Afternoon summary
- Theresa May is planning a tour of Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland in an attempt to build consensus before she triggers article 50 and embarks on the formal Brexit process, the Guardian understands. As Anushka Asthana reports, it has been suggested that the prime minister and the Brexit secretary, David Davis, will also meet key business figures to discuss Britain’s approach to the EU negotiations. Government figures have claimed there was always a plan to reach out to all parts of the United Kingdom, including responding to the Scottish government’s Brexit white paper, in the final two weeks of March before embarking on talks with the EU27.
- May has used a statement in the Commons to condemn the Scottish government’s call for a second independence. She also urged MPs not to refer to Brexit as a “divorce” from the EU. (See 3.36pm.)
- Nicola Sturgeon has indicated she could delay a fresh Scottish independence referendum until after Brexit, in the hope of a deal with Theresa May on its timing. As Severin Carrell reports, after saying on Monday the vote must be offered before the UK leaves the EU in March 2019, the first minister signalled she could stage it after that date if more time was needed to confirm the precise terms for the UK’s Brexit deal.
- The Scottish government has decided to hold its vote in the Scottish parliament calling for a second independence referendum next Wednesday.
- Pro-union activists are to stage a day of campaigning across Scotland in the wake of Nicola Sturgeon’s independence referendum announcement. As the Press Association reports, Scotland in Union said it aims to rally no voters who are “angry that their 2014 vote is being ignored”. The non-party movement, which has about 15,000 supporters, will take its campaign to towns and cities across the country on Saturday as the SNP meets for its spring conference in Aberdeen.
That’s all from me for today.
Thanks for the comments.
Rowena Mason
At cabinet this morning’s ministers discussed Scotland and the prime minister’s “plan for Britain”. Theresa May’s spokesman would not be drawn any further on her view of the timing of a second independence referendum, or Nicola Sturgeon’s claim to have more of a mandate than the prime minister.
He said the “plan for Britain” was not just about the vision for Brexit set out in May’s Lancaster House speech but a wide-ranging domestic agenda, including new legislation for the third session on education, health, policing, national security, new technology and infrastructure. The Downing Street spokesman said:
She said it was important to remember we have an ambitious programme for economic and social reform designed to deliver on the mission she set out on the steps of No 10: building a country for everyone, not just the privileged few. The PM said that as we look forward to negotiations we cannot lose sight of that mission. It is at the heart of the message the British people delivered at the referendum. They voted for signficant change to the way the country works and for whom it works forever. The PM said this is why she has developed a plan for Britain with two interim objectives - the right deal for Britain abroad and a better deal for working people at home, such as driving up skills and improving education.
The spokesman was pressed on whether this new agenda would depart from David Cameron election manifesto that gave him a mandate to govern in 2015. He said there was no retreat from that manifesto.
In her interview (see 2.18pm) Gina Miller talked about a leak today saying more than 10 acts of parliament will be needed to implement Brexit.
She was referring to this story in today’s Times (paywall) by Sam Coates. Here’s an extract.
Parliament will need to pass at least seven controversial bills to prepare Britain for life outside the European Union, according to a leaked list of legislation prepared by Whitehall.
Each new law, covering immigration, tax, agriculture, trade and customs regimes, fisheries, data protection and sanctions, will give MPs and peers the chance to influence the terms of Brexit. It will raise concerns in government that bills could be amended or blocked during what is already a tight two-year timetable ...
The Times has learnt that Mrs May faces a further testing legislative programme. Documents presented to ministers show that seven separate bills must be passed to set out Britain’s future after Brexit.
A further six bills may also be necessary, covering EU migrant benefits, reciprocal healthcare arrangements, road freight, nuclear safeguards, emissions trading and the transfer of spending from various EU funds to individual government departments.
Theresa May's statement - Summary
Here are the main points from Theresa May’s Commons statement.
- May condemned Nicola Sturgeon’s decision to call a second referendum on Scottish independence. Although this was not the subject of her statment, May made a reference to it in her opening remarks and then she was asked about the proposed referendum when being questioned by MPs. In her opening statement she said:
This is not a moment to play politics or create uncertainty and division. It is a moment to bring our country together; to honour the will of the British people and to shape for them a brighter future and a better Britain.
And later she said:
It is important that we keep the union of the United Kingdom together. There is much that binds us and I do not want to see anybody doing constitutional game playing with the future of the United Kingdom.
But May repeatedly refused to comment when asked whether she would accept or reject Sturgeon’s call for a referendum to take place between autumn 2018 and spring 2019. Generally she did not address the timing issue at all, although she did say that it was possible that the details of the Brexit detail would not be known until right at the end of the process (see 1.11pm) - countering Sturgeon’s argument that by autumn 2018 the outline of the final Brexit deal will be clear.
- May said that voting for independence would lead to Scotland leaving the EU. She said the Spanish government had been very clear that it was not possible for a country to break away from an EU member state and immediately rejoin the bloc.
This is the [former president of the European commission Jose Manuel] Barroso doctrine, it has been reaffirmed by the European commission, and so as far as Scotland is concerned independence would not mean membership of the European Union, it would mean that Scotland would remain outside the European Union.
- She said polling showed a majority of people in Scotland did not want a second referendum.
- She claimed there was a similarity between what the SNP wanted from the Brext talks and what she wanted. She told the SNP MP Joanna Cherry.
I have of course already set out the broad objectives of our negotiations which does include the reference to the very sort of trade deal that she and her colleagues have said they want to see for the United Kingdom and Scotland.
That is an unusual reading of the SNP’s position because their main point is that they want to stay in the single market, which May has rejected.
- May urged people not to describe Brexit as a “divorce”. She said:
A number of people have used this term of divorce. Actually, I prefer not to use the term of divorce from the European Union because very often when people get divorced they don’t have a very good relationship afterwards. Honourable members need to stop looking at this as simply coming out of the European Union and see the opportunity for building a new relationship with the European Union and that’s what we will be doing.
(I’m tempted to adapt a famous Guardian headline and summarise this as: ‘Don’t call our divorce from the EU a ‘divorce’, says May’.)
- She said staying in the single market would effectively mean staying in the EU.
Membership of the single market means accepting free movement, it means accepting the jurisdiction of the European court of justice, it means effectively remaining a member of the European Union. We have voted to leave the European Union and that is what we will be doing.
This is interesting because it it is an argument commonly used by hardcore leave campaigners in Ukip and on the Tory anti-European right, but almost no one else. Before June 23 May would never dreamt of deploying this logic, and the fact that she is doing so now is a measure of how far her thinking has shifted.
- She said that the government had taken legal advice about the threat of a legal challenge to Brexit. When the Tory Sir Bill Cash asked if this was the case, she replied:
I can assure [Bill Cash] that as we move ahead with this, as we have at every stage, we have of course taken appropriate legal advice.
- She welcomed the findings of a House of Lords report saying that the government will have no legal obligation to pay money into the EU budget after it leaves. When the Tory Jacob Rees-Mogg asked about this report, she replied:
I can assure [Rees-Mogg] that I have noted the House of Lords report on this particular matter. As he will know, when people voted on 23 June last year, I think they were very clear they did not want to continue year after year to be paying huge sums of money into the European Union.
- She said now was not the right time for a poll in Northern Ireland on uniting with the Republic of Ireland.
- She refused to say whether the government’s proposed transitional deal would involve the UK remaining part of the European Economic Area (EEA) for a time after Brexit.
Updated
Angus Robertson, the SNP leader at Westminster, has put out a press notice after Theresa May’s statement accusing her of giving up attempts to get a UK-wide approach to Brexit. He said:
The last time the prime minister came to the dispatch box from an EU Council meeting I asked her what issues she raised on behalf of the Scottish government and its priorities - she could not give a single example.
A year on, and given that this was the last EU Council before the triggering of article 50, the prime minister yet again failed to set out a single issue that was raised on behalf of Scotland or its priorities at the meeting.
Does the prime minister understand that this means the end of any pretence that she believes in a partnership of equals, it is an end to any claim of a respect agenda, it is an end to the credibility of a United Kingdom that listens and respects the different nations of the UK?
Scottish parliament to vote on second independence referendum next Wednesday
Nicola Sturgeon’s bid to seek the legal authority to allow Holyrood to stage a second independence referendum will be voted on by MSPs next Wednesday, the Press Association reports.
The Scottish parliament is due to spend two afternoons debating whether the first minister should be given the authority to seek a Section 30 order from Westminster.
The issue is then likely to be decided in a vote on March 22 - with the timetable expected to be confirmed by MSPs in a vote on March 15.
While the Conservatives, the Labour party and the Liberal Democrats have all vowed to oppose a second referendum, a majority of MSPs support Scotland leaving the UK.
Although Sturgeon’s SNP lost its overall majority in 2016, the election of six Scottish Green MSPs means 69 of the 129 politicians at Holyrood are in favour of independence.
The vote comes after Sturgeon announced on Monday she intended to “seek the authority of the Scottish parliament to agree with the UK government the details of a section 30 order - the procedure that will enable the Scottish parliament to legislate for an independence referendum”.
The SNP leader is also determined the terms of a second independence referendum be “made in Scotland”, saying Holyrood must be allowed to decide the question that will be put to voters and the timing of the ballot.
Here is Gina Miller, the businesswoman who took the government to court to force it to get parliament’s permission to trigger article 50, commenting on last night’s votes approving the Brexit bill.
The statement is now over. John Bercow, the Commons speaker, said 66 backbenchers asked questions.
Theresa May did not have anything big to announce and the statement was rather short on 24-carat news, but there was quite a lot that she did say that was new and intriguing for anyone following Brexit closely.
I will post a summary soon.
Labour’s Ian Murray asks May if she agrees that the principle of devolution should apply to powers coming back from Brussels.
May says she is opposed to taking any powers back from Scotland. And there may be a case for giving Scotland powers that come back from Brussels, she says.
May says she is opposed to describing Brexit as 'divorce'
May says she does not like the term “divorce” to cover Brexit. When people get divorced, they often don’t have a good relationship afterwards. She says she wants a good relationship with the EU afterwards.
- May says she is opposed to describing Brexit as a “divorce”.
Labour’s Heidi Alexander asks if EEA membership will be the basis for the transitional deal the government will seek. She accuses May of doing Ukip’s bidding.
May does not answer, but criticises Allan for her attack on her Brexit plans.
Updated
The SNP’s Peter Grant asks May if she accepts Nicola Sturgeon’s argument for a referendum between autumn 2018 and the spring of 2019.
May does not address the question, but she says will push for the best trade deal.
Labour’s Paula Sheriff asks about what the impact of Brexit will be on EU nurses working for the NHS.
May says she recognises the contribution EU nurses have made. But there are many people in the UK who want to train as nurses but who have not been able to. They will now, she says, because the cap on student numbers has been lifted.
View all comments >