Thu Jul 6, 2017, 03:57 PM
Different Drummer (5,507 posts)
Donald Trumps Populism Decoded: How a Billionaire Became the Voice of the Little People
Source:
Egbertowillies.com <snip> A key factor in understanding American populists is their drive to regain a lost status they once held but no longer claim in our economy and culture. Behavioral economics teaches us that people are far more motivated to avoid a loss than acquire a gain — and invest far more emotion to prevent a loss than benefit from a gain — which suggests that politicians who promise to reaffirm the status of erstwhile dominant constituencies will gain far more enthusiastic support than those who simply promise new and bigger programs to help people pursue their American dream. And that was precisely the magic behind Donald Trump's 2016 campaign: he promised his supporters that the only way to "make America great again" was by restoring their status as the ones who made America great in the first place — which is exactly how they see themselves. In particular, white working-class Americans — Donald Trump's base — were a constituency ripe for this message. To them, they were the real heroes of post-World War II America, the ones who made our prosperity and pre-eminence possible. Theirs is a narrative of an American century built by smokestack industries and sturdy white men with a blue-collar, lunch-pail ethic that would come to define the middle class of the post-war years. <snip> More at https://egbertowillies.com/2017/07/05/donald-trump-populism-decoded/
|
8 replies, 1537 views
Always highlight: 10 newest replies | Replies posted after I mark a forum
Replies to this discussion thread
8 replies | Author | Time | Post |
Donald Trumps Populism Decoded: How a Billionaire Became the Voice of the Little People (Original post) |
Different Drummer | Jul 2017 | OP |
LisaM | Jul 2017 | #1 | |
NCTraveler | Jul 2017 | #5 | |
LisaM | Jul 2017 | #8 | |
Goonch | Jul 2017 | #2 | |
Mike Nelson | Jul 2017 | #3 | |
KG | Jul 2017 | #4 | |
Different Drummer | Jul 2017 | #7 | |
NCTraveler | Jul 2017 | #6 |
Response to Different Drummer (Original post)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:16 PM
LisaM (26,185 posts)
1. I think this narrative drives resentment of the Clintons and Obamas, too.
People don't like, generally, comparing themselves to people who really did work their way to the top. They are more comfortable with electing someone who started out rich. I don't really get that, but it's so. Even the Carters were reasonably well to do. I think Bill Clinton and Barack Obama were anomalies (especially since neither had strong father figures). Where does Reagan fit into this? Not sure, though I would say that a lot of people who voted for him may not have been aware of his relatively humble roots and thought of him as a glamorous Hollywood figure.
|
Response to LisaM (Reply #1)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:25 PM
NCTraveler (30,481 posts)
5. How does that work considering Clinton won the vote of those making under 50,000/year?
You literally have to divide it down to income and white men in order to make it a plausible argument.
|
Response to NCTraveler (Reply #5)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:34 PM
LisaM (26,185 posts)
8. I don't mean that in his case, lower-income voters didn't vote for him.
I'm just stating that the fact that Clinton (and Obama) were essentially self made stirs some resentment in some people.
As we've seen in all recent elections, there is a giant unpredictability factor, too. |
Response to Different Drummer (Original post)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:21 PM
Goonch (1,680 posts)
2. ALL TIE SMALL HANDS TROPHY WIFE
|
Response to Different Drummer (Original post)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:22 PM
Mike Nelson (8,210 posts)
3. Not to mention...
...Make America Great Again meant back to a time when there were no Black or female Presidents, no gay people getting married, and no need to learn new computer skills for a job market based on 20th century technology.
...also not to mention that, although Trump was elected, Hillary Clinton won - meaning her message was the most popular. |
Response to Different Drummer (Original post)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:24 PM
KG (28,570 posts)
4. coz he speaks at a 6th grade level to a bunch of morons.
Response to Different Drummer (Original post)
Thu Jul 6, 2017, 04:27 PM
NCTraveler (30,481 posts)
6. Populism is the wrong word to use....
and is deceptive as hell. Clinton won those making under 50,000 by pretty large numbers. I guess the populist label is only good for some if it's identifying white men.
|