If the Trans-Pacific Partnership was really as good for jobs and growth as Malcolm Turnbull says it was, he would be able to point to a study saying so.
He might have even commissioned one. Instead, despite the Productivity Commission practically begging for the role, his government has been resolute in its determination not to subject the 12-nation treaty that Donald Trump just dumped to independent analysis.
More World News Videos
- Video duration
- 01:34
TPP worth hanging onto: Ciobo
TPP worth hanging onto: Ciobo
Trade Minister Steve Ciobo isn't giving up on the trans pacific partnership despite US President Donald Trump planning to withdraw from the global trade deal.
Up Next
Dogs love music too
- Video duration
- 00:57
- Video duration
- 00:57
Dogs love music too
Dogs love music too
Although every pup is different, a new study finds dogs prefer soft rock and reggae to pop, Motown and classical music.
Up Next
Trump: Most Presidential person ever
- Video duration
- 01:01
- Video duration
- 01:01
Trump: Most Presidential person ever
Trump: Most Presidential person ever
In his first TV interview since becoming President, Donald Trump outlines his policy positions. Vision: ABC News
Up Next
Doomsday Clock ticks closer to midnight
- Video duration
- 00:45
- Video duration
- 00:45
Doomsday Clock ticks closer to midnight
Doomsday Clock ticks closer to midnight
The Bulletin of Atomic Scientists say they are taking the 'unprecedented' step of moving the symbolic Doomsday Clock 30 seconds closer to midnight.
Up Next
Trump: meeting Mexico would be 'fruitless'
- Video duration
- 01:33
- Video duration
- 01:33
Trump: meeting Mexico would be 'fruitless'
Trump: meeting Mexico would be 'fruitless'
US President Donald Trump says he and Mexico's president Enrique Pena Nieto 'agreed to cancel' their scheduled meeting next week, saying it would have been 'fruitless' if Mexico will not agree to treat America with respect.
Up Next
Trump and Kim impersonators kiss, make up
- Video duration
- 01:28
- Video duration
- 01:28
Trump and Kim impersonators kiss, make up
Trump and Kim impersonators kiss, make up
Donald Trump and Kim Jong-un look-alikes walk around Hong Kong, causing a buzz amongst residents and tourists.
Up Next
Trump to investigate voter fraud
- Video duration
- 01:18
- Video duration
- 01:18
Trump to investigate voter fraud
Trump to investigate voter fraud
President Donald Trump, still claiming voter fraud cost him the popular vote despite a lack of evidence, tweeted that he is calling for an investigation into the matter.
Up Next
Trump acts on Mexico border wall
- Video duration
- 01:16
- Video duration
- 01:16
Trump acts on Mexico border wall
Trump acts on Mexico border wall
US President Donald Trump has signed documents to build a wall along the US border with Mexico, boost the numbers of agents policing illegal immigration, and put an end to sanctuary cities.
TPP worth hanging onto: Ciobo
Trade Minister Steve Ciobo isn't giving up on the trans pacific partnership despite US President Donald Trump planning to withdraw from the global trade deal.
An earlier analysis of three landmark trade agreements that the government did commission found that, combined, the Japan, Korea and China agreements were set to create a total of 5434 extra jobs by 2035.
That's 5434 extra jobs after 20 years. According to the Bureau of Statistics, employment is growing at a trend rate of 8200 per month, meaning the extra jobs will amount to less than a month's worth, after 20 years.
The government-commissioned study found that, combined, the agreements would boost exports 0.5 to 1.5 per cent while boosting imports 2.5 per cent, which means they would send Australia's trade balance backwards.
In the absence of an Australian analysis of the agreement Turnbull insists would have produced jobs and growth, one by World Bank found that 15 years on, it would have bolstered Australia's economy just 0.7 per cent, which amounts to 0.05 per cent per year, somewhat less than measurement error.
It's easy to conclude Turnbull is talking up the TPP because he has not much else to talk up.
In any event, it's dead. Its rules say it can only come into force if it is ratified by members accounting for 85 per cent of its combined gross domestic product, which means it can only come into force if it is ratified by the United States, something President Trump has ruled out.
Part of the problem with it, and part of the problem with reviving something like it without the United States, is that it's so darn complicated. That's because in the assessment of James Pearson, head of the Australian Chamber of Commerce and Industry, "so-called free trade agreements never seek free trade".
Much of the TPP dealt with things such as copyright terms, patent protection for drugs, and so-called investor-state dispute settlement procedures that would have allowed foreign corporations to sue sovereign governments. It took a decade to negotiate.
Pearson says if free trade agreements genuinely sought free trade "they would be simple, stating that the parties agree there shall be no restrictions on trade, investment or movement of people between the two countries, full stop".
When even the potential beneficiaries are questioning the value of ever more complex trade agreements, it could be time to take stock.
It’s easy to conclude Turnbull is talking up the TPP because he has not much else to talk up.
0 comments
New User? Sign up