AFL
  1. Home
  2. Sport
  3. AFL
  4. News

Jobe Watson has returned his 2012 Brownlow Medal to the AFL

Caroline Wilson

Up Next

Home invasion leaves Essendon players shaken

null
Video duration
01:40

More AFL Real Footy Videos

null
Video duration
01:40

Home invasion leaves Essendon players ...
Tiana Ernst
Video duration
02:33

Living two lives
null
Video duration
01:32

Essendon offers support following Hird ...
SYDNEY, AUSTRALIA - DECEMBER 05: Isaac Heeney performs strength drills during a Sydney Swans AFL pre-season training ...
Video duration
00:47

Heeney wants midfield spot
More videos

AFLW Plays of Round One

The most stunning plays from round one of the AFLW.

The most controversial Brownlow Medal in the game's history now sits in a drawer in Gillon McLachlan's office, with Jobe Watson having delivered his 2012 Brownlow back to the AFL.

The AFL chief revealed that Watson had organised for the medal to be returned to the game's head office but would not elaborate on whether the former Essendon captain had delivered it personally. McLachlan said he had not asked Watson to return the medal.

"It's in a drawer in my office," McLachlan said. "He [Watson] gave it back. He's not the 2012 Brownlow medallist, that decision was made and that's the end of it as far as we're concerned."

Related Content

The delivery of the medal was handled by McLachlan, Watson and Watson's father Tim. The former captain's manager, Craig Kelly, said he had no knowledge of the medal's whereabouts and that he had not been involved in its return, saying it was a personal issue for the Watson family.

The highly sensitive issue has been the topic of some debate since the AFL accepted Watson's decision to relinquish the medal last November.

Advertisement

The unique and devastating nature of the move has clearly tested McLachlan, who refused to even explain in an AFL media briefing on Tuesday how the medal had come to end up in his drawer.

The prevailing view is that the AFL, having reached the view that Watson could not keep the medal given the finding of the Court of Arbitration for Sport, had been reluctant to add insult to injury by immediately forcing him to physically return it.

Also reluctant to put a time on when Watson had given back the medal – which is understood to have previously been in New York – but implying he had done so in recent days, the league CEO added he had "no idea" what the AFL would do with the relinquished Brownlow.

"I've always believed Jobe to be a man of great character and integrity and he's demonstrated that again in the last 24 hours," said McLachlan of Watson, who on Wednesday was replaced as Essendon captain by Dyson Heppell.

"This is such a personal matter. The relevant thing is a decision has been made about the Brownlow Medal and the medal has been returned."

Watson announced he was returning the Brownlow Medal in a carefully worded statement last November but made it clear he did not believe his brilliant 2012 season had come as a result of performance-enhancing drugs.

He said it had been "incredibly distressing" to have his integrity questioned and suffer the inference he had acted against the spirit of the game.

"If there is a question in peoples' minds as to whether the 2012 award is tainted, the fairest and best thing to do is to give it back and honour the history that has gone before me."

"I want to make it clear that today's decision does not in any way reflect a change in my personal opinion regarding the CAS finding, but rather reflects my desire to put to a close further speculation about what should be done with the 2012 Brownlow Medal."

However speculation as to the physical whereabouts of the medal continued because McLachlan refused to say whether Watson had actually given it back. The ongoing delicacy around the relinquished Brownlow spilt over into the handling of the new medallists Trent Cotchin and Sam Mitchell.

That sensitivity was shared by Kelly, who struggled personally with the stripped Brownlow on Watson's behalf and when quizzed about the medal responded: "The dog ate it".

McLachlan was also reluctant to elaborate upon his thoughts on James Hird's serious health issues and in one briefing bristled at suggestions the actions of the AFL had contributed to Hird's drug overdose in January.

He also refused to address comments by Hird's father Allan, who laid blame at the league, and said he had not spoken to the senior Hird. "This is an incredibly difficult situation," McLachlan said. "I feel for James and his family terribly. We're terribly aware of how difficult it is.

"We stand willing here and able to help but we, like everyone else, have been specifically asked by his wife to respect the family's privacy. This is just a really tough situation."

0 comments