Greenback is likely to get over any loss of confidence in Trump

Political uncertainty is back. The inquiry into Russian interference in the election, and the president's apparently ...
Political uncertainty is back. The inquiry into Russian interference in the election, and the president's apparently desperate attempts to thwart it, have raised comparisons with Watergate. Alex Brandon
by John Authers

Three months ago Donald Trump said: "I think our dollar is getting too strong and partially that's my fault because people have confidence in me. But that's hurting - that will hurt ultimately."

If the problem was excessive confidence in the US president, it appears to have been solved. Last week the dollar, on a trade-weighted basis, fell to levels at which it last traded in June 2016, before the Brexit vote forced a one-off revaluation against the pound.

In January, the dollar index was at a 14-year high and the president-elect worried that: "Our companies can't compete with them [Chinese companies] now because our currency is too strong. And it's killing us."

Anthony Scaramucci, then close to the administration and a week ago appointed head of communications, said: "We have to be careful about the rising currency."

Since then the trade-weighted dollar has dropped 10 per cent. For an administration that came to power trumpeting its determination to put America first and to resort to protectionism if necessary, this is a success. Such a devaluation automatically makes imports more expensive and exports more competitive - it is as effective as a tariff.

But why is the dollar weakening? Does it show success for the administration in talking the dollar down, or is it more about a loss of the confidence in Mr Trump that he once blamed for the dollar's strength? Or could it have little to do with the president, even if his exploits - and those of his henchmen - dominate the media?

To defend the idea that this is all about Mr Trump, note that the dollar rose sharply after November's election. The result was a surprise, as was the working majority for the Republicans in both houses of Congress. Uncertainty had been replaced with clarity.

Trump-Republican policies of cutting taxes and spending on infrastructure would stimulate the economy and push up the dollar. Protectionist tariffs, if imposed, would be countered by a rise in the dollar - so it was logical to push down almost all other currencies against the dollar after the election.

But policy developments have been terrible for the dollar. There is nothing on infrastructure, no tariffs - and the failure to do anything about healthcare raises the risk that Republicans might not even be able to agree on a tax cut.

Bond markets, which express economic fundamentals, suggest that the dollar should be strengthening this year.
Bond markets, which express economic fundamentals, suggest that the dollar should be strengthening this year.

Political uncertainty is back. The inquiry into Russian interference in the election, and the president's apparently desperate attempts to thwart it, have raised comparisons with Watergate.The dollar does badly during scandals - such as Watergate and Iran-Contra under Ronald Reagan.

This and the bizarre news flowing out of the White House should hurt the dollar.Against this you could base an argument on fundamentals.

Ignoring politics, the US economy seemed strong and ready to expand six months ago, while Europe's appeared in the doldrums. But US core inflation has fallen, and the eurozone has had a surprisingly strong recovery.

The election of Emmanuel Macron as French president has given the eurozone a fillip of confidence. Money is pouring into Europe. Without looking at Trump's tweets, these developments would entail a falling dollar.

The problem with this is that bond markets, which express economic fundamentals, suggest that the dollar should be strengthening this year. Currencies tend to move according to yield differentials - higher interest rates in one country draw funds and push up the currency.

There are various ways to measure this but, comparing two-year yields, the chart shows that the gap of US over German yields is as wide as it has been in more than a decade.The exchange rate usually follows the yield differential, so the dollar's fall suggests something unusual afoot - probably a loss of confidence in Mr Trump.

If so, in the short term any bet on the dollar is a bet on US politics, and hence in part on the temperament of the president.

Few want to make such a bet. Success or failure of a tax cut could be decisive, as might an escalation of the Russia scandal (such as an indictment).

Economic fundamentals, probably affected by politics, will reassert themselves in the longer term.

To predict the strength of the dollar in a few years you need to answer questions about central banks. If the Federal Reserve starts reducing its balance sheet, as seems likely, while its counterparts in Europe and Japan do not, that will strengthen the dollar.

The weakness of the dollar deters other central banks from tightening, which will tend to strengthen the dollar in the longer run.

You also need to ask about the economy. How strong is the eurozone recovery? A lot of hopes have been hung on it. But if the US continues to grow faster than the eurozone, expect a stronger dollar in the long run - despite the lack of confidence in President Trump. john.authers@ft.com

reports.afr.com

Financial Times