Find Me On

  • Xbox Live
    KefkaTaran
  • PlayStation Network
    KefkaTaran
  • Steam
    KefkaTaran
  • Battle.net
    KefkaTaran
  • Nintendo Wii U
    KefkaTaran

Phil Kollar

  • joined Sep 28, 2012
  • last login Feb 22, 2017
  • posts 858
  • comments 1656

I'm the deputy reviews editor for Polygon. This means that I play lots of video games and write lots of words about them. It's pretty rad.

Email: phil@polygon.com

Website: Polygon

Ethics Disclosure:

I worked as a freelance contractor for Natsume in 2009, editing the script for Harvest Moon DS: Sunshine Islands. I back the following creators on Patreon: Mattie Brice, Arielle Grimes, Hardcore Gaming 101, Void Burger, Carolyn Petit

Recent Activity

Article
5 Comments
Article
2 Comments
Comment
1 reply

Yeah, I think this is a big part of the issue, and one with no easy solutions. There needs to be better tools for YouTubers looking for support on a lot of stuff, but making that happen is … difficult. To say the least.

Comment
Recommended (4)

Games do not start at a 10 and then get deducted points for each issue. I do not think the gameplay is shallow, just less deep than some other games. Very big difference there, and as I stated, I think it works to Horizon’s benefit mostly.

Comment
Recommended (2)

1,600 words is more detailed than most our reviews, but also a 10 does not = "perfect" on our scale. Sorry!

Re: hacking robots, I didn’t make a ton of use of this, which is why I didn’t mention it, but I also had no problems doing it when I tried.

I did mention that there is less depth/more approachability than other games in this style (i.e. Monster Hunter), but I don’t feel that strongly detracted from the game.

I don’t get the "can’t plan ahead" complaint at all. But either way, the game provides plenty of space for changing up tactics on the fly.

Comment
1 reply

No clue! If they’ve announced any, it’s not obvious where it would slot into the game or anything.

Comment
2 replies Recommended (12)

I played it on a regular PS4 and the performance was more or less flawless for me.

Comment
Recommended (3)

Bad news: You have to deal with focus vision to see footsteps. I am sorry! (But once you see them, you can highlight and see them outside of focus vision too.)

Comment
Recommended (12)

Wha? This is well above our average review length. We try to keep most reviews around 1,000 words; this one is over 1,600.

Comment
1 reply Recommended (4)

I’d rather not say more for fear of spoiling any of the surprise :blush:

Comment
1 reply

Nier is later in the U.S. at least!

Comment
1 reply Recommended (3)

Yep, the title is at least partially explained.

Review
147 Comments
Comment
Recommended (25)

[whisper] Fire Emblem isn’t made by Square Enix.

Feature
10 Comments
Article
13 Comments
Comment
1 reply Recommended (15)

This is an article reporting on an interesting trend in a game. It’s not an op-ed arguing for removal of anything.

Review
76 Comments
Nioh review
14 days ago
Article
4 Comments
Article
13 Comments
Article
76 Comments
Feature
15 Comments
Article
25 Comments
Article
3 Comments
Comment
Recommended (3)
Article
8 Comments
Comment
1 reply

Yeah, I’ve seen that theory floated to. The only weird part is, why would he need to lie to this dude who’s never met him?