ROBERT HARDMAN: Queen Victoria a greater monarch than Elizabeth II? Twaddle! She was a workshy recluse
Late next Wednesday afternoon, there will have to be yet another amendment to the royal record books. And, this time, it’s the big one.
On September 9, the Queen’s reign will surpass the 63 years, seven months and two days that Queen Victoria sat on the throne.
Elizabeth II is already our longest-lived monarch, enjoying history’s most enduring royal marriage.
The first reigning monarch to fly in a helicopter, visit every single realm and change a puncture (among umpteen other firsts), Her Majesty will still not be the world’s longest-reigning monarch. That honour, for now, rests with King Bhumibol of Thailand.
![Elizabeth II is already our longest-lived monarch but on September 9 she will become the longest serving as well, surpassing Queen Victoria](http://web.archive.org./web/20170423010036/http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/09/02/01/29A460AE00000578-3219090-image-a-43_1441154101305.jpg)
Elizabeth II is already our longest-lived monarch but on September 9 she will become the longest serving as well, surpassing Queen Victoria
But she will have reached a milestone which may never be surpassed in the annals of these islands. It is, by any standards, a historic moment.
The Queen remains endearingly underwhelmed by the occasion. Never one for competition with the ancestors, she had originally planned to spend the day quietly and privately at Balmoral.
When it became clear that the rest of the world regarded this as a major landmark, she accepted that a public appearance would be required, provided there was a point to it all. So, she will spend the day opening the new Borders railway line in Scotland.
Elsewhere, however, there will be the greatest outpouring of affection since her Diamond Jubilee in 2012. There will be speeches in Parliament, the minting of a new coin, special programmes and much analysis in the global media.
![Queen Victoria 'was happy to be an Empress, she never set foot in her empire'](http://web.archive.org./web/20170423010036/http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/09/02/01/27AEC49000000578-3219090-image-a-45_1441154141353.jpg)
Queen Victoria 'was happy to be an Empress, she never set foot in her empire'
Yet, inevitably, there is a truculent minority for whom this is not a moment to celebrate or reflect. Instead, it is time for a fight.
The republican fringe, invigorated by the prospect of an overtly anti-monarchist Labour leader, are as sour as ever. Reheating her familiar cry for the Queen to go down in history as ‘Elizabeth the Last’, The Guardian’s Polly Toynbee dismisses her as the ‘past mistress of nothingness’ and warns: ‘Another avalanche of adulation is about to asphyxiate us.’
More noteworthy is the contribution from Britain’s pre-eminent historian-curmudgeon, Dr David Starkey. He accuses the Queen of the crime of banality.
While ‘Victoria was and remains universally instantly recognisable’, Dr Starkey argues in the Radio Times, the opposite applies to Elizabeth II: ‘She has done and said nothing that anybody will remember. She will not give her name to her age. Or, I suspect, to anything else.’
He then adds crisply: ‘I say this not as criticism but simply as a statement of fact. Even as a sort of compliment. And, I suspect, the Queen would take it as such.’
I suspect (and we can all ‘suspect’ because we will never know), the Queen couldn’t give two hoots. After more than six decades on her throne, she has heard pretty much every extreme of flattery and abuse levelled at it.
But it is sad to see a historian as distinguished as Dr Starkey peddling such utter tosh at such an important moment.
His words rang a vague bell in my mind and, after a little digging, I realised why.
When the Queen notched up her previous milestone, overtaking Victoria to become our longest-lived monarch in 2007, the same David Starkey chose to give a similarly inflammatory interview to The Guardian, accusing the Queen of being a philistine, among other things.
![David Starkey has argued that while ‘Victoria was and remains universally instantly recognisable,’ Elizabeth II, 'has done and said nothing that anybody will remember'](http://web.archive.org./web/20170423010036/http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/09/02/01/1B150707000005DC-3219090-image-a-46_1441154222410.jpg)
David Starkey has argued that while ‘Victoria was and remains universally instantly recognisable,’ Elizabeth II, 'has done and said nothing that anybody will remember'
This time, he salutes the ‘boundless energy’ of the Victorian age, while he sneers that the present Queen has redefined the monarch’s three existing constitutional rights, ‘to be consulted, to encourage and to warn’, by adding a fourth — ‘the duty to be silent and make no public comment’.
That the Queen has worked with 12 British Prime Ministers, not to mention more than 150 PMs in all her other realms, without a batsqueak of criticism is, to my mind, a far more accurate, impressive barometer of constitutional success.
Dr Starkey also overlooks the fact she is the only sovereign who has genuinely redefined the role of the monarch.
It is there in black and white on the royal website. The Queen is the first sovereign to embrace not just the role of ‘Head of State’, with its official obligations, but the equally important role of ‘Head of Nation’, encompassing recognition of excellence, service, national unity and continuity.
So let us turn the argument around and imagine it was Victoria reigning today. If so, the monarchy would be in serious trouble.
Where, for example, would the monarch have been at the State Opening of Parliament? Not in Parliament, that’s for sure. After the death of Prince Albert, Victoria set foot in the place only six times, and invariably left the chore of reading the Queen’s Speech to the Lord Chancellor.
![The Queen with Prince William, Prince George, Catherine Duchess of Cambridge and Prince Harry watch the Trooping of the Colour in June. She is set to surpass the 63 years, seven months and two days that her great-great-grandmother Queen Victoria sat on the throne](http://web.archive.org./web/20170423010036/http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/09/02/01/2BDBDE6C00000578-3219090-image-a-51_1441154997089.jpg)
The Queen with Prince William, Prince George, Catherine Duchess of Cambridge and Prince Harry watch the Trooping of the Colour in June. She is set to surpass the 63 years, seven months and two days that her great-great-grandmother Queen Victoria sat on the throne
Where would she have been for Trooping the Colour? Nowhere to be seen. Victoria turned up for her Birthday Parade only once. The present Queen has never missed one.
We would not have seen Victoria handing out commemorative coins to well-deserving pensioners on Maundy Thursday, in keeping with a tradition dating back to King John.
More from Robert Hardman for the Daily Mail...
- Now THAT'S what I call horse power! It was the photo that lit up an oh-so serious week - the shire horses still used by a farmer who shuns tractors. ROBERT HARDMAN picks up the reins 21/04/17
- The election that could sink the EU: ROBERT HARDMAN reveals how an anti-Muslim fascist and a Maoist who wants 100% wealth taxes could be the two winners when terror-hit France votes tomorrow... and, oh yes, both want FREXIT 21/04/17
- A hundred years on, a salute to the heroes who forged a nation: ROBERT HARDMAN on the centenary commemorations at Vimy Ridge 10/04/17
- A royal salute to Snowdon the rebel romeo (and, of course, the mistress and love children came too!) ROBERT HARDMAN on the memorial service for Antony Armstrong-Jones 07/04/17
- How Miss World is Britain's secret weapon in the battle for The Rock: ROBERT HARDMAN on another 'Iron Lady' fighting for Britain in the row over Gibraltar 04/04/17
- The lioness who simply said, 'I can’t wait to cook for him again': ROBERT HARDMAN on Claire Blackman's fight to see her husband freed from prison 28/03/17
- A misty-eyed Clinton. Glad handing Alastair Campbell. And, oh yes, what a wonderful family man the Bogside Butcher was. Pass the Semtex coated sick bag, says ROBERT HARDMAN 23/03/17
- Deluded! The EU's smug elites claim the Far Right's failure to win the Dutch election proves anti-migration populism is in decline. They couldn't be more wrong, writes ROBERT HARDMAN 17/03/17
- Earl who went to war with Tripe Advisor! There's a backlash against the website that makes or breaks restaurants - led by a gloriously grumpy upper-crust foodie 15/03/17
- VIEW FULL ARCHIVE
Victoria never did it. Elizabeth II has not merely observed the ritual but been the first monarch to take it to cathedrals all over the country.
Palace officials would be pushed to tot up all the ribbon cuttings, hospital openings, plaque unveilings and walkabouts conducted by our Queen in the past year.
Victoria, although fond of meddling in political affairs, would infuriate her ministers and private secretaries with her reluctance to do anything which struck her as remotely disagreeable.
In his biography, Victoria — A Life, A. N. Wilson recounts her hilarious exertions to avoid opening London’s new Blackfriars Bridge in July, 1869.
‘As Mr Gladstone [her Prime Minister] seems still in doubt,’ she wrote, referring to herself in the third person, ‘she will repeat her sincere regret that it is quite out of the question for her to do anything of the kind in the heat of summer.’
Victoria was then 50. Six weeks ago, at the age of 89, our Queen spent a day touring the London borough of Barking and Dagenham without a word of complaint.
Historians are fond of comparing the rise and rise of the British Empire on Victoria’s watch with the unstoppable imperial decline under her great-great-granddaughter.
Neither monarch can be praised or blamed on either count. But while Victoria was happy to be an Empress, she never set foot in her empire.
Elizabeth II, as Dr Starkey at least acknowledges, has shown an assiduous devotion to that Empire’s remnants, forging her Commonwealth ‘family of nations’. She has made a point of visiting almost all of it.
For all its faults, it remains an important and significant 53-nation partnership, spanning almost a third of the world’s population and all its main religions.
![The Queen's first television Broadcast in Sandringham, 1957. The Queen has worked with 12 British Prime Ministers and more than 150 PMs in all her other realms](http://web.archive.org./web/20170423010036/http://i.dailymail.co.uk/i/pix/2015/09/02/01/02A7304C000005DC-3219090-image-a-50_1441154427320.jpg)
The Queen's first television Broadcast in Sandringham, 1957. The Queen has worked with 12 British Prime Ministers and more than 150 PMs in all her other realms
It is the envy of all of our European rivals with their own post-colonial ‘club’. Any of its leaders will tell you the Commonwealth would have fallen apart without the Queen.
With the benefit of hindsight, it is easy to talk about a ‘Victorian age’ because it neatly spanned a steady arc of progress and expansion. If we do not (yet) talk of a new ‘Elizabethan age’, it is because the idea is so vast that it becomes almost meaningless.
It began with ration books and God-fearing families gathered around the wireless. Today, the Queen reigns over a secular, digital, globalised, multicultural society.
Yet she remains as respected and popular as the day she took the throne. Would wilful, capricious, interfering Victoria be able to say the same?
Of course, the 19th century was a world apart from post-war Britain in so many ways, but it is not hard to see who has been the more dutiful and loyal to her people.
That is why, next Wednesday, we will gladly salute one of our greatest sovereigns — even if it does irk Dr Starkey and ‘asphyxiate’ poor Polly Toynbee.
As for the Queen, I dare say she has her heart set on a very different royal record altogether. And it is not one which belongs to Queen Victoria either but to Edward VII; thus far, the only reigning sovereign to own a horse that has won the Epsom Derby.
Most watched News videos
- Mom sobs after AA flight attendant 'violently took her stroller'
- Dramatic footage of fight between Somali pirates and cargo ship
- Pit bulls maul man as he saves his own dog from vicious attack
- Ferry smashes into port wall after engine failure in Gran Canaria
- John Trode tells off chef Lisa Allen for nearly double dipping
- GRAPHIC: Horrifying moment pit bull attacks toddler in street
- 2009: Londoners celebrate Pakistan beating Sri Lanka at cricket
- Adorable orphaned baby kangaroo is inseparable from her pouch
- Bleeding child screams in aftermath of 'Russian air force' bomb
- French police officers arrest a man in attempted knife attack
- Hilarious moment cat is inspired by Houdini to escape from lead
- Gibbons go crazy when they discover rat inside their enclosure
-
American Airlines flight attendant 'whacks a mother in...
-
Bone cancer victim, 20, lies in the dress and make-up she...
-
Millions of drivers are in the dark over new £2,500...
-
The moment a heroic dog owner was mauled by two pit bulls...
-
EXCLUSIVE: Teacher on the run with his student, 15, spent...
-
Dramatic footage captures a deadly firefight between...
-
Stevie Wonder leads the droves of A-list guests arriving...
-
EXCLUSIVE: Mel B and her nanny were lovers, had sex...
-
Auctioneers expect a rousing reaction as a rare,...
-
Saturday Kitchen causes a stir after host John Torode...
-
North Korea could destroy the world with just THREE bombs...
-
Ferry smashes into a port wall on Gran Canaria leaving...
-
Diner publicly shames her cheating boyfriend after...
-
Did Madeleine McCann wander off and have an accident? Was...
-
The miserable life on the run of teacher and the...
-
Passengers flee in panic as knife-wielding man is tackled...
-
Arch remoaner Gina Miller raises £250,000 to stop...
-
Something to celebrate, Ma'am? Beaming Queen watches as...