Federal Politics

Courageous or crazy Cory? Nine political defections that ended in tears

  • 62 reading now

"Pray. Pray hard."

That was Barnaby Joyce's pithy advice to Cory Bernardi, the latest in a long but no-so-illustrious line of Australian political turncoats.

Up Next

One-upmanship: question time's top three

null
Video duration
01:29

More National News Videos

Cory Bernardi: Why I quit

Just minutes after publicly quitting the Liberal Party, the Senator reveals why he had to do it.

While Bernardi hopes to build a new nationwide conservative movement, modern political history suggests his decision is more likely to end in tears.

Here are nine examples of relatively recent federal defections resulting in disappointment, defeat or disgrace.

Ian Macfarlane 

The Queenslander defected from the Liberals after Malcolm Turnbull removed him from the ministry shortly after coming to power in 2015. His plan was to join the Nationals and continue his parliamentary career, and possibly even find his way back on to the frontbench. But the Queensland LNP intervened to block the move, leading to Macfarlane's decision to quit politics.

Liberal MP Ian Macfarlane holds up an ALP membership form sent to him as a joke during Question Time after it was announced he planned to defect to the Nationals, at Parliament House in Canberra on Thursday 3 December 2015. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Ian Macfarlane. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Advertisement

Julian McGauran 

The Victorian senator did the reverse of Macfarlane, quitting the Nationals to join the Liberals. He said he was doing it because it would let him better represent his constituents and there were no significant policy differences between the two parties any way. In reality, he was maneuvering to keep a winnable spot on the Coalition Senate ticket, which he did - but then lost to a minor party.

Senator Julian McGauran speaks at a media conference in Melbourne, Monday Jan. 23, 2006, announcing his resignation from the National Party to join the Victorian Liberal Party. Senator McGauran said he hoped to be sitting with the Liberals when federal parliament resumed. (AAP Image/Joe Castro) NO ARCHIVING

Julian McGauran. Photo: AAP

Peter Slipper 

The Queenslander quit the Liberals to take up the Speaker's chair in 2011, giving Julia Gillard a much-needed fillip in the finely-balanced minority Parliament. But it didn't last. Six months later, he was forced to stand aside over travel rorts and a few months after that he resigned amid sexual harassment allegations. He stood as an independent at the 2013 election but lost.

Peter Slipper.

Peter Slipper. Photo: Andrew Meares

Mal Colston 

The Queensland did a similar deal to Slipper: he quit Labor to sit as an independent after John Howard's government promised to hand him the coveted position of Deputy President of the Senate. And much like Slipper, he was undone by travel rorts. He was charged with defrauding the Commonwealth in 1997 but never actually stood trial because he was suffering from terminal cancer.

Late senator Mal Colston.

Mal Colston. Photo: Mike Bowers

Shayne Murphy

The Tasmanian was another Labor senator who quit to sit as an independent, citing his opposition to the ALP's policy on logging. His decision gave him a high-profile balance-of-power position on the crossbench - and he often voted with his former Coalition foes. But like most defectors, he just couldn't hold on to his seat, losing his spot at the 2004 election.

SPECIAL IRAQ FAIRFAX , NEWS , IRAQ DEBATE SENATE Sen Shayne Murphy TAS ALP . Photograph taken by Paul Harris /prh on the 5th Feb 2003

Shayne Murphy.  Photo: Paul Harris

Cheryl Kernot 

The former Democrats leader gave us one of the most spectacular defections of all time, quitting after seven years in the top job to join Labor. It didn't go terribly well and while she won the lower house seat of Dickson in 1998, she lost it in 2001. But that wasn't the end of the drama: a year later it emerged she had had a long affair with Labor's Gareth Evans, who helped engineer her switch.

In 2002, Laurie Oakes✓​ controversially reported a relationship between Cheryl Kernot✓ and Gareth Evans✓ after she omitted the relationship from her autobiography.

Cheryl Kernot with Gareth Evans. Photo: The West Australian

Meg Lees

Another Democrat leader to depart. She was the leader of the party who controversially helped John Howard introduce a GST. She subsequently lost the party's leadership and quit to sit as an independent. Much like Cory Bernardi, she had grands plans to start a new movement, forming the Australian Progressive Alliance in 2003. It was a fizzer and Lees lost her spot in Parliament a year later.

990528...News...GTidypic...RPeake story...After coming to a compromise agreement on the GST,Australian Democrats leader, Senator Meg Lees holds a media conference immediately after the PM and Treasurer held theirs.

Meg Lees.  Photo: Graham Tidy

Tony Windsor and Rob Oakeshott

The duo both defected twice, in a sense. Both belonged to the Nationals before becoming independents at a state level. But it was their mutual decision to support Gillard's Labor in 2010 that was their undoing: their conservative electors saw it as a betrayal of their values and of their independence. Both men resigned rather than face their wrath - both attempted comebacks but failed.

An emotional Tony Windsor and Rob Oakeshott announced they will not recontest the next election at Parliament House in Canberra on  Parliament House Canberra on Wednesday 26 June 2013. Photo: Andrew Meares

Rob Oakeshott and Tony Windsor. Photo: Andrew Meares

Rod Culleton 

The embattled West Australian is the most recent defection on this list, quitting One Nation just five months into his job. A few weeks later, his job evaporated altogether when he was declared bankrupt. If he had stayed in the One Nation stable, the party probably would have found a way to look after him. But his spectacular falling-out with Pauline Hanson means he has got nothing but debt. 

Rod Culleton, with his  Australian Senator pin on display, departs the High Court earlier this week.

Rod Culleton. Photo: Alex Ellinghausen

Follow us on Facebook