When in doubt, soak the rich. It seems obvious because, after all, there are votes in it, right?
Labor is reportedly flirting with the idea of imposing a tax floor in a system that is more often known for its tax flaws.
More National News Videos
- Video duration
- 01:22
Tax the rich?
Tax the rich?
It's named after US billionaire Warren Buffett - a proposal that the ultra-wealthy pay a minimum rate of tax.
Up Next
From mobile laundries to living rooms
- Video duration
- 00:50
- Video duration
- 00:50
From mobile laundries to living rooms
From mobile laundries to living rooms
Orange Sky pioneered mobile laundry services for the homeless and now they have launched a service offering a big screen TV and internet technology. Vision supplied: Orange Sky
Up Next
What are your consumer rights?
- Video duration
- 01:57
- Video duration
- 01:57
What are your consumer rights?
What are your consumer rights?
When are you eligible for a repair, replacement or a refund? The Australian Consumer Law gives you more rights than you might know.
Up Next
Does Australia have 'food security?'
- Video duration
- 02:14
- Video duration
- 02:14
Does Australia have 'food security?'
Does Australia have 'food security?'
Food security isn't just an issue for developing countries; in Australia we've already experienced the perils of food shortages.
Up Next
Ahmed Fahour's shock Australia Post resignation
- Video duration
- 01:08
- Video duration
- 01:08
Ahmed Fahour's shock Australia Post ...
Ahmed Fahour's shock Australia Post resignation
Mr Fahour surprisingly announced on Wednesday that he would resign just weeks after the revelation of his $5.6 million salary caused a national furore and drew the ire of Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull.
Up Next
Will a sugar tax really help?
- Video duration
- 03:18
- Video duration
- 03:18
Will a sugar tax really help?
Will a sugar tax really help?
The economics of a sugar tax might seem straight-forward, but some surprising statistics indicate potential flaws in the theory.
Up Next
Penalty rate cut: how did it happen?
- Video duration
- 02:07
- Video duration
- 02:07
Penalty rate cut: how did it happen?
Penalty rate cut: how did it happen?
Workplace reporter Nick Toscano contextualises the Fair Work Commission's announcement on Thursday that Sunday penalty rates paid in retail, fast food, hospitality and pharmacy industries will be reduced from the existing levels.
Up Next
Cambodian land grab victims confront ANZ
- Video duration
- 01:59
- Video duration
- 01:59
Cambodian land grab victims confront ANZ
Cambodian land grab victims confront ANZ
Four farmers forcibly evicted from their land in rural Cambodia by a land grab financed by ANZ have travelled to Melbourne on behalf of almost 700 Cambodian families seeking compensation from the bank.
Tax the rich?
It's named after US billionaire Warren Buffett - a proposal that the ultra-wealthy pay a minimum rate of tax.
Clever, creative accountants and crafty tax lawyers, look out. Clients earning above the $300,000-a-year-mark would face a minimum bill of say, 35 per cent. That's a hefty margin-sapping slug - like $105 grand annually.
Mind you, upper middle-income-earners are being hit like this every single year, percentage-wise, so it is not so onerous. And besides, that's its attraction: both fiscally and politically.
Related Content
The budget is short on funds and long on resentment as the rich minimise their declared income to avoid paying their fair share.
And those schmucks who cannot fiddle their particulars pay extra, only to be dudded with deteriorating services, a failing safety net and endless lectures about living within their means.
Meanwhile, the budget stays determinedly in the red anyway.
So, a Buffett rule - a mandated minimum tax bill for the super-rich makes both sense and cents. Plenty of them potentially. Good policy even.
But the fiscal repair benefits should not be over-stated. Even with their tricks, wealthier taxpayers already carry a heavy burden of personal tax revenue. And the design of such rules is extremely problematic because fairly distinguishing legitimate work expenses - say the cost of a ute - from those that are not, is anything but straightforward.
For small businesses, sole traders, this is critical.
Should Labor embrace the idea, it will win plaudits but put at risk its hard-won reputation as pro-aspirational, pro-wealth accumulation, pro-business.
Sure as eggs, the government will tag the move as creeping socialism, and of course, as typical of a party that never sees a problem that cannot be fixed with more taxes.
And if Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull is captive to his conservative right wing, Labor leader Bill Shorten increasingly appears vulnerable to the charge of being in thrall to the left.
Whether it be climate policy - where he is struggling to reassure voters that his 50 per cent renewable commitment is affordable, or other policies, a gathering Coalition narrative paints Shorten as a populist, every bit as desperate to neutralise his green-left flank as Turnbull is to manage One Nation and the Nats on his right.
Meanwhile the middle gets thinner.
238 comments
Comment are now closed