ASK THE DOCTOR: Is a painful tum a sign that I have gallstones?
Until recently I worked as flight crew for a major airline. During one stop-over in the Far East, I paid to have a full medical check-up. An ultrasound showed I had a 23mm gallstone. I had no symptoms and medical opinion was split on whether to remove my gallbladder or leave it, so I decided to leave it be.
Seven years later, I sometimes get a severe stabbing pain in my left lower abdomen. The pain comes in sharp short throbs, lasting one to ten seconds, and feels like I'm being jabbed with a needle. I am 63.
Robert Bailey, by email.
The most common symptom of gallstones is pain, known as biliary colic, when the stone blocks the bile duct
Gallstones are common and affect about one in ten adults. In most cases they cause no symptoms, although studies have shown that about 15 per cent of people whose stones are found 'accidentally', as in your case, will go on to develop symptoms at some stage in the next ten years.
The most common symptom is pain, known as biliary colic, which occurs when the stone blocks the bile duct.
The pain is typically felt in the right upper abdomen, although it can be felt more centrally, behind the sternum (breastbone), and may even be mistaken for heart pain. The pain can also radiate in to the back, or right shoulder blade region.
It is usually severe and can last from several minutes to several hours, but remains constant. So the pain that you describe in your left lower abdomen, which occurs in short throbs, is not typical of gallstone pain, either in distribution or character - but I will say more on this later.
About 15 per cent of people whose stones are found 'accidentally' will go on to develop symptoms
As for not having the surgery seven years ago, I believe you made the right decision. It is not normal practice to remove the gallbladder for the sake of symptomless gallstones.
However, when the stones do cause symptoms, we do have to remove the gallbladder; the presence of stones is a sign of gallbladder disease and more stones will inevitably form in future, with the risk of other complications, such as infection, so just removing the stones is not an option.
Your symptoms, while unlikely to be due to the gallstone, do merit further investigation.
I wonder whether your problems are linked to a stone that's migrated from your left kidney to the ureter, the tube that connects the kidney to the bladder.
Stones that originate in the kidney are known as kidney stones, though doctors tend to use the term 'urinary stones', as they can become stuck anywhere between the kidney, the bladder or even the urethra on the way out. Urinary stones can cause intermittent pain with few other symptoms.
Problems could be due to a stone that's migrated from the left kidney to the ureter [file photo]
Another possibility is that your pain is actually intestinal pain originating in the descending or sigmoid colon, both part of the large intestine.
The matter should be looked at further and I would recommend that you discuss this issue with your GP.
In the past two years, I've had bouts of bleeding from the bowel.
More from Martin Scurr for the Daily Mail...
- 'Do I actually need an op to unblock my arteries?': Our expert reveals if statins are enough to keep your heart disease at bay 02/01/17
- ASK THE DOCTOR: Why is my nose blocked or runny all the time? 28/12/16
- ASK THE DOCTOR: My hot flushes and night sweats have lasted for 22 YEARS - is there anything I can do? 19/12/16
- Tens of thousands are diagnosed with prostate cancer every year, so how often should YOU go for a screening? Our expert gives his advice on tests and treatments 12/12/16
- 'Can the fasting diet reduce my weight and ease my diabetes?' Our expert explains why dieting is essential for overweight patients to protect their future health 05/12/16
- 'What can I do about my severe stomach cramps?' Our expert advises a 30-year-old who has been diagnosed with a stomach condition normally found in pensioners 28/11/16
- Can a laser beam really get rid of piles forever? A reader consults our expert about the new procedure, as he wants to avoid a painful operation 21/11/16
- 'Do we REALLY have to pay £2,000 for a Lyme disease test?' A reader is worried his daughter may need an expensive treatment in Germany after falling ill from a tick bite 14/11/16
- Why does my son look PREGNANT? Our expert explains why some men have big bellies and stick-thin limbs, and reveals how to banish the food baby for good 07/11/16
- VIEW FULL ARCHIVE
My GP was vague about the problem and what caused it; my local pharmacist said it was unusual to get the problem for the first time at my age, 74. I recently read that unabsorbed iron in the gut may cause bowel disease.
For several years now I've been eating a great deal of watercress - often four to six bunches a week - for its vitamins and nutrients, one of which is iron. Have I been overdosing on it?
B. Darlow, Kempston, Beds.
There are two aspects to your letter: most importantly what should be done about rectal bleeding - and, second, whether eating watercress almost every day can do harm.
In my opinion, rectal bleeding must be investigated.
It is not good enough, particularly in an older patient, to assume that it is due to an unimportant problem such as haemorrhoids (piles) - these are common and, if they cause no symptoms apart from occasional slight blood loss, can be ignored. But an exact diagnosis is needed.
Rectal bleeding can be caused by diverticular disease (where small bulges or pockets form in the lining of the intestine), inflammatory bowel disease (this includes Crohn's disease and ulcerative colitis and it is certainly true that it's unusual for either to occur for the first time in someone of your age) and colon cancer.
Your bouts of bleeding should be investigated by an inspection of the colon - the gold standard is a colonoscopy, during which a doctor examines the inner lining of your large intestine using a thin, flexible tube with a tiny camera attached.
The recent article you mention suggested unabsorbed iron in the intestine was linked to inflammation and changes in gut bacteria, which could increase the risk of bowel disease: the article suggested seaweed pills might prevent this by binding to excess iron in the gut.
This is still an area of ongoing research, and it could even be that the watercress you've been eating might have the same protective effect as seaweed, rather than the negative effect you fear.
However, studies into any potentially protective effect of watercress have not been conducted.
What I can tell you is that the nutritional constituents of watercress have been evaluated in great detail.
According to McCance and Widdowson's Composition of Foods - the authoritative record of nutrient data for the most commonly consumed foods in the UK - 100g of raw watercress contains 2520mcg of carotene (vitamin A), several milligrams of vitamin E and the B group of vitamins, and 62mg of vitamin C.
In terms of minerals, there is sodium, potassium, calcium, phosphorus, copper, zinc, chloride, manganese - and iron (2.2mg only). All these are very good nutritionally, and none is found in excess in watercress.
Studies into any potentially protective effect of watercress - which is very nutritious - have not been conducted
I would add that what is important is you are taking care to eat foods that are fresh and unadulterated with additives that are a feature of so many manufactured foods. This attitude is ideal for promoting good health.
Do discuss the rectal bleeding once again with your doctor, to consider the possible causes, and have no fear about the watercress, even on a daily basis.
By the way ... Hospital really is no place to die
I think it's fair to say that hospitals are not good places for those dying from chronic disease - too often we read of inadequate treatment and the unnecessary suffering of these patients, which is both unsettling and puzzling. After all, this is not high-tech medical care, nor are the failures in care due to lack of understanding.
Instead, the problem centres around deficiencies in the so-called 'soft side' of medical and nursing treatment: essentially, kindness and compassion.
These are things that are difficult to teach and where standards are difficult to measure - and which have suffered in the current culture with its emphasis on protocols, tick-box mentality, completing the paperwork and so on.
Thus it was that the Liverpool Care Pathway (a set of guidelines that was intended to assist those professionals engaged in the giving of palliative care) ended up being so misused - with dying patients being refused even a sip of water, in some instances - that it ended up having to be abandoned.
Blind adherence to the pathway became an end in itself, thereby missing the point entirely.
When it first emerged many decades ago, the hospice movement led the way in how it should be done, with doctors and nurses trained in the care of the dying based upon apprenticeship and experience: young professionals learned by the example set by their senior colleagues.
There is no reason at all why this shouldn't also be what happens in hospitals, yet somehow we have deviated from the four pillars of medical ethics in the care of dying patients. These are: autonomy - if someone is thirsty, give them a drink and allow them to govern what is happening to them; beneficence - be kind, be gentle, be understanding and ease pain; non-maleficence - do nothing harmful, help settle tumultuous emotions, do not sit in judgment; and, finally, justice - be fair, do everything to ease the journey and the suffering, within what is laid down by law.
The word hospice originally referred to a place of rest for a weary traveller, often a traveller who was ill or dying.
Any of us who care for the dying must take care to remember that and adhere to these four key principles. It's no less than what we'd want for ourselves or our loved ones, too.
Most watched News videos
- Five inmates injured during prison brawl at Chicago jail
- Heartbreaking moment horse cries at owner's funeral
- Al Jazeera Investigations film Shai Masot while undercover
- Woman hilariously struggles to keep her footing on icy driveway
- Inside the epic White House party
- "UFO" has been filmed demonstrating highly unusual behaviour
- David Blaine to risk electrocution in truly shocking new stunt
- Queen attends church for first time since heavy cold
- Hammerhead shark bites whaler in half as fisherman reels in
- Up close and personal with Emma Thynn AKA Lady Weymouth
- Researchers find mysterious giant 'alien claw' in Peru
- GRAPHIC: Cop shoots deer at point blank range
-
Inside the Obamas' final star-studded party: White House...
-
Horrifying moment a truck driver mows down soldiers in...
-
72 MILLION are put under a winter storm warning: Three dead...
-
'Is that a RAT?': Woman posts a glamorous selfie of her...
-
Brad Pitt's fury over leaked court records as friends accuse...
-
Our little miracle of Longleat: Lady Weymouth – Britain’s...
-
'I was sure I was dead': Magician David Blaine's attempt to...
-
The British girl from Rochdale who became a jihadi bride for...
-
Texas mother LAUGHS in her mugshot as she is charged with...
-
'My girl was not raised like that': Grandmother of two black...
-
Hacking cough that can last weeks has struck down thousands...
-
Sick thug filmed rape of his girlfriend and threatened to...