National

Assessments get most attention but have least importance in teaching: survey

It's a frustration commonly voiced by teachers and educators: the media dedicate far more coverage to issues that are often the least important when it comes to effective teaching and learning.

Now there's a measure of that priority gap.

Up Next

Chief scientist goes off at Trump

null
Video duration
01:56

More NSW News Videos

What PISA says about Australian schools

The major global test of student achievement reveals just how far Australian high school students are behind their peers in the world's best performing countries.

A global survey by the US-based International Literacy Association asked more than 1500 teachers, policy-makers and literacy academics to rate 17 literacy topics as either "hot" or "important". 

Hot was defined as trending – debates or issues that receive the most attention in the classroom, in conversations with other educators, and in the media. 

Important was defined as those topics most critical to advancing literacy for all learners. 

The survey found that educators believe standards and assessments (including national tests and the global PISA tests) get far more attention than they deserve, while early literacy is actually the most important topic when it comes to boosting literacy skills.

Advertisement

Parent engagement was considered the most important topic that gets the least emphasis. 

But the survey report's authors were surprised that there was not more importance attached to digital literacy, with 37 per cent saying it was not at all, slightly or moderately important in their country, despite being an extremely hot topic. That meant it was ranked less important than early literacy, professional learning and development, diversity, parent engagement, independent reading and several other topics. 

The five hottest topics were assessment/standards; diversity; digital literacy; early literacy and disciplinary literacy (which includes STEM literacy). 

In contrast, the topics actually considered the most important by educators were early literacy; teacher professional learning and development; diversity, literacy in resource-limited settings and English learners (kids learning in a second language).

A total of 69 per cent of respondents said assessment/standards were a very or extremely hot topic in their country, making it by far the No. 1 hot topic, but it was ranked 12th in importance. 

"There is a need for less emphasis or reliance on standardised testing to assess student literacy and more on developing teacher observation," one respondent said. 

Australia contributed the third-largest response to the survey, after the US and Canada.

Respondents to the survey included classroom teachers and reading/literacy specialists teaching 5-14-year-olds, academics and people working in government, with an average of 11 years of professional experience.