Mexican President weighs up response to Trump's wall

Surrounded by journalists protesters burn a pinata in the likeness of U.S. President Donald Trump next to a Mexican ...
Surrounded by journalists protesters burn a pinata in the likeness of U.S. President Donald Trump next to a Mexican flag, in Mexico City. MARCO UGARTE
by Azam Ahmed, Paulina Villegas

President Enrique Peña Nieto of Mexico is considering cancelling his meeting with President Donald Trump in Washington next week, officials said Wednesday, responding to broad public outrage in Mexico over Trump's announcement that he will construct a wall along the southern border of the United States.

Mexicans across the political spectrum have been calling for Mr Peña Nieto to cancel the meeting since Trump signalled his intention to build the wall late Tuesday night.

"In light of today's ambush and 'my way or the highway' policies, Mexico would do well in carefully re-evaluating the president's trip next week," Arturo Sarukhan, the former Mexican ambassador to the United States, said Wednesday morning.

On Twitter, others had less measured words for Trump's announcement, calling it "an offence to Mexico," a "slap in the face" and a "monument to lies."

Mr Trump's executive order complicates a relationship that had already grown tense during the US election campaign. His promises to build a wall, deport millions of Mexicans and cancel the North American Free Trade Agreement became harder for Mexicans to ignore. But Wednesday's broadside, coming as the foreign minister, Luis Videgaray, was to begin his first day of preliminary talks in Washington, touched a new low in bilateral relations.

A low point

Pressure has been building on Mr Peña Nieto , whose approval ratings are near the single digits, to respond more forcefully to Trump's provocations. So far he has resisted such calls, preferring dialogue to confrontation. But having his foreign minister greeted with an order for building a border wall was likely to chip away at that resolve.

Mr Videgaray orchestrated Trump's visit to Mexico during the campaign last year, when he was finance minister. The move drew such widespread condemnation that Mr Videgaray resigned his post.

After Mr Trump's victory, Mr Videgaray's fortunes revived and he became foreign minister. But any hope that his invitation could be leveraged in Mexico's favour now seem dashed.

Many Mexicans said they felt conciliatory gestures were no longer an option.

"It's like we are Charlie Brown and they are Lucy with the football," said Jorge Castañeda Gutman, a former foreign minister of Mexico. "Peña is a weak president in a weak country at a weak moment, but he has to find a way to get some official backbone."

While Mexico does not want a war of words – or trade – with Washington, in recent days top government officials have gone on record saying they would be willing to walk away from NAFTA if the negotiations did not suit Mexico's interests. That position was unthinkable even a few months ago.

Widely disliked

For a new US president, Trump is both extremely well known in Mexico and widely disliked.

His positions have has unified an otherwise fractious country, where corruption, a fledgling rule of law and economic struggles have alienated many from political engagement. As Trump's promises have begun to materialise into action, the public discourse is changing.

"This wall, instead of creating good borders, will inevitably and undoubtedly create more security problems for the US," said Roberto Ortiz, 72, who sells GPS navigation units for drivers. "He will no longer enjoy Mexico's cooperation and help with these issues."

Still, despite the outrage, there was a recognition that the action was more political than substantive, like the wall itself. A meaningful stretch of the US border is already lined with a wall, and illegal immigration persists.

Most experts do not think a wall will make any difference.

"Symbolic gestures are not going to change the fact that we're neighbours and that our countries will affect each other in perpetuity," said Carlos Pascual, a former US ambassador to Mexico. "We have no choice but to keep working for better solutions."

Others took the wall threat with a grain of salt, figuring Mexican creativity, or ingenuity, would render it useless anyway.

"This is just politics, it won't upend life in Mexico," said Ariel Najum, 39, who runs a family business. "You know how Mexicans are: If they go high, we go underneath, with tunnels."

The New York Times