Comment

Letters to the Editor

Brows knitted over patronising Peter Dutton

SMH Letters

The plan being floated by Barnaby Joyce to pay a share of gas royalties to farmers is a thoroughly bad idea and if implemented would lead to division and bitterness in rural communities.

Australia slow learners over energy woes

SMH Letters dinkus

Chris Danckwerts (Letters, March 16) asks why we need an energy market at all. Answer? We don't – unless a market can be designed that achieves some public good.

Devoted parents

SMH Letters dinkus

Let us thank Bethan and Johnny McElwee, who have generously revealed their poignant journey with their daughter Aviana, ("When the new normal is getting ready for your baby's death", March 12). The photographs are so beautiful that they almost distract us from the words describing the disease of muscular spinal atrophy, its effects and prognosis. But this information, however depressing, enables us to understand the constant demands upon these devoted parents. Our thoughts, hopes and prayers go to Bethan and Johnny as they ensure that every precious moment of Aviana's life is filled with love and wonder.

Postscript: Privatisation a failure or the future?

SMH Letters

Forget supercharging the Snowy Hydro scheme, the steam rising off Herald readers contemplating the failures of privatisations past and the folly of privatisations future could drive all the turbines the nation needs to solve its energy crisis.

An energy 'market' really what we need?

SMH Letters

In all the discussions over energy policies at state and federal levels the question that needs to be asked is: why do we need an energy "market" at all?

Stamp duty changes must dissuade investors

SMH letters dinkus DO NOT REMOVE TEXT

It is imperative that any proposed changes to stamp duty on residential real estate purchases in NSW do not further embolden investors, as these costs are one of the few impediments to dissuade investors in the market ("Young buyers locked out", March 11-12).

Cash shows gulf between haves, have-nots

SMH Letters

Michaelia Cash, defender of cutting wages of low-income workers, owns two investment properties. Is it any wonder that reform to negative gearing has been dismissed by the government against overwhelming advice to the contrary.

Selective schools cop flak but no remedies

SMH Letters

Christina Ho picks through a pile of wobbly statistics, purports that they reveal some grave social injustice, yet fails to propose any remedy ("Wealthy, gifted and talented: Selective schools favour the rich", March 10). Entry to academically selective schools is based on an entrance test. There is no other fair or practical method. The socioeconomic background of the child's parents is irrelevant. Tone-deaf children aren't offered places at the Conservatorium High; out-of-area children with minimal athletic ability are unlikely to gain a place at a sports high school. In any case, it's difficult to imagine how Ms Ho would rectify what she claims is a bias against the entry of "disadvantaged groups" to our selective schools. Must each child sitting the entry test first produce their parents' income tax returns?

Women's voices welcomed

Girl-power icon Adele.

With International Women's Day this week, and girl-power icon Adele in town, it seems an appropriate time to turn our attention to women who know their way with words. With the ABC's kicking off the week with an all-female Q and A panel, it was suggested by a long-time letter writer, Robyn Dalziell of Castle Hill, that we follow suit, with an all-female letters page. "I note that women have  been well represented as SMH Letters Editors, possibly because the job is so difficult, I imagine. However, I recall that some years ago a previous editor, Jennie Curtin, took the bold step and quietly invited regular female contributors to write a letter of interest related to or directly from their experiences as women, as an acknowledgement of IWD."

Politicians disregard abuses of power

SMH Letters dinkus

It seems Gladys Berejiklian is yet another of those politicians who believe in accountability for everyone else but themselves ("Premier was sent warning over $549m light-rail rise", March 9). Almost daily we read of MPs who rort the system, or in an effort to protect themselves, withhold vital information, mislead or deliberately lie to the public. Some of these instances would be deemed illegal outside of politics, and offenders charged. It is as if politicians are above the law, or licensed to exploit the taxpayer for personal gain. The major parties share the shame for allowing this disregard for morality and abuse of power to continue. Graham Lum North Rocks

'No Jab, No Pay' sharp penalty

Illustration Alan Moir

Dr Bronwyn Harmon of Elizabeth Cowan University says that Pauline Hanson's must have sourced her claim of "blackmail" from the anti-vaccination movement ("Anti-vaxxer network spurs online culture of supporters", Mar 8). I am pro-vaccination, and wouldn't vote for Hanson in a fit, but my thesaurus doesn't turn up a better word to describe "No Jab, No Pay", unless you resort to "coercion", "extortion" or "intimidation".

Kings Cross deserves safety too

SMH Letters

. However, the fall in alcohol-related crime within the lockout zones still exceeds any crime displacement. In fact, with these latest statistics one might argue for extending the lockout zones.

Rail best for northern beaches

The Spit Bridge, a lift bridge that spans across Middle Harbour may be replaced by a tunnel.

The State Government is reportedly planning a road tunnel to improve city access for northern beaches motorists ("Berejiklian hints at finally fixing notorious traffic snarl", March 4-5).   While applauding the willingness to address access to the rest of Sydney from this rapidly-growing area, I wonder if expansion of the road network is the best solution? Simultaneously, a new harbour crossing is also being planned for Sydney's metro rail network.  Why not build into this metro line the capability of expansion into a branch to the northern beaches?  Crossing the harbour has always been a bottleneck for previous rail proposals, so here is an opportunity to take full advantage of a major piece of infrastructure, and also slow down Sydney's growing dependence on private cars using increasingly clogged roads.

Being driven mad

SMH letters dinkus DO NOT REMOVE TEXT

How will the robot drivers be programmed to avoid jaywalking texters, ignore backseat drivers, respond to cries of children asking 'Are we there yet' and put coins in parking meters?

Joyce earns accolades on 18C

Illustration Alan Moir

The debate over the race laws has put many people in the unaccustomed position of supporting Barnaby Joyce (" Christensen berates Joyce over race laws", March 3).  

Postscript: Who will pay the penalty for Fair Work pay decision?

How much workers should be paid for working Sundays is generating plenty of argument.

There will be penalties paid once the dust settles on the Fair Work Commission's decision to cut Sunday pay rates for hospitality and retail workers – but judging from the passion the issue has generated among our readers, the most punishing ones will be political.

Liberal Party's broad church is broken

SMH Letters

It now seems delusional to believe the Liberal Party is still able to comfortably accommodate the agendas of both its fiercely conservative right flank and its moderate, progressive centrists

Palestinians playing own part in impasse

SMH Letters

A just and enduring resolution to the conflict between Israelis and Palestinians is critical and long overdue ("Blind support for Israel does it no favours", February 18-19).

Reality check on insanity of wage growth

Illustration Alan Moir

Do we have record low interest rates? Tick. Stagnant wages and chronic underpayment of workers? Definite tick. Added to that, wages for many actually will fall thanks to the Fair Work Commission decision on Sunday penalty rates ("Paying the penalty: thousands face wage cuts", February 24).