Trump’s Flawed Protectionism

 

In the midst of the din over Charlottesville, let’s not overlook the Trump administration’s controversial stance on free trade. This smoldering problem has risen to the surface in the delicate negotiations that the United States now is undertaking with China over the status of American intellectual property rights, and with Mexico and Canada over the North American Free Trade Agreement. Before looking at the particulars of these two disputes, it is instructive to set out the intellectual case for free trade, which Trump has consistently misunderstood.

The basic insight here is that ordinary contracts between private parties are not neutral; they produce gains for each party. If I swap my horse for your cow, it is tempting, but wrong, to say that no value has been added for the parties because we have the same horse and cow after the transaction that we had before it. So why worry, the argument goes, if the trade does not take place? This facile argument ignores that these transactions are costly to complete. Why would two parties waste money to organize a trade from which neither side has gained? Even this simple trade is a positive-sum game that produces for each side a net advantage that exceeds the costs of putting the deal together. I could desperately need a cow for milk or breeding, and you might need the horse to pull a plow. The trade allows both of us to get greater value by the more efficient deployment of existing resources. That short-term advantage has long-term effects, by letting me breed horses while you breed cows.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Lighting a Match to History

 

There will always be those who are bigoted and racist. There will always be those who believe that race is always a problem, holding them back. Both are wrong. As a nation we have done more than any other to erase race, origin, sex, age, religion and sexual preference in how we deal with others in the conduct of our daily lives. We aren’t perfect. Our freedoms allow our citizens the liberty to be ugly. But we are the most open, generous and forgiving country that has ever been; a place where everyone is offered an opportunity to rise beyond his natal station.

There is a call from the Left and the media that all symbols of the losing cause in the Civil War, after more than a century and a half, be purged from the public eye and destroyed. They inspire racists and bigots, we are told. However, ritual removal of all confederate memorials will do absolutely nothing to remove the purple scar of slavery from America’s history. It provides no absolution, no confession, no relief for anyone. Six generations of Americans have been born since the end of that horrible war and not one of them bears any responsibility for that institution in America, an institution as old as mankind and still strong in the world.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

When the Ewok Dies

 

I’m a bit of a nerd. Consequently, I tend to draw analogies along those lines. I tend to gravitate toward history and movies, though in the word-nerd category I’ve got some clout. I enjoy deliciously crafted run-on sentences that break all the rules. Shelby Foote once wrote a sentence in The Civil War that took up an entire page. I still kick myself for not marking it out of apprehension for scarring a beautiful hardcover — even with a pencil — but secretly look forward to re-reading all 2,968 pages of its three volumes in order to find it. Books are a passion, but I get downright sick about Star Wars.

The Battle of Endor began as a raid. The Rebel Alliance had sneaked deep behind enemy lines on a covert mission that was supposed to facilitate a surprise attack, swift victory, and perhaps even the death of the Emperor himself. But from the get-go it seemed nothing had gone right. Setbacks mounted, and the plan had quickly gone completely out the window. Then it got worse. The enemy was a step ahead in every detail, and though the Alliance adjusted and countered effectively, it seemed to merely postpone an inevitable retreat. They were losing.

More

Women of a Certain Age in America

 

Time was when women of a certain age had to rely on Mrs. Nancy Meyers and the late Nora Ephron for vaguely risque romantic stories. Well, there’s a new generation of Meyers for a new generation of women. And, boy, is newness needed! We are longer lived, especially the women, but afraid of getting older earlier. Women on the wrong side of 20 seldom are without the fear of getting on the wrong side of 30. In an America where marriage comes later and later and with less and less hope of it lasting a lifetime, romantic comedy is fast turning into a politically revolutionary act. Movies about daring at that certain age therefore could bring together women in facing the problem.

Behold Home Again, the product of a newer, younger Meyers, a story the silliness of which I will let you glean from the trailer. And what a story! It seems to teach women that 40-year-old mother-of-three Reese Witherspoon is worth making a movie about only if, abandoned, she then abandons herself to the romantic ideas of a boy who gets carded when he asks for a drink. Isn’t that dreadfully bittersweet, and something of an embarrassment? How did we end up here? What can we learn from the poetess of Boomer rebellion?

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Fake News Alert: Secret Service Not Running Out of Money Because of Trump and Family

 

Major news outlets around the country would have you think that the United States Secret Service is running out of money due to President Trump’s frequent travel and large family. From the USA Today:

The Secret Service can no longer pay hundreds of agents it needs to carry out an expanded protective mission – in large part due to the sheer size of President Trump’s family and efforts necessary to secure their multiple residences up and down the East Coast.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

My Quote of the Day

 

I have a subscription to National Review and First Things. I also read True West, a magazine that I’m sure does not grace the coffee tables of the political elites and the beautiful people. That’s okay by me, but I do say a prayer for those that opened up the West because it allows me to live about 3,000 miles away from DC.

There is a page in every issue of True West titled “Truth Be Known” compiled by Robert Ray containing quotes. In the September issue he included a quote from George Orwell.

More

The Trump Doctrine Meets Afghanistan

 

“We are not nation-building again. We are killing terrorists.” That line sums up the Trump Doctrine outlined in the President’s Monday night address on Afghanistan.

In Trump’s delivery, you could hear the frustration with the 17-year war now overseen by three presidents. Most Republicans long ago dropped the Bush dream of transforming the graveyard of empires into a modern democracy, while Democrats simply ignored the body counts stacking up under Obama.

More

Beautiful Dark Things – Desire from Nature

 

Earlier, @iwe wrote on desire and creativity as a holy act, on how humans are called, not to pagan imitation of nature, but to make things entirely new. And yet, for many of us, learning to imitate nature seems a necessary part of artistic discipline. Most conservatives are unlikely to be impressed, to put it mildly, by painters and sketchers without good observational-drawing skills. Music and literature, too, benefit from observant imitation of the natural world. Neither the sound of the sea nor the sight of the Milky Way could be imitated exactly in a song or poem, of course, but an artist may find that the only reason a work of his exists is because he attempted to record these natural features faithfully.

Matsuo Basho wrote a haiku sandwiching an island between the turbulent sea and the River of Heaven – the Milky Way. Music for that haiku might spring from hearing, over and over, the relentless beat of waves in your head, from the desire to imitate that sound, the desire to imitate, sonically, the frosty light of so many stars, to imitate nature’s creation of a beautiful dark thing:

More

We’ve Been the Silent Majority for Too Long

 

“We have always spoken out against the Left and it never works.” That’s what I’ve been told by my fellow Ricochettis for years, and my response is, really?

My disclaimer is that I’ve only been following politics for about the last 15 years, and rabidly for only five years, and the perception I have is that we’ve spent a lot of time complaining about the Left and their co-conspirators (known as the media). But when have people of the Right spoken out in a way that they’ve been heard? I have the impression that we’re residing in one giant conservative echo chamber where our protestations, condemnations, and statements of misery have been bouncing off each other as we bang our heads against the wall in frustration.

More

What Really Just Happened (Eclipse Science for Dummies)

 

Sure, lots of people are talking about the eclipse and how awesome it was. They had their NASA glasses and pinhole cameras. But do they really understand this phenomenon? They think they do but most are just faking it. As a public service to Ricochetti as they hobnob with fellow partisans of astro-doohickey-gawking and what not, they can thank me for providing this clear illustration of what an eclipse actually is. Study this illustration and then you will be able to set everyone straight.

Solar Eclipse Explained

As a bonus, next time a Lunar Eclipse occurs in your area, you will be ahead of the crowd if you memorize this:

More

The Political Assault on Big Tech Is Now in Full Swing

 

Axios goes big on the mounting political woes for America’s tech giants: “Tech behemoths Google, Facebook and Amazon are feeling the heat from the far-left and the far-right, and even the center is starting to fold.”

I mean, like I have been saying — see here, here, and here — for the past year. This issue really came to my attention when Elizabeth Warren attacked Apple and Google for using their size to “snuff out” competition.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Why we need Robert E. Lee

 

Robert E. Lee was on the wrong side of the Civil War. Yet his defenestration is a great loss for all Americans.

The reason can be captured in three words: Duty, authority, and Providence. These are three concepts that were once in the bloodstream of all Americans, but their late disappearance is part of the reason our politics is so fragmented, dysfunctional and uncivil. Lee is a superlative example of a life lived by all three concepts and rather than tossing him on the ash heap, we desperately need to learn from him.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Was Slavery the Cause of the Civil War?

 

The great American tragedy is raising its ugly head once more, as it does occasionally. People on both sides are viciously accused by people on opposite sides, sometimes justly, sometimes not, as America divides along fault lines remarkably similar to the one that ruptured in 1861. My contention is that the horrible war could only be justified by the victorious side by making it a moral war. Was it?

In GFHandle’s piece, “Should We Honor Lee?,” several of us discussed that question, i.e., whether slavery was the cause. I contend that, in fact, the American Civil War was a cultural war, a refight of the English Civil War of the 1630s. Members of each side fled England to escape the other during the seventeenth century, one side to Massachusetts to seed northern culture, the other to Virginia to seed southern culture — and maintained both their cultures and their animosities to such an extent that they would fight again in the 1860s.

More

On Cultural Purging

 

I think the concept of collusion is operative here, though not the sort of collusion we’ve been hearing about. No, to listen to the fanatical class, what we are witnessing is collusion by accident of birth.

As a Christian, for example, I accept my part in the metaphysical collusion of those whose sins made necessary Christ’s sacrifice on the cross. And while I accept the transcendent sense in which mankind was indeed born into darkness, it will take a herculean philosophical effort (akin to proving that Nancy Pelosi is coherent or that Ted Kennedy was a para-rescue specialist) to convince me that Original Sin is a tribal condition applicable to civic life.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Antifa? Yeah, They’re Kinda Sorta Skinheads.

 

Punk riots. Skinheads. Before special snowflakes, SJWs, or the alt-right’s revolt against “the tyranny of nice” became a thing, musical subcultures I can’t even pretend to understand fractured along white-nationalist and anti-white-nationalist lines.

I can’t claim to understand the punk ethos – or ethe, ethea, or ethoses (fittingly, there are multiple ways to pluralize “ethos”) – but the news of my youth was vaguely colored by incidental stories of “direct action,” of “taking it to the streets,” of punks getting their riot gear ready. Often, the “oppression” they fought was gentrification, one more manifestation, apparently, of “the tyranny of nice.”

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

Treating the Body Politic

 

I’m not a doctor but I know enough about medicine to know that a fever is not an illness in itself but a symptom of a larger underlying problem. And right now, America has a raging fever.

Most fevers are caused by infections. The political and punditry classes have diagnosed the problem as Donaldus Trumpitis, a relatively new disease some are describing as a cancer. But more likely than not, this case of the DTs is not the disease itself but just the manifestation of the fever.

More
Ricochet Member Recommended FeedRecommended by R> Members

What Comes After “Nazi?”

 

While sitting in my favorite bagel place today, I watched a ramshackle group of middle-aged men and women — a real low-testosterone, NPR-looking crowd — walk by carrying signs that had negative things to say about Nazis, hate, and President Trump.

It saddens me a little that there are people stupid enough to believe that the anti-Nazi message actually has to be delivered, given that essentially everyone already agrees that Nazis were evil. But then, this same group was probably waving Bernie signs a few months ago, so I suppose it’s progress that they’re rejecting at least one form of socialism (the most murderous idea in human history), given that they were embracing it so recently.

More

Standoff Between the President and the Military on Transgenderism

 

A few weeks ago, President Trump again threw the country into a tizzy by declaring a ban on transgender people in the military. Everyone was surprised, including James Mattis, Secretary of Defense. A number of factors seemed to contribute to Trump’s decision, including contradictory ones. I’d like to explore some of those here, and also explain the reasons why his decision may actually benefit not only the military, but this nation.

In studying the background for Trump’s decision, President Obama in 2011 repealed the “don’t ask, don’t tell” policy but was silent regarding transgender members of the armed forces. Following that decision, however, Defense Secretary Ashton Carter announced that transgender people could openly serve in the military. He said:

More