Labor has questioned the bona fides of a report apparently commissioned by the Treasury that plays down the role of big government spending in helping Australia survive the global financial crisis.
Written by Griffith University professor Tony Makin, a long-term critic of the so-called cash-splash during the crisis, it finds "no evidence fiscal stimulus benefited the economy over the medium term".
More Victoria News Videos
- Video duration
- 01:17
Scott Morrison: Talk of recession is ...
Scott Morrison: Talk of recession is 'alarmist'
Treasurer Scott Morrison says his focus is on ensuring economic policy drives investment. Courtesy ABC News 24.
Up Next
Fire at Melbourne Islamic Centre
- Video duration
- 00:23
- Video duration
- 00:23
Fire at Melbourne Islamic Centre
Fire at Melbourne Islamic Centre
Authorities are investigating a fire that damaged an Islamic community centre in Melbourne's north. Vision courtesy ABC News 24.
Up Next
North-East 'missing' link proposal
- Video duration
- 01:08
- Video duration
- 01:08
North-East 'missing' link proposal
North-East 'missing' link proposal
Victorian government releases an animation showing how they'll close the ring road gap if relected in 2018.
Up Next
Man killed in City Loop tunnel
- Video duration
- 00:17
- Video duration
- 00:17
Man killed in City Loop tunnel
Man killed in City Loop tunnel
A Metro Trains spokesman said a person was hit by a train about 2.30pm on Friday but said at 5.45pm all lines running on their normal routes. Vision courtesy Seven News Melbourne.
Up Next
Inside the House of Dior
- Video duration
- 01:21
- Video duration
- 01:21
Inside the House of Dior
Inside the House of Dior
In celebration of the seventieth anniversary of the House of Dior, the National Gallery of Victoria presents The House of Dior: Seventy Years of Haute Couture.
Up Next
Skydiving record set in Nagambie
- Video duration
- 01:28
- Video duration
- 01:28
Skydiving record set in Nagambie
Skydiving record set in Nagambie
32 skydivers took flight in northern Victoria on Friday to set a new national sequential record for large formation skydiving.
Up Next
VCE results accidentally released early
- Video duration
- 03:00
- Video duration
- 03:00
VCE results accidentally released early
VCE results accidentally released early
VTAC tells 3AW the glitch is being investigated and Mary, mother of twin Year 12 students, says one of her children received her results, the other didn't.
Up Next
Andrews government debates assisted dying
- Video duration
- 02:14
- Video duration
- 02:14
Andrews government debates assisted dying
Andrews government debates assisted dying
Victoria is considering legalising voluntary euthanasia, and much parliamentary debate is expected. Vision courtesy Seven News Melbourne
Scott Morrison: Talk of recession is 'alarmist'
Treasurer Scott Morrison says his focus is on ensuring economic policy drives investment. Courtesy ABC News 24.
"In sum, the nature of Australia's fiscal stimulus was misconceived because it emphasised transfers,unproductive expenditure such as school halls and Pink Batts, rather than tax relief and/or supply side reform, as occurred for instance in New Zealand," the paper says.
"Largely implemented after the worst of the crisis had passed, fiscal stimulus countered the effectiveness of monetary policy by keeping market interest rates higher than otherwise and therefore contributed to a strong exchange rate. This worsened Australia's international competitiveness and damaged industries in the internationally exposed sector, particularly manufacturing."
Australia is one of the few countries in the developed world to have escaped recession during the crisis that began in 2008. Others, including New Zealand, did not.
Professor Makin has previously been taken to task by the Treasury for his criticism of economic stimulus during the crisis, which it said was "based on a theoretical model that does not apply in Australia's case in general and assumptions that did not hold during the global financial crisis".
The status of his new paper is unclear. It is dated August 2016 but did not appear on a Treasury website until late Friday morning after requests for it and after two newspapers were apparently given early access to it. Even then, it wasn't placed on the Treasury website itself but on as lesser-known site entitled "Treasury Research Institute" which the treasury says was established earlier this year to report on "topics of interest to Treasury to encourage work or collaboration with Treasury".
Only on Friday afternoon did the treasury create a link to the Treasury Research Institute from its homepage. It said the institute would "regularly publish papers to the site on topical economic and policy issues, written by both external contributors and staff".
Labor treasury spokesman Chris Bowen said he would write to the secretary to the Treasury, John Fraser, to ask why he commissioned work by a "well-known ideological opponent of the stimulus package".
He said its release seemed to have been designed to distract attention from government's backflips over energy policy and to preempt calls for further stimulus in the wake of national accounts figures showing the economy going backwards.
On Wednesday, Treasurer Scott Morrison attacked Labor's spending during the crisis, saying: "They gave money to dead people and thought that was going to grow the economy; that was a nonsense".
Mr Bowen said the Treasurer ought to be concentrating on the present rather than the past.
At the time, the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development and other international bodies had praised Australia's response to the crisis as "one of the best designed and implemented in the world".
111 comments
Comment are now closed