François Fillon blames French media for centre-right campaign crisis

Francois Fillon has been under a preliminary probe since news reports said he paid his wife Penelope and two of the ...
Francois Fillon has been under a preliminary probe since news reports said he paid his wife Penelope and two of the couple's children nearly one million dollars from public funds over the years for allegedly fake jobs as his parliamentary aides. THIBAULT CAMUS
by Adam Nossiter

The embattled centre-right candidate in France's presidential race, François Fillon, called an extraordinary news conference Monday to defend paying his wife hundreds of thousands of euros as his supposed parliamentary assistant, saying he had been the victim of a "media lynching."

"All the facts are perfectly legal and transparent," he said.

Before Monday, the air of scandal swirling around Fillon had led to speculation in the French news media that he would pull out of the race. Instead, he used the news conference at his Paris campaign headquarters to start a last-ditch effort to save his faltering candidacy.

Fillon lashed out at the news media, insisted that the work his wife had done for him was real, defended his own ethics and said he was staying in the race. "There has been a press campaign of unheard-of violence," he told reporters.

A bad hire

Fillon's troubles have grown with a string of revelations that he paid his wife and children nearly €1 million from public payrolls, prompting an investigation by France's financial prosecutor.

While it is legal for members of Parliament to hire family members, it is not clear that Fillon's wife or children actually did much for the money, and the scandal has fed public disillusionment with a cosseted political establishment.

As Fillon has plummeted in the polls, the presidential race has unexpectedly opened up to two maverick candidacies. The far-right National Front's Marine Le Pen and an independent, Emmanuel Macron, the former economy minister, are now seen as likely to face each other in a runoff in May.

The Le Pen factor

If Le Pen wins, it could mean the disintegration of the European Union – she has vowed to hold a referendum on France's membership – and would be further evidence of the tide of authoritarian populism sweeping parts of the West.

A Le Pen victory is still considered unlikely, but the political tides on both sides of the Atlantic have proved unpredictable, and the race is being closely watched for its potential impact across Europe.

The Socialist Party, tainted by the unpopular president, François Hollande, has been almost a nonfactor in the race. Fillon's fall now signals the cratering of both of France's establishment parties.

It looks like a catastrophe for his center-right Republican Party, which has no fallback candidate.

Plan B: Berezina

On Monday, Fillon joked grimly that the only Plan B was "Berezina" – a reference to Napoleon's disastrous 1812 defeat in Russia. But it was far from clear that his performance Monday, combative and pugnacious, would be enough to salvage his candidacy.

He mostly blamed the news media for his troubles, and he offered no proof that his wife had carried out substantive tasks – essentially merely repeating his first defense.

Fillon apologised to French voters for what he called an "error" in employing her, but he noted that many other members of Parliament hired family members.

"If the system needs to be reformed, reform it," he said. "There are old practices that aren't acceptable."

He suggested there was a conspiracy to deprive French voters of the "only candidate" who was proposing real change.

"The goal is to wipe out the choice the voters made in the primary," he told reporters at the news conference. "They are doing this because I am proposing a program of total change. But you can't steal their choice from them."

A family disagreement

But Fillon did not directly rebut suggestions by his wife, Penelope Fillon, made long before the scandal broke, that she had never done any work for him.

In 2007, after her husband became prime minister, Penelope Fillon, who is of Welsh origin, told a British journalist that she had "never been his assistant." That interview, exhumed last week, severely hurt her husband's case.

On Monday, her husband was able to say only: "She was first and foremost my companion in work. She was discreet."

He said that she had handled "correspondence" and represented him in "cultural manifestations" in his district in rural western France. But there was no documentation of any work.

At the same time, the old interview with Penelope Fillon revealed, poignantly, a politician's wife who had spent years in her husband's shadow. She felt that her intelligence and accomplishments were underused and worried about how her children perceived her.

'I'm not stupid'

"I realised that my children have only known me as just a mother," she was quoted as saying. "But I did a French degree, I qualified as a lawyer, and I thought, 'Look here, I'm not that stupid.'"

Penelope Fillon is seen in much of the French news media as a victim in the scandal – perhaps exploited by a husband of modest means whose social circle nonetheless included moneyed aristocrats and others of wealth. Her husband said Monday that his wife's remarks had been taken out of context.

Repeatedly, François Fillon expressed his contempt for and anger at the news media.

"This campaign against me is defamatory," he said. "None of you has a question about the violence of these accusations against me."

"Politically assassinate me, as you have done for 10 days now, that poses a real problem," Fillon said. "But the French are realising this," he added, vowing to carry on with his campaign.

The New York Times