The Guardian
Former finance minister and economist say Egypt is in dire predicament as foreign investment and tourism collapse
May 16, 2013
Patrick Kingsley
Egypt is suffering its worst economic crisis since the Great
Depression, a former finance minister of the country and one of its
leading economists have warned.
In terms of its devastating effect on Egypt's poorest, the country's
current economic predicament is at its most dire since the 1930s,
Galal Amin, professor of economics at the American University in Cairo, and
Samir Radwan, finance minister in the months after Egypt's 2011 uprising, said in separate interviews with the Guardian.
Since the fall of Hosni Mubarak in 2011, Egypt has experienced a
drastic fall in both foreign investment and tourism revenues, followed
by a 60% drop in foreign exchange reserves, a 3% drop in growth, and a
rapid devaluation of the Egyptian pound. All this has led to mushrooming
food prices, ballooning unemployment and a shortage of fuel and cooking
gas – causing Egypt's worst crisis, said Amin, "without fear of making a
mistake, since the 30s."
"Nobody cares about the poor now," Amin said. During comparable
crises in the late 1960s, the mid-70s and the late 80s, Amin and Radwan
argued that Egypt's poorest were variously shielded from absolute
hardship either by state subsidies, overseas aid, comparatively low
unemployment, or by remittances from expatriates in the Gulf states. But
now one in four young Egyptians is unemployed, household remittances
are low, and there is a shortage of subsidised goods.
"You are talking about nearly half of the population being in a state
of poverty," said Radwan, a development economist. "Either in absolute
poverty or near-poor, meaning that with any [economic] shock, like with
inflation, they will fall under the poverty line." Currently, 25.2% of
Egyptians are below the poverty line, with 23.7% hovering just above it,
according to figures supplied by the Egyptian government.
For most Egyptians, rising food prices are the most critical problem.
Some goods have doubled in price since last autumn – catastrophic for
the quarter of families that already spend 50% of their income on food.
For Hoda Goma, a Cairo architect, the situation is having a serious
effect on her two eight-year-old sons. "They're getting worse at
school," she said. "They're getting ill more often. They have these
black patches under their eyes and their teeth have got worse."
It is down to their diet, Goma explained. She cannot afford to feed
them what they need. Six months ago she spent half her salary on food.
Now she says it is closer to four-fifths – not because she is earning
less, but because rising food prices show no sign of slowing down.
"Prices are on fire," said grocer Walid Ali. Just last week, Ali
would buy a kilo of mandarins for four Egyptian pounds – or 40 British
pence – from wholesalers, and sell them for six (60 British pence). "Now
I buy them for six and sell them for eight."
As a result, consumers are either buying less, or not buying at all.
"It's impossible," said Ali. "I've lost half my customers. People can
only afford to buy basic foods." At his two-storey market in central
Cairo, the top floor is now entirely empty. Neighbours said all
stall-holders on the upper level had been forced to close in recent
months.
Inflated food prices are not a new phenomenon in a country that is
the world's biggest importer of wheat, where the population has long
risen more rapidly than production, and where up to half of the produce
rots in the heat on the way to market. But the recent rate of inflation
has been significantly raised by Egypt's disastrous economic
predicament.
Most problematically, the value of the Egyptian pound has fallen by 12% against the dollar since December. For two years,
Egypt's central bank had used its foreign currency reserves to arrest the slide
– but with those reserves having shrunk by around 60% since 2011, the
bank had to abandon the tactic last winter. As a result, the pound's
value has this year fallen further and faster. In turn, it has become
much more expensive to import foreign goods – catastrophic for a country
that buys in 60% of its wheat, and whose farmers also often rely on
imported fertiliser, fuel and animal feed.
"They have a serious crisis on their hands," said the EU's envoy to
Egypt, James Moran, who noted that Egypt's foreign reserves had fallen
from $36bn (£24bn) three years ago to $14.4bn last month. "This gives
you less than three months' import coverage – and in an import-dependent
economy, this is quite dangerous."
"We are suffering," said Ali Eissa, the chairman of Nahdet Misr, a
farm company which grows potatoes and oranges on 3,000 acres across
Egypt. "It's impacted most of our fertilisers, machines, tractors – all
their prices have dramatically increased."
The pound's devaluation has also made it
harder for the Egyptian government to import fuel. The state has
subsidised diesel
(along with goods such as bread, cooking gas and fertiliser) since the
dictatorship of Gamal Abdel Nasser. But with those subsidies now
accounting for over a fifth of the Egyptian budget, and with a budget
deficit of 13%, the state cannot afford to support the population at the
level it once did. As a result, there are daily shortages at pumps
across Egypt, long queues – and, at times, fatal fights.
"Last month, we couldn't find any diesel," said Eissa, who was
consequently forced to turn to the black market, where he says fuel
prices are between 40% and 80% higher than their legal rate. "The worst
thing is that most of the black market quantities are mixed with water –
which is breaking a lot of our machines. We have to change the filter,
get them maintained, stop the irrigation, stop the tractors."
In turn, farmers must sell their crops for higher prices – and with
the government also under pressure to cut subsidies, food is therefore
increasingly unaffordable for the poorest Egyptians. "The rich can take
care of themselves," said Karim Abadir, professor of econometrics at
Imperial College London, and a co-founder of the Free Egyptians, an
opposition party. "But the poor of Egypt are really, really poor.
Their
daily diet is just bread. First of all, that's a terrible diet.
Secondly, they're not even going to afford that. And the government has
nothing in place to provide them with a safety net when they have to
raise prices and cut subsidies."
So far, Mohamed Morsi's Islamist-led government has attempted to keep
Egypt afloat with short-term measures. It has accepted loans and grants
worth more than $5bn from Gulf states such as Qatar, and interest-free
fuel handouts from neighbouring Libya.
Domestically, it has avoided
major economic reforms that might cause short-term upheaval – perhaps
fearing bread riots similar to those experienced in 1977,
when the then dictator Anwar Sadat first temporarily tinkered with
subsidies.
Instead, Morsi has focused mainly on meaningless initiatives
such as tax rises on peripheral imports such as shrimp and nuts, or
closing shops early at night to save electricity. Morsi has also
attempted to legalise the controversial
sukuk, an Islamist form of government bond that may help to bring in more short-term cash.
"There is no vision, there is no vision whatsoever," said Radwan of
the government's current economic ministers. The Egyptian finance
ministry did not make any official available for interview.
Along with Amin, Radwan said the initial route out of the crisis was
obvious. The government needed to take the lead in restoring calm to the
polarised Egyptian street and its tumultuous political sphere. National
stability would give investors the confidence to reopen the 1,500
factories that have closed since 2011, and encourage tourists – whose
spending was once worth $1bn a month to the Egyptian economy – to
return.
"Restore stability, restore tourism, and restore confidence from
investors," summarised Amin. Such a process would raise employment, and
so lift millions from poverty, gradually allowing the government to end
food subsidies for those who would no longer need them.
"It has to be spread over a period of time otherwise the social
consequences would be very dire," said Amin. "As you succeed in raising
the income of the poor, you [can] reduce the subsidy."
The delivery of a much-delayed $4.8bn International Monetary Fund
loan – and a further $12bn in contingent loans from the EU and elsewhere
– depends on Egypt's agreement to such reforms. Without the loan,
foreign investment – which has fallen by 56% since 2011 – is also
unlikely to return.
Radwan said: "I regard the IMF loan, which I was the first to
negotiate, and it was turned down, as the key. Not because of the sum.
But because if you sign with the IMF, it means you have a sound
financial and monetary programme to get you out of the crisis."
Not everyone agrees. Amin sees the loan as too small to make much
difference in itself. Instead, he suggests Egypt should enact the
reforms the IMF suggests without taking on the debt itself.
"What is the
use of this $4.8bn sum?" Amin asked. "It is a big sum, but it still
less than what tourism used to bring you. The conclusion is that the
loan from the IMF is neither necessary nor sufficient. Not necessary
because by attacking the real problems, you can dispense with it – and
not sufficient, because if you don't attack the real problems it doesn't
help you very much. It's only short-term relief."
Whatever happens, while politicians prevaricate, ordinary Egyptians
are being ever more compromised by the soaring cost of living. Mostafa, a
30-year-old driver, started dealing hashish late last year when his
wife became pregnant, realising his monthly earnings of 1,500 Egyptian
pounds, or £150, would not be enough to feed his enlarged family.
"Without the drug dealing, I would only have 300 Egyptian pounds [£30]
to pay for everything after rent and food," Mostafa said. "How would I
be able to support my new children?"
Economists often predict a so-called "revolution of the hungry",
should conditions worsen further. But for Radwan, Egypt is already at
that stage: robbery rose 350% in 2012 as Egyptians
took wealth redistribution into their own hands.
"The elite sits there saying the revolt of the hungry is coming," said
Radwan. "What do you mean it's coming? Are you waiting for a violent,
bloody destruction of the Bastille? It's already there."
*Additional reporting by Mowaffaq Safadi
*Photos courtesy of Khaled Elfiqi (EPA) & Khaled Desouki (AFP)
