Comment

Letters to the Editor

Premier Mike Baird during question time on Tuesday.

Mike Baird's moves on the ICAC raise thorny questions

The proposal to move to a three-person ICAC will result in a restriction on the commissioner's power to hold public inquiries, which have played a large part in the ICAC's success, both as a deterrent to corruption and as a means of stimulating other witnesses to come forward.

Voters are waking up to Magic Mike's tricks

SMH Letters

To distract us from the disaster of the Orange byelection, Magic Mike's Coalition government has announced its "commitment" to a metro rail line from the Sydney CBD to Parramatta.

Bizarre refugee deal stains us again

Illustration: Cathy Wilcox

It is wonderful to see the suffering crowds on Manus and Nauru offered a home in the land of the free ("Secret deals end offshore detention", November 12-13). Their treatment to date has been a dreadful stain on our national history. Based on our actions many of them have probably decided already that Australia is no longer a place they want to call home. However I am very confused about how this acts as a deterrent to people smugglers. A back door to the USA seems a real incentive to try for Australia with hopes of a home in another fine place. Malcolm says "once only" but he is of the professional expediency class who live in our own Disneyland beside Lake Burley Griffin. Other than the saving of face for our political leaders, how has can this be more practical than finding them place in our country. They are now shown to be real refugees. Why are we so proudly and stubbornly merciless in this aspect of Australia's refugee policies. Peter Copleston Westleigh  

Network priority

SMH letters dinkus PLEASE DON'T DELETE CAPTION

My free advice to Sydney Trains would be to spend more on improving Sydney's ailing public transport network.

Another sell-off, another sell-out

SMH Letters dinkus

What a disgrace to see the Lands and Education buildings joining the long list of heritage assets flogged by the Baird government.

Make sex abuse redress scheme obligatory

SMH letters dinkus

The big problem with the federal government's compensation scheme for victims of child abuse in institutions is that it's optional for the institutions to participate ("Churches feel heat over plan to help sex abuse survivors", November 5-6).

Recipe for a bit success revealed at last

<p></p>

These days the main difference between successful people and unsuccessful people seems to be that successful people write books on success and unsuccessful people buy them.

Bad attitudes on roads a killer

SMH Letters

Congratulations to the Herald for highlighting the devastating consequences of speeding on our roads (Letters, November 4). If a car exceeds the limit and kills innocent people it must not be seen as an accident. It is a criminal act. Penalties for speeding must be greatly increased.

POSTSCRIPT: Political farce not so funny

Former Senator Bob Day.

Halloween, Melbourne Cup and all manner of frivolity filled the inbox this week. But it was our nation's federal politicians causing the most mirth: notably One Nation Senator Rod Culleton and former Families First Senator Bob Day. Letter writers were more inclined to agree with Peter Rawsthorne of Largs, who found nothing funny about Culleton's farcical press conference. "It was indicative of the current state of politics in Australia and much of the Western world. I don't expect to agree with every member of the Parliament, but I do expect them to have a working knowledge of the judicial system and a familiarity with the difference between guilt and innocence in the courts. For the Senator to stand in front of a press conference that he called and announce that he was not there to be 'cross-examined by the media' beggars belief." George Manojlovic of Mangerton quipped on the Culleton key controversy: "If the truck driver's account of the confrontation is correct, it looks like a case of the [John] Dunn key and the ass." Tony Re of Georges Hall wrote: "There is nothing surprising about any secretive arrangement that Malcolm Turnbull has had with Bob Day.  This is a major pattern of his leadership. His cloak and dagger undermining of Tony Abbott was just the start. What is next to emerge from the shadows of Potts Point?" On matters Potts Point, Daniel Flesch of Bellingen wasn't the only one to point out that this week's letter writer Merona Martin of  Meroo Meadow is giving Peter Pitt (no relation) of Potts Point an alliterative run for his money. Our Meroo Meadow resident was writing about point-to-point speed checks,  a hot button topic especially for our rural readers.

China has reason to question rules in its region

SMH Letters

Peter Hartcher quotes, and seems to endorse, Peter Varghese's view: "We all have an interest in a rules-based system, though China doesn't see it. There wouldn't be a China story if not for the stability the US has provided" ("Tough talk needed in face of hysteria", November 1).

Premier deaf to the sounds of protesters

SMH Letters

Premier Baird seems hellbent on bulldozing his "developments" and privatisation through as quickly as possible to claim it all on his watch, but what about the people being told (not asked) to move aside

Housing solutions are ripe for the picking

SMH Letters

Jacob Saulwick's useful comment on affordable housing explains how massive numbers of affordable rental homes in the US have been built by incentivising developers through tax credits.

Allow empty-nesters to breathe, please

Illustration: Cathy Wilcox

As a so-called "empty nester", I would point out that many of us do not have empty bedrooms gathering dust. There's the joy of finally having our own study or work space, as well as these rooms doubling up as somewhere to put the exercise bike to renew our ageing bodies.

Growth not enough

SMH Letters

Arthur Sinodinos believes that a strong economy is the key to relieving child poverty in Australia. Australia has had a strong economy for more than 25 years. Yet for some reason that hasn't helped.