed him the continuity he needs, but he has benefited from his recent time out.

His numbers in his comeback game against Geelong – eight possessions, 16 hitouts and no goals or contested marks – were modest, but the Swans felt he had an influence. In racing parlance, he will be better for the run.

"He contributed pretty strongly, he competed in the air quite well, he rucked quite well," coach John Longmire said.

"There was a big tackle in the last quarter from the centre bounce. He competed quite well."

Another factor is whether the Swans play just the one frontline ruck or two. When Tippett was at his top last year he played as the No.1 with relief from a forward.

But do the Swans believe Tippett can return to that level now to justify playing him one out with assistance from Reid or Dean Towers, or do they need a second big man in Sinclair or Naismith, which could leave them top heavy?

The Swans played some of their best football this year with one specialist ruckman. If Tippett rediscovers his form of early 2016, he is that man.