2014 Latakia offensive
2014 Latakia offensive | |||||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Part of the Syrian Civil War | |||||||
![]() Syrian Army control Opposition control |
|||||||
|
|||||||
Belligerents | |||||||
Supported by:
![]() |
![]() |
||||||
Commanders and leaders | |||||||
Unknown top provincial Al-Nusra commander † (Nusra Front commander) Abu Ahmed al-Turkmani (Nusra Front commander)[22] Muslim Abu Walid al Shishani (Junud al-Sham commander)[8] Abu Musa al-Shishani (Ansar al-Sham commander)[23] Abu al Hassan (Ahrar ash-Sham commander)[8] Ibrahim bin Shakran † (Harakat Sham al-Islam commander)[24] Abu Safiya Al-Masri † (Harakat Sham al-Islam deputy commander)[25] Brig. Gen. Abdul-Ilah al-Bashir (FSA Chief of staff)[1] Anas Abu Malik (Latakia FSA commander)[26] |
Lt. Gen. Ali Abdullah Ayyoub (Army Chief of staff)[19] Hussam Khadra † (Latakia Ba'ath Brigades commander)[9] Col. Samuel Ghannum † (Observatory 45 commander)[29] |
||||||
Strength | |||||||
4,000 fighters[30] | Unknown | ||||||
Casualties and losses | |||||||
582 killed (opposition claim)[31] 2,700 killed and 5,635 wounded (government claim; by 30 March)[32] |
571 killed (opposition claim)[33] |
||||||
11 civilians killed[37][38] |
The 2014 Latakia offensive was a rebel offensive in the Latakia Governorate of Syria launched on 21 March 2014 by rebel Islamist groups including Al-Nusra Front, which called the offensive "Anfal",[4] while a coalition of Supreme Military Council rebel groups called the offensive "The Martyrs Mothers".[22] The objectives of the offensive have been stated to be the taking over of all strategic observatories, government villages and the Mediterranean coast.[39] Observers have stated a strategic aim was to force the Syrian army to redeploy forces to Latakia,[40][41] which would relieve pressure on other rebels elsewhere in Syria.[42] They reportedly succeeded in this with government forces being sent from Idlib, Hama and Aleppo to bolster defenses.[16][17]
During the offensive the Syrian military was joined by Hezbollah, Iraqi Shi'ite militia and Iranian military advisers.[43] After almost two months of fighting, the offensive stalled and eventually petered out, with rebels losing most of their early gains.[21][44] However, the rebels' established strategic bridgehead consisting of the town of Kessab and nearby territory remained.[11] By mid-June a new advance by government forces recaptured the last rebel gains of the campaign, including Kessab.[10]
The offensive, and in particular the degree of Turkish involvement in it, has been widely attributed with the deportation of the native ethnic Armenians of the town of Kessab, who make up 70% of its population, and has been compared with the past Turkish killings of Armenians during the Hamidian massacres and Armenian Genocide.[45][46][47]
Contents
Background[edit]
The Armenians of Kessab were previously victims of Turkish violence during the Hamidian massacres, Adana massacres and the Armenian Genocide, last two of which took place in the last century and involved the massacre of two millions of Armenians.[48]
Three days before the assault on Kessab, the leader of Turkey's opposition Republican People's Party (CHP), Kemal Kilicdaroglu, called on Chief of General Staff General Necdet Ozel "not to embark on an adventure" with a military intervention in Syria, saying that "He [Prime Minister Recep Tayyip Erdogan] could decide to move the army into Syria before the elections."[49] Kilicdaroglu
Kessab was the only city bordering Turkey that was controlled by the Syrian government. Syrian-Armenian war correspondent Sarkis Kassargian believes taking control of Kessab means taking control of the border crossing with Turkey, which allows anti-government fighters to advance toward the coastline, and in turn strengthen their position on the ground. In addition, the alleged capture of Samra village by rebel forces grants them access to the highest point in the village. Abdoullah Ali, an expert on Islamic groups in Syria, confirmed the takeover was headed by Abou Mousa al-Chechani (Chechnyan), among other senior and experienced fighters who had previously fought in Afghanistan, Bosnia, Chechnya and Iraq, thus indicating the importance of this battle.[49]
Human Rights Watch Syria and Lebanon researcher Lama Fakih told the UK Telegraph rebel groups had wanted to attack Kassab for a long time, but Turkey had previously denied them access, citing a lack of unity.[50]
Offensive[edit]
Initial rebel advance[edit]
In the early hours of 21 March 2014, rebel fighters led by the al-Nusra Front advanced from inside Turkish territory and attacked the Kasab border crossing with Turkey. The fighters reportedly crossed into Syria from the Turkish village of Gözlekçiler.[51] Subsequently, the civilian populations of Kessab and its surrounding villages either fled or were evacuated, with most seeking safety in Latakia, as Kessab remained under the control of rebel groups.[52][53]
The rebel fighters initially managed to capture guard posts around the crossing but not the crossing itself. The also captured the nearby Al-Sakhra hill[54][55] and a police station[56] and directed mortar fire from the hill at the crossing and at the nearby Alawite village of Karsana, killing five people including a child. The leader of Al-Nusra for Latakia province was killed during the fighting.[54][56] Rebels had also captured the Jabal al-Nisr mountain, but it was recaptured by the military within hours.[13]
By 22 March, the rebels managed to capture the Kasab crossing, while Kesab town remained under government control and fighting was still continuing around both of them.[3] Government forces launched a counter-attack in an attempt to recapture the crossing[57] and a security source stated the Army had retaken the previous day two police stations that were seized by the rebels.[58] According to the opposition activist group the SOHR, rebels at the crossing had been targeted by government troops since the previous day.[57] In the meantime, rebels directed their attacks against a strategic hill known as Observatory 45,[57] which they captured later in the day.[37] Overall, the SOHR reported fighting in three government-held villages that were coming under a rebel attack and three rebel-held villages which the Army was trying to capture.[58] As fighting spread to other villages, the military responded with air strikes and ambushes which left 20 rebels dead and 30 wounded[59] around Observatory Kherbah Solas.[60]
On 23 March, Turkish Air Force F-16 jet fighters shot down a Syrian warplane that allegedly bombed rebels fighting around the border post.[5] The pilot ejected safely, according to a Syrian military spokesman, who also claimed that the plane was in Syrian airspace;[61] Turkish officials, however, claimed it violated their airspace.[62]
Meanwhile, significant military reinforcements were sent to the border area.[59] Rebels also launched a new attack against the village of Kherbah Solas, about 25 kilometers south of Kasab.[63] Opposition sources claimed that over 20 soldiers surrendered to the rebels in the village of Nab Al-Murr after a three-hour siege on a building.[64]
Later during the day, government forces recaptured Observatory 45 and secured the village of Al-Samra,[65] while rebels captured the village of Al-Nab'in[66] and the surroundings of Jabal al-Nisr, which forced the Army to evacuate it. However, the rebels were not able to capture the top of Jabal al-Nisr itself due to the Army's control of Observatory 45, which is the highest point in the region and oversees Jabal al-Nisr.[13] During the day's fighting, the NDF commander of Latakia province, Hilal al-Assad, and seven pro-government militiamen were killed in fighting in Kasab.[27] According to the rebel Islamic Front, he was killed when they used Grad rockets to hit a scheduled meeting of pro-government militia leaders in Latakia city.[67]
On 24 March, according to the SOHR, rebels were in control of the village of Kasab, after capturing the main square[68] the previous day,[69] with fighting continuing in the town's outskirts,[68] specifically the hills outside the center of Kasab.[70] However, according to a military source, neither side had control of the village and the situation was unclear.[68] Rebel jihadists reportedly took Armenian families hostage in Kasab and desecrated the town's three Armenian churches.[71] The Army managed to recapture the town of Nab al-Murr.[13] Meanwhile, Turkish media claimed the leader of the pro-government Syrian Resistance militia, Mihraç Ural, had been killed the previous day.[28][72] However, that evening Mihraç Ural posted a video on his Facebook account denying rumors of his death.[73] Al-Arabiya television also claimed that two other cousins of Bashar al-Assad were killed in the fighting.[74]
According to Col. Afif al-Suleimani, head of Idlib's rebel Military Council, the Army withdrew many of its soldiers from Idlib province to reinforce their forces in Latakia province after the rebel offensive against the coastal area began.[74]
On 25 March, rebels captured Al-Samra[75] and were reportedly advancing towards Anfal.[76] A military source denied the village had fallen stating that fighting was still ongoing and that the Army was in complete control of the mountains overlooking Al-Samra.[75] Meanwhile, fighting was still raging at Kasab, with the Army shelling the town and the Air force striking it four times around noon.[76] Later, a pro-government news agency claimed the Army managed to recapture most of Kasab.[77] According to the editor-in-ehief of Aztag Daily, information warfare was being conducted and that it was too early to conclude whether government forces managed to regain control of the town, but confirmed fighting was ongoing.[78] Rebels had also once again captured Observatory 45,[79] after a Tunisian suicide bomber in an armored troop carrier blew himself up[80] in the Observatory's yard killing a number of soldiers, including Colonel Samuel Ghannum, commander of Observatory 45.[29] The fall of the Observatory removed the threat of artillery strikes against Jabal al-Nisr and the rebels were able to occupy its peak. Government troops from the hill retreated towards Qastal Maaf.[13] Fighting around Observatory 45 continued.[81] Meanwhile, the Army recaptured Al-Nab'in.[82] Nineteen rebels and 16 soldiers were killed during the day's fighting[80] and 40 soldiers and 100 rebels were wounded.[79] The Turkish Army accused the Syrian government of "harassing" five Turkish F-16 fighter jets with surface-to-air missile systems. The Turkish F-16's intercepted four Syrian aircraft approaching Turkish airspace in Yayladagi and Cilvegozu of Hatay province in southern Turkey before the incident occurred.[83]
On 26 March, rebels slowly pressed their advance from Observatory 45 and attacked the town of Qastal Maaf. Fighting had also renewed at Al-Nab'in. The battle for both towns had been described as a seesaw one with both attacks and retreats.[84] At the same time, fighting continued around Kasab, Observatory 45 and Al-Samra[85] as the Army intensified its shelling on Kasab and Al-Samra. The government mobilised thousands of soldiers and NDF fighters to retake the areas that had been lost to the rebels and many government supporters, the majority of them Alawites, volunteered to fight against the rebels.[34] A military officer claimed rebels had been pushed back from Observatory 45, but were still in nearby areas.[86] Another source also confirmed that the Army had beaten back the rebels from Observatory 45, but did not reoccupy it, instead securing the hill's surroundings. The military had also evacuated from Nab al-Murr, due to the town's vulnerability to rebel shelling from Observatory 45 and Jabal al-Nisr.[13] Pro-government sources claimed 500 rebels[29] and 50 soldiers had been killed since the start of the offensive, while the SOHR stated around 100 fighters on each side had died.[34]
The Syrian government called on the United Nations to halt the Turkish involvement in the Kasab region. It accused the Turkish government for "organizing, receiving, funding and hosting tens of thousands of terrorists from various Takfiri movements and facilitating their entry into the Syrian territories" and for providing the rebels with direct military support in the region.[87]
On 27 March, several helicopter and air strikes were conducted against Observatory 45,[88] while Jabhat Al-Nusra reinforcements arrived in the contested areas.[89] Two pro-government sources reported the military managed to defend their positions at Al-Nab'in and Qastal Maaf and was advancing towards Kasab from the two towns.[90][91] A pro-opposition source reported that rebels managed to capture Al-Nab'in but that fighting was ongoing as the military was trying to recapture both it and Kasab.[92] Another source reported that the military recaptured Al-Nab'in after it received reinforcements from troops who evacuated Jabal al-Nisr.[13] Fighting was also still raging around Al-Samra.[93] A pro-government newspaper also claimed another 200 rebel fighters had been killed in the last day.[90] The military intelligence head in Latakia province was reportedly able to escape after he was surrounded by rebels for five days in Al-Nab'in.[94] By the end of this day, according to the SOHR, more than 150 pro-government fighters, including 14 officers, had been killed since the start of the offensive.[95]
On 28 March, it was reported that the rebels had blocked several attempts by the Syrian Army to send reinforcements to Latakia.[96]
On 29 March, Al-Nab'in was once again reported under rebel control, but with fighting continuing in its outskirts.[14] Al Aan TV claimed that 10 pro-government fighters were killed in an attempt by the Army to recapture Observatory 45. It also reported the arrival of Hezbollah fighters in the area. According to a local activist, the FSA had set up a joint operations room under command of Brigadier General and FSA Chief of staff Abdul-Ilah al-Bashir to support the rebel offensive.[1]
On 30 March, the SOHR reported that several attempts by the Army to retake areas in northern Latakia had been repelled by the rebels. However, the military was bringing more reinforcements from the coastal city of Tartous to try and stem the rebel advance.[97]
The battle for Observatory 45[edit]
By 31 March, thousands of refugees reportedly fled to Latakia city, while a rising tension between the Armenian-Christian-Alawite community and the Turkmen community was reported.[2] At this time, Barnabas Aid stated 80 Christian civilians were killed and thousands more displaced after rebel fighters captured Kasab;[98] however, a delegation from the Armenian National Assembly visited and interviewed refugees from Kessab who fled to Latakia and concluded that "fortunately, no casualties were reported on the Armenian side," though around 2500 were displaced.[99] According to the SOHR, 1,052 fighters from both sides had been killed and wounded since the start of the offensive.[100] Among the dead were 27 Army officers and 56 foreign rebel fighters.[101]
During the day, government forces made an attempt to advance towards Kasab as the rebel offensive started to stagnate[102] and state TV made a live report from near the hilltop of Observatory 45 claiming the Army had recaptured it.[103] The SOHR confirmed the Army made progress in the area[104] and stated that government troops managed to install multiple rocket launcher on Observatory 45, but fighting was continuing in the vicinity of the hillside.[105] Meanwhile, rebels hit the pro-government village of Bahloulieh with seven Grad missiles. Other pro-government villages were also shelled with mortars.[97] The Turkish Army stated that they had returned fire after mortar shells and a rocket struck areas near the town of Yayladagi.[106]
After midnight, government troops ambushed rebels in the forest around Observatory 45 resulting in a number of deaths among opposition fighters.[107]
On 1 April, Ahmad Jarba, head of the Syrian National Coalition, visited the front-line in the Kasab region. The SOHR also denied State TV's claim that the Army had recaptured Observatory 45, stating that clashes were still ongoing over the hilltop.[108]
On 2 April, according to the SOHR, the rebels reached the perimeter of al-Badrousiya village where violent clashes took place amid new Army reinforcements in that area.[109] Opposition activists in Latakia claimed that the rebels repulsed an Army attack on Observatory 45. During the fighting for the hill, the Moroccan leader of the Harakat Sham al-Islam rebel group, Ibrahim bin Shakran, was killed.[24] A local rebel commander was also killed in other clashes, while "dozens of bodies" of pro-government fighters were reportedly bussed to the city of Tartous, according to opposition activist's claims. An opposition TV station also claimed that 11 Hezbollah fighters were captured in an ambush by rebels in the province, but this report could not be verified.[110]
On 3 April, according to the SOHR, rebels managed to regain control over the buildings of Observatory 45 after they were captured by pro-government fighters during the night. At least 11 rebels were killed in the fighting, while at least 20 pro-government fighters were killed and wounded.[111] But later activists reported that government forces, supported by the NDF, had managed to reach the peak of Observatory 45 and clashes ensued with opposition fighters, including Jabhat al-Nusra.[18] The SOHR also updated the past day's rebel death toll to 20.[112]
On 4 April, the SOHR reported that 64 rebels, including 40 foreign fighters, and 35 government soldiers were killed in fighting for Observatory 45 over the previous two days. 50 soldiers were also wounded[113][114] and among rebel fatalities, beside the leader of Harakat Sham al-Islam, was the group's Egyptian military commander, Abu Safiya Al-Masri.[25] Fighting was continuing around Observatory 45 with mutual bombardment from both sides,[115] while the Syrian Army's chief of staff, general Ali Abdullah Ayyoub, visited government forces on top of the hill at the post.[19] Eight rebels and eight pro-government fighters were killed and 15 wounded in the fighting at Observatory 45.[116] Meanwhile, the Turkish Army fired shells into Syria, responding to six shells that landed in Yayladadi.[117]
Continued Army advance[edit]
On 5 April, after midnight, government troops ambushed rebels on the road towards Al-Nab'in resulting in a number of deaths among opposition fighters,[107] while two Moroccan field commanders of Ahrar Al-Sham were killed in fighting in Kasab.[118] It was reported that Latakia city was hit by two Grad missiles during the day.[119]
On 7 April, fighting erupted on the edges of the Jabal al-Haramiya area with government forces advancing.[120] The next day, Iranian Press TV claimed the Army had regained control of Jabal al-Haramiya.[121]
On 12 April, fighting erupted in Al-Nab'in and Nab Al-Murr[122] and later in the day clashes were still ongoing in the towns perimeters.[123] The next day, the Army recaptured Chalma mountain (also known as Sal-Darin mountain), near Kassab, while heavy clashes were still taking place near Observatory 45.[124][125]
By 15 April, the FSA commander for Latakia province stated the offensive had stagnated after rebel forces had become exhausted due to the number of casualties they had endured and a shortage of ammunition.[26] Three days later, another opposition commander criticised the opposition Syrian National Coalition for not providing enough financial support for the offensive and supporting countries for not providing enough arms.[126]
Capture of Al-Samra and the battle for the hills[edit]
On 27 April, government forces captured a guard post near Al-Samra,[127] namely the town's police station,[128] after an amphibious assault from the sea. As evening came, rebels had retreated from Al-Samra[129] and government forces captured the village.[130]
The next day, the military secured Chalma mountain and engaged rebels on top of Tal Al-Ahmar, while other government troops, including Special Forces from Al-Samra, advanced towards Al-Nab'in. Four soldiers were killed and 75 wounded by mid-day, while an unknown number of rebels also died.[131] Government forces from Observatory 45 had also advanced, capturing Height 724 north of the Observatory.[132] The Army further captured Heights 959 and 1017.[133] Two days later, government forces were fighting rebels on Jabal al-Nisr mountain, near Al-Nab'in, and on three hills overlooking Kasab in an attempt to capture the hilly terrain before engaging opposition forces in the towns themselves.[134] Later in the day, government troops fully secured Al-Samra and its surrounding hills.[135] On 3 May, government troops captured radar hill 1013 overlooking[136] and the next day fighting erupted in Al-Nab'in.[137]
In mid-May, rebels reportedly recaptured Hills 53, 724 and 1013, as well as Seriatel and Al-Nab'in hills. Opposition forces also attempted to capture Observatory 45, but failed.[138]
As of 18 May, the offensive was considered to had petered out.[44]
Syrian army offensive – Rebel retreat[edit]
On 12 June, the military started a new offensive[139] and by the next day captured Hills 714, 767[140] and 803.[141]
On 14 June, most rebels retreated from Kasab, while a few of them stayed to protect the retreating fighters. This came after the Army took hold of areas that surround Al-Nab'in and advanced towards Kasab.[142] The SOHR reported the military was moving towards nearby villages,[143] including Al-Nab'in,[144] while state TV already reported the capture of the town.[145] SANA also stated two-thirds of Kasab were under military control.[146]
On 15 June, the Syrian Army took control of Kasab, its border crossing, Al-Nab'in and Nab Al-Murr, fully reversing all opposition gains during the three-month campaign.[10][147] Meanwhile, the Army intensified its operations in the east of the province near Salma.[148]
Controversies[edit]
Allegations of Turkish involvement[edit]
It was reported that the attackers, members of the al-Nusra Front, Sham al-Islam, and Ansar al-Sham, advanced directly from the village of Gözlekçiler on Turkish territory, were being supported by the Turkish military, and that injured rebel fighters were being sent to medical centres in Turkey. Some Kessab village guards reported that the Turkish military withdrew from its positions along the border shortly before the fighters crossed from Turkey.[51]
Mehmet Ali Ediboğlu, MP of Turkish CHP party, who visited the area several days after the attack began, said locals told him that "thousands of fighters coming from Turkey crossed the border at at least five different points to launch the attack on Kassab." While journalists were barred from visiting Gözlekçiler, Ediboğlu said he personally observed "dozens of Syrian-plated cars nonstop transporting terrorists and firing into the Syrian outpost from the military road between Gözlekçiler village and our military base at Kayapinar."[51]
According to security sources in Kessab, the attacks were waged under heavy artillery cover by the Turkish army, while the injured were being carried back and treated in the city of Yayladagi in Turkey, which borders Syria.[49][149]
An activist told the Telegraph on 21 March "Turkey did us a big favour… They allowed our guys to enter from their border post," allowing them to finally access Kessab. Turkey denied the allegations as "totally unfounded and untrue", the Telegraph reported, but HRW's Fakih replied "it is not feasible that these groups could have crossed into Syria from where they did without the knowledge of the Turks."[50]
Turkish shootdown of Syrian fighter jet[edit]
After Turkish Air Force F-16 jet fighters had shot down a Syrian warplane near the border post, the pilot, who ejected safely, claimed that the plane was in Syrian airspace[150] Turkish officials, however, claimed it violated their airspace.[151]
Turkey's opposition leader, Kemal Kilicdaroglu (CHP) claimed that the Syrian jet was a reconnaissance plane and that its downing was part of a government scheme to provoke war with Syria to divert attention from corruption scandals enveloping Turkey's president Erdogan and his party.[152] Istanbul-based journalist Amberin Zaman commented that the recently leaked audio tapes in which Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoğlu is heard discussing ways to spark a war with Syria might vindicate Kilicdaroglu's claims.[153]
Armenian civilian fatalities[edit]
The offense has been widely compared to the Hamidian massacres and Armenian Genocide, as over 70% of Kessab's population is Armenian and is one of the last Armenian settlements in the Cilicia region, where the Armenian population had been massacred twice by Turkey. President of Armenia Serzh Sargsyan stated, “All of us perfectly remember the history of Kessab, which was unfortunately full of hellish realities of deportations in the last 100 years", referring to both events.[154] On 2 April, during a hearing before the House State-Foreign Operations Appropriations Subcommittee and in response to a question by Congressman Schiff, US ambassador to the UN Samantha Power, said that Kessab "is an issue of huge concern". Congressman Schiff noted that many of the residents were descendants of victims of the Armenian Genocide and that "there is a particular poignancy to their being targeted in this manner."[155] On 3 April Armenia's Minister of Diaspora Hranush Hakobyan said that 38 of Kessab's Armenian inhabitants had been captured when the town fell to the rebels, 24 of them were later released, 3 had been forcefully taken into Turkey and were now in the village of Vaqif, and that 670 Armenian families had been displaced after the attack on Kessab, with about 400 of the families, at least 2,000 ethnic Armenian civilians, sought refuge in Latakia and other neighboring hills. The minister also said that in Kessab, Armenian churches had been defaced, crosses on the churches had been removed, Armenian shops and homes had been looted.[49][149][156] Also on 3 April, Ruben Melkonyan, deputy dean of the Oriental Studies department at Yerevan State University, said that the Armenian community of Kessab was unlikely to recover and that what had happened were "crimes that make a genocide".[157]
A number of eye-witness accounts of looting and occupation of Armenian homes, stores, and churches left behind were reported in Kessab.[149][158] Armed men entered the town, looted Armenian shops and homes, taking families hostage, and desecrating the town's three churches.[49] Kessab Armenians who phoned their neighbors and relatives homes from Latakia discovered that their houses are already occupied by rebel fighters, who went on to taunt and threaten the refugees.[149] Some of the rebels had spoken in Turkish.[149] Some 670 Armenian families, the majority of the population of Kessab, were evacuated by the local Armenian community leadership to safer areas in neighboring Basit and Latakia. Ten to fifteen families with relations too elderly to move were either unable to leave or chose to stay in their homes.[149] According to witnesses, the rebels had raped elderly women because they couldn't find any girls.[158][159]
Aftermath[edit]
After the Syrian Army retook Kessab and the surrounding villages, news agencies and local residents of Kessab reported that the town's Armenian Catholic and Evangelical churches had been ruined and burnt by the Islamist groups, along with the Misakyan Cultural Centre.[160][161][162] Around 250 families from Kessab who had taken refuge in Latakia returned to their homes a day after the Syrian Army recaptured the town.[163][164][165] On 25 July the St. Astvatsatsin Church in Garaturan was reconsecrated, with the first liturgy since the ending of the Islamist occupation taking place on 27 July, the day of Vardavar, and attended by a large number of people [166]
Foreign reaction[edit]
Armenia – President Serzh Sargsyan made a press statement at the World Forum Convention Center in The Hague (Netherlands) expressing his deep concern over the events in Kessab, remembering that the Armenian population of Kessab had experienced exile and deportation in April 1909 and in 1915 (during the Armenian Genocide), making a parallel with the 2014 situation: "The third deportation of Kessab Armenians today is a serious challenge to ethnic minority rights protection mechanisms of the 21st century." He also thanked the Syrian authorities for the steps being taken to protect the Armenians in Kessab.[167]
Canada – Andrew P. W. Bennett, Canadian Ambassador to the Office of Religious Freedom stated: "Canada is deeply concerned by the recent attacks by al Qaeda affiliated armed groups on the ancient Armenian town of Kessab in the Latakia district of northern Syria during which Armenian churches were reportedly desecrated and Armenians driven from their homes...We stand determined that the perpetrators be brought to justice for such acts and to stem the rising tide of sectarian violence.".[168][169]
Nagorno-Karabakh – David Babayan, Spokesman for the President of the Nagorno-Karabakh Republic, said that Turkey continues its anti-Armenian policy, in particular in Kessab: "Through subversive attacks, Turkey tries to make Armenians leave Syria and aims to liquidate the Armenian community of Syria." He also stated that while it would be preferable for Syrian Armenians to remain in Syria and preserve their communities there, Nagorno-Karabakh would be ready to accept and welcome any refugees.[170]
Russia – Gennady Gatilov, Deputy Foreign Minister of Russia, condemned the attack on Kesab and the ethnic cleansing of Armenian Syrians in Latakia. He accused Turkey, the western countries and the Persian gulf states of supporting terrorism in Syria and called for an urgent meeting of the United Nations Security Council to discuss the situation.[171] The UN Security Council declined Russia's meeting proposal.[172]
Chechnya – Ramzan Kadyrov, Head of the Chechen Republic, condemned the attack on Kesab and accused Turkey of assisting terrorists and expressed his condolences to the ethnic Armenian victims. He said: "The official data says the attack on Kesab was carried out by al-Qaida militants affiliated with the so-called al-Nusra Front and Islamic Front. I am stating herein bindingly that these terrorists have nothing in common with Islam and cannot be called Moslems." Kadyrov also accused the U.S. and European countries of remaining silent on the attack and accused NATO members of contributing to it: "These terrorists have been reared, fostered and armed by the West and trained by secret services of NATO countries. They are fulfilling a task to ruin Syria and weaken the Islamic countries."[173]
United States – State Department Deputy Spokesperson Marie Harf stated during a press briefing on 28 March: "We are deeply troubled by recent fighting and violence that is endangering the Armenian community in Kessab, Syria and has forced many to flee. As we have said throughout this conflict, we deplore continued threats against Christians and other minorities in Syria". She ended adding: "The United States will continue its steadfast support to those affected by violence in Syria and throughout the region, including Syrian Armenians. We have long had concerns about the threat posed by violent extremists, and this latest threat to the Armenian community in Syria only underscores this further".[174] The Congressional Armenia Caucus noted their concern in a letter to the President.[175]
- The Armenian National Committee of America (ANCA), has condemned the "onslaught on Kessab" and accused Turkey of facilitating the infiltration of radical groups in their attacks on Christian and other minority populations in Kessab. The group has also called on the US administration and Congress to pressure Ankara to end its support for "the destruction of Kessab." In a statement, the group said, "For months, we have warned the international community of the imminent threat posed by extremist foreign fighters against the Christian minority population in Syria. These vicious and unprompted attacks against the Armenian-populated towns and villages of Kessab are the latest examples of this violence, actively encouraged by neighboring Turkey. We call upon all states with any influence in the Syrian conflict to use all available means to stop these attacks against the peaceful civilian population of Kessab, to allow them to return to their homes in safety and security."[49]
See also[edit]
References[edit]
- ^ a b c d رانيا علوني (30 March 2014). "مقتل 10 جنود من قوات النظام أثناء محاولتهم اقتحام البرج 45 في كسب" [Ten regime fighters killed while trying to capture Observatory 45]. alaan.tv.
- ^ a b "Fear and loathing descending on Latakia". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ a b c Evans, Dominic (22 March 2014). "Rebels battle for Syria border post near Mediterranean". Reuters.
- ^ a b c d La chronique de Nagib AOUN (21 March 2014). "Syrie: combats féroces autour d'un point de passage avec la Turquie". Lorientlejour.com.
- ^ a b "Turkey downs Syria warplane on border". Al Arabiya.
- ^ "'Syria rebels get US-made missiles'". AFP. Archived from the original on 17 April 2014. Retrieved 15 April 2014.
- ^ "Congress secretly approves U.S. weapons flow to 'moderate' Syrian rebels". Reuters. Retrieved 27 January 2014.
- ^ a b c Bill Roggio (27 March 2014). "Chechen al Qaeda commander, popular Saudi cleric spotted on front lines in Latakia". Longwarjournal.org.
- ^ a b c Jawad, Aymenn (26 April 2014). "Aymenn Jawad al-Tamimi – The Latakia Front". Brown-moses.blogspot.co.uk.
- ^ a b c d "Syrian Army Crushes Rebel Push Near Turkish Border". Time. Associated Press.
- ^ a b "Elections cannot mask Bashar al-Assad's vulnerabilities in Syria". Financial Times. 29 April 2014. Retrieved 28 May 2014.
- ^ "Fierce Fighting Raging in Syria's Latakia". Naharnet.com. 26 March 2014.
- ^ a b c d e f g "Kassab falls to Syrian opposition gunmen". Al-monitor.com.
- ^ a b "Continuing clashes in Rural Damascus and Latakia". Syriahr.com. 29 March 2014.
- ^ "Latakia and Deraa attacks intended to draw Syrian government troops away from other areas". Jane's Defence 360. 23 March 2014. Archived from the original on 21 May 2014. Retrieved 21 May 2014.
- ^ a b "Increased pressure on Latakia is helping to improve Syrian insurgents' position in Aleppo". Jane's Defence 360. 9 April 2014. Archived from the original on 16 April 2014. Retrieved 21 May 2014.
- ^ a b "Assad's forces deploy in Latakia to repel rebel offensive". Al Arabiya. Retrieved 18 May 2014.
- ^ a b "Battle for Latakia". Al Jazeera.
- ^ a b c "Syrian army chief visits key base in Latakia". Press TV. 4 April 2014.
- ^ Cedric Labrousse [CdricLabrousse] (15 April 2014). "Chronicle Map Update" (Tweet). Retrieved 2 January 2015 – via Twitter. (password-protected)
- ^ a b Aji, Albert (15 April 2014). "Syrian Troops Choke off Rebels North of Damascus". The Philippine Star.
- ^ a b "Rebels Reopen the Latakia Front". Institute for the Study of War. 10 April 2014. Retrieved 10 April 2014.
- ^ "The Ansar al-Sham Battalions". Carnegie Endowment for International Peace. 24 March 2014. Retrieved 24 March 2014.
- ^ a b The Arab Chronicle. "Abu Ahmad al-Maghrebi (Ibrahim Bencheqroun), un vétéran du Jihad mort en Syrie | Jihad veteran killed in Syria". The-arab-chronicle.com.
- ^ a b "The death of the commander of the movement Cham Islam and his deputy during clashes with regime forces". Syriahr.com. 3 April 2014.
- ^ a b "Leader of the Free Syrian Army: Battle of the "coast" entered a phase of stagnation". Syriahr.com. 15 April 2014.
- ^ a b "Islamic battalions kills the NDF leader "Hilal Al-Assad" in Lattakia countryside". Syriahr.net. 23 March 2014.
- ^ a b "Pro-Assad THKP/C leader reportedly killed in clashes with Syrian opposition". Today's Zaman. 24 March 2014.
- ^ a b c "Over 500 rebels killed in Syria's Latakia battles". Xinhua News Agency. 26 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian rebels allowed to attack Latakia from Turkish soil under Turkish air cover. Iran raises Cain in Ankara". Debka.com. 22 January 2014.
- ^ 128 killed (21–30 March),[1] 13 killed (31 March),[2] 7 killed (1 April),[3] 64 killed (2–3 April),[4] 370 killed (4 April–15 June),[5] total of 582+ reported killed
- ^ "most of 8000 between the gunman dead and injured toll losses opposition Brive Latakia!". Alhadathnews.net. 31 March 2014.
- ^ 194 killed (21–30 March),[6] 11 killed (31 March),[7] 7 killed (1 April),[8] 35 killed (2–3 April),[9] 12 killed (4 April),[10] 312 killed (5 April–15 June),[11] total of 571 reported killed
- ^ a b c "Syria forces in heavy counterattack on rebels in Latakia". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Dramatic moment Syrian jet explodes as it is shot down by Turkish fighter planes for 'violating its airspace'". Daily Mail. London.
- ^ "Turkish F-16 shoots down a Syrian MiG-23". F-16.net.
- ^ a b Syrian rebels seize strategic hill near Aleppo: NGO[dead link]
- ^ "295 died yesterday, including 245 from the regular forces and combat battalions". Syriahr.com. 24 March 2014.
- ^ "Lattakia province". Facebook.com.
- ^ "Syria rebels take coastal village in Assad heartland". Agence France-Presse. Retrieved 19 May 2014.
- ^ "Syrian moderates try to rebuild opposition force". Al Monitor. Retrieved 14 May 2014.
- ^ "Syrian rebels slowly advancing in Latakia". Al Jazeera.
- ^ "In Assad's coastal heartland, Syria's war creeps closer". Reuters. 13 April 2014. Retrieved 20 May 2014.
- ^ a b "Street by street, Assad extends grip in central Syria". Trust.org. Thomson Reuters Foundation.
- ^ "Christians flee Syria's Kessab, Twitter cries atrocities, Armenia accuses Turkey". Russia Today. 31 March 2014. Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- ^ "Syrian Armenians, who had been insulated from war, forced to flee after rebel offensive". Washington Post. Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- ^ "Armenians dismayed as Syrian rebels seize historic area, prompting residents to flee". Fox News. 28 March 2014. Retrieved 11 April 2014.
- ^ "Syria: Kessab's battle and Armenians' history". Opendemocracy.net. 2 April 2014. Retrieved 17 April 2014.
- ^ a b c d e f "Turkish main opposition leader warns over military strike in Syria". Hurriyet. 20 March 2014. Retrieved 9 January 2015.
- ^ a b "The Telegraph reveals Turkish role in the attack on Armenian-populated Kessab". Public Radio of Armenia. 15 April 2014. Retrieved 27 November 2015.
- ^ a b c Fehim Tastekin (31 March 2014). "Fall of Kassab will be costly for Turkey". Al Monitor. Retrieved 6 December 2015.
- ^ "Kessab Targeted by Al-Qaeda Front Groups in Cross-Border Attack from Turkey." The Armenian Weekly. 23 March 2014.
- ^ "Rebels Reassure Christians After Capturing Key Syrian Border Town". Time Magazine. 28 April 2014. Retrieved 24 March 2014.
- ^ a b "24 killed as rebels fight to take Syria border post". Ma'an News Agency.
- ^ "Casualties in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 21 March 2014.
- ^ a b "Victory announces the start of a battle in the Anfal coast and clashes in the win". Syriahr.com. 21 March 2014.
- ^ a b c "Syrian troops and rebels clash near Turkish border". Nujournal.com. Associated Press. 22 March 2014. Archived from the original on 23 March 2014.
- ^ a b "Syria fighting rages in Assad's home province". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ a b "Third day of fighting at Syria-Turkey border crossing". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "More than 20 martyrs and the continued clashes in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 23 March 2014.
- ^ Syria says Turkey shoots down Syrian warplane Archived 23 March 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ "Turkey shoots down Syrian regime plane after violating airspace, PM confirms". Hürriyet Daily News. 13 September 2011.
- ^ Butler, Daren (23 March 2014). "Turkey shoots down Syrian plane it says violated air space". Reuters.
- ^ "Opposition forces seize multiple villages in Latakia". Syrianewsdesk.com.
- ^ "Provide for regular troops in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 23 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian paramilitary commander killed in Latakia". Kuna.net.kw. 24 March 2014.
- ^ "Cousin of Syria's President Assad reportedly killed by rebels". Los Angeles Times.
- ^ a b c "Rebels seize border village as regime warplanes bomb frontier". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Syrian forces battle rebels near Turkey border crossing". Reuters. 24 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian Rebels Capture Town Near Turkish Border". ABC News.
- ^ "Reports cite 80 dead in Kessab; Churches desecrated". Armradio.am. 24 March 2014.
- ^ "Mihraç Ural Suriye'de öldü iddiası!". Internethaber.com. 24 March 2014.
- ^ "Ural Maharaja: I'm not dead". Sabah.com.tr. 26 March 2014.
- ^ a b "Syria rebels launch northern offensive after heavy losses". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ a b "Syria rebels take coastal village in Al Assad heartland – NGO". Gulf News. 25 March 2014.
- ^ a b "Free Syrian Army marches on to Lazkiya". Worldbulletin.net. 25 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian army ousts militants from border town of Kesab". Aysor.am. 25 March 2014.
- ^ "Clashes are taking place in Kessab-Shahan Kantaharian". Hayernaysor.am. 25 March 2014.
- ^ a b Activists: Syrian rebels seize coastal area Archived 25 March 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ a b "Violent clashes in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 25 March 2014.
- ^ "Violent clashes in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 26 March 2014.
- ^ "Agaydada prominent Saudi Abdullah Mahiseny speaking from the top of the observatory 45". Syriahr.com. 25 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian missile system "harasses" Turkish F-16 jets: statement". Xinhua News Agency. 25 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian Rebels and Army Clash Over Coastal Town". ABC News.
- ^ Fierce fighting raging in Syria's Latakia[dead link]
- ^ "Syrian rebels battle deeper into coastal province". Knoxnews.com.[dead link]
- ^ "Syria complains to the UN over Turkish "aggression"". Syriahr.com. 27 March 2014.
- ^ Activists: Syrian warplanes bomb rebels in Latakia[dead link]
- ^ "Clashes continue in Lattakia countryside". Syriahr.com. 27 March 2014.
- ^ a b <%= item.timeFlag %>. "Syrian forces regain control over highlands on border with Turkey". Information Telegraph Agency of Russia.
- ^ Aji, Albert (27 March 2014). "Activists: Syrian warplanes bomb rebels in Latakia". The Washington Times.
- ^ "Regime fights back against rebel gains in Latakia". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Hot battles continue in surrounding of Samra village". Armenpress.am.
- ^ "Head of the military intelligence in Latakia province escaped after being surrounded". Syriahr.com. 27 March 2014.
- ^ "more than 150 regular forces killed in Lattakia countryside". Syriahr.net. 28 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrians rally in support of rebels' coastal offensive". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ a b "Regime tries to rally on coast after taking Qalamoun villages". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Syrian Islamists Kill 80 Christians, Displace Thousands More". Worthynews.com. 31 March 2014.
- ^ Poghosyan, Ekaterina (31 March 2014). "Tevan Poghosyan: "No casualties reported in Kessab on the Armenian side"". Mediamax. Retrieved 27 April 2014.
- ^ "More than 1000 killed and wounded in the clashes in Latakia". Syriahr.com.
- ^ "Syrian army pounds rebels in Assad's home province". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Chronicle Map Update". Twitter.com.
- ^ "Turkey fires into Syria after shelling damages mosque". English.al-akhbar.com. 31 March 2014.
- ^ "Shelling and clashes in Latakia and Hama clashes South Mork". Syriahr.com. 31 March 2014.
- ^ "Syrian army retakes key post in Latakia". Main.omanobserver.om.
- ^ "Turkish military fires into Syria after rocket hits mosque". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ a b "Shelling and clashes in Latakia". Syriahr.com. 1 April 2014.
- ^ "Syria opposition says chief visits Latakia". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "Reef Latakia witnessing violent clashes and arrival of reinforcements". Syriahr.com. 2 April 2014.
- ^ "Violence flares around Damascus". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ "استعادة مقاتلون من شام الاسلام السيطرة على مباني بالمرصد45". Syriahr.com. 3 April 2014.
- ^ "Fighting rages in Syria's Latakia: activists". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ Lundquist, Lisa (4 April 2014). "Al Qaeda emir Ayman al Zawahiri eulogized Abu Khalid al Suri...". The Long War Journal.
- ^ "Un centenar de morts en combats entre els rebels i l'Exèrcit a Síria". Diaridegirona.cat. 5 April 2014.
- ^ "Clashes continued in the countryside of Lattakia". Syriahr.com. 4 April 2014.
- ^ "مقتل 8 عناصر من القوات النظامية وجرح اكثر من 15 في اللاذقية". Syriahr.com. 4 April 2014.
- ^ "Rebels take northern town on main highway". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ Lundquist, Lisa (5 April 2014). "The Al Nusrah Front and the Islamic Front clashed with regime forces...". The Long War Journal.
- ^ "سقوط صاروخ غراد في بساتين الريحان بمدينة اللاذقية". Syriahr.com. 5 April 2014.
- ^ "Violent clashes in the vicinity of Mount thieves Brive Latakia". Syriahr.com. 7 April 2014.
- ^ "Syrian army seizes strategic mountain in Latakia". Retrieved 13 April 2014.
- ^ "Lattakia province". Facebook.com. 12 April 2014.
- ^ "Clashes continue in Lattakia and Homs". Syriahr.com. 12 April 2014.
- ^ "Violent clashes and martyrs in Lattakia and Kalamoon". Syriahr.com. 14 April 2014.
- ^ "Syria in Last 24 Hours: Army Takes Back Strategic Mountains in Eastern Syria". English.farsnews.com. 15 April 2014.
- ^ "Commander of the Western Front and Central :: 398 thousand dollars given to battles Coast". Syriahr.com. 18 April 2014.
- ^ "Rebel fire kills 21 in Syria's Aleppo". Globalpost.com.
- ^ "Site of Al-Samra Police Station in Lattakia under Army's Control". English.farsnews.com. 27 April 2014.
- ^ "The Arab Chronicle". Twitter.com. 27 April 2014.
- ^ "Aleppo violence claims dozens of lives". The Daily Star. Lebanon.
- ^ Elijah J Magnier Archived 29 April 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ "Syrian Army Regains Control over Height 724 in Latakia". Almanar.com.lb.
- ^ Разработка сайта prodengiblog.ru (29 April 2014). "Syria: Summary fights for April 28, 2014". Lratvakan.com.
- ^ Elijah J Magnier Archived 2 May 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ Elijah J Magnier Archived 2 May 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ Elijah J Magnier [EjmAlrai] (3 May 2014). "#BreakingNews #Syria #Lattakia #Kessab #SAA #Hezbollah:..." (Tweet). Retrieved 2 January 2016 – via Twitter.
- ^ Elijah J Magnier [EjmAlrai] (4 May 2014). "2/ #Syria #Kessab: SOHR confirmed Nab'ayn,..." (Tweet). Retrieved 2 January 2016 – via Twitter.
- ^ Elija J Magnier [EjmAlrai] (17 May 2014). "1/ #BreakingNews #Syria #Kessab #Lattakia:" (Tweet). Retrieved 2 January 2016 – via Twitter.
- ^ "Syrian Arab Army 1". Facebook.com.
- ^ "Syrian Arab Army 2". Facebook.com.
- ^ "Syrian Army Advances in Kasab, Strikes Nusra Terrorists in Rankous". Almanar.com.lb. 24 May 2010.
- ^ "Withdrawal of fighters from the front and the victory of the Islamic battalions town win". Syriahr.com.
- ^ "Al-Nusra jihadists pull out Syria's Kesab city seized in March". The Voice of Russia. 15 June 2014.
- ^ "NGO: Syria rebels, jihadists withdraw from town near Turkey". Al Arabiya.
- ^ "Syria rebels withdraw from border town near Turkey". Globalpost.com. 6 June 2014.
- ^ "Kessab Liberated [Update". Asbarez.com. 24 April 2014.
- ^ "System controls the gain and Mabrha and bitter spring". Syriahr.com.
- ^ "Clashes in the win and martyrs in Daraa". Syriahr.com.
- ^ a b c d e f "Armenian Homes in Kessab Looted, Occupied". Asbarez. 25 March 2014. Retrieved 9 January 2015.
- ^ Syria says Turkey shoots down Syrian warplane Archived 23 March 2014 at the Wayback Machine.
- ^ "Turkey shoots down Syrian regime plane after violating airspace, PM confirms". Hürriyet Daily News. 13 September 2011.
- ^ Amberin Zaman (27 March 2014). "Turkish opposition leader says Erdogan wants war with Syria". Al Monitor. Retrieved 6 December 2015.
- ^ Amberin Zaman (27 March 2014). "Fear of war grips Turkish border province". Al Monitor. Retrieved 6 December 2015.
- ^ "Serzh Sargsyan makes press statement on Kessab in The Hague". Panorama.am. 25 March 2014.
- ^ Samantha Power Questioned About Kessab, Syria by Rep. Schiff http://www.aaainc.org/index.php?id=7&no_cache=1&newsID=491
- ^ Minister Of Diaspora: Armenian Churches Were Defaced In Kessab http://www.mediamax.am/en/news/politics/9769/
- ^ "Armenian expert in Turkish affairs accuses West of inaction over Kessab Armenians". Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ a b "Latakia not a safe place – Kessab Armenians on evacuation, looting and rapes". Tert.am. 27 March 2014. Retrieved 9 January 2015.
- ^ "Suzy Kasab testimony". YouTube. 1 May 2014. Retrieved 9 January 2015.
- ^ "Photos of ruined Armenian churches of Kessab appear in internet". armenpress.am. 16 June 2014. Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ "Syrian Armenians: Terrorists burnt all Armenian churches in Kessab". Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ Rebels Robbing Homes, Desecrating Churches in Kessab, Syria
- ^ "250 families return to Kessab". Public Radio of Armenia. Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ "Click here to Log in". Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ "LiveLeak.com - 250 Families Return to Kessab". Retrieved 13 February 2015.
- ^ Armenian Church of Kessab Was Re-consecrated. Lragir.am, 28 July 2014.
- ^ "Serzh Sargsyan makes press statement on Kessab in The Hague". Panorama.am. 25 March 2014. Retrieved 25 March 2014.
- ^ Canada Concerned by Attacks on Armenian Town in Syria International.gc.ca, 25 March 2014
- ^ Canada Concerned by Attacks on Armenian Town in Syria News.gc.ca, 25 March 2014
- ^ "Babayan: Through subversive attacks, Turkey tries to make Armenians leave Syria". Panorama.am. 25 March 2014. Retrieved 26 March 2014.
- ^ John says:. "Russia Denounced War on Syria and Ethnic Cleansing of Armenian Syrians in Kessab and Lattakia". Nsnbc.me.
- ^ UN Rejected Russian Proposal on Kessab http://www.lragir.am/index/eng/0/politics/view/32240
- ^ "Chechnya's President condemns attackers on Syrian town of Kesab – News – World – The Voice of Russia: News, Breaking news, Politics, Economics, Business, Russia, International current events, Expert opinion, podcasts, Video". The Voice of Russia.
- ^ "Daily Press Briefing – March 28, 2014". U.S. Department of State. 28 March 2014. Retrieved 6 April 2014.
- ^ "Lawmakers, Armenians urge U.S. to investigate attack on Syrian city". Los Angeles Times. 8 April 2014.
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War in 2014
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving the al-Nusra Front
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving the Free Syrian Army
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving the Syrian government
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving Hezbollah
- Military operations of the Syrian Civil War involving Turkey
- Latakia Governorate
- Anti-Armenianism
- Recep Tayyip Erdoğan controversies