I always find it ironic when the ultra-right references socialist Orwell in their banter. I think the constant nineteen eighty-four referencing reveals two things:
a) the novel is a cultural icon and an easy slippery slope argument to reference b) that the schizophrenic 'EVERYBODY is out to get me' subject matter of the work identifies heavily with these people who obviously have mental health issues.
Let us all hope they get the help they need and thus no longer have to drag poor Georgie through the mud with them.
23 October 2009 at 10:04
Not much to say about it, other than a desire to keep our readership in the loop:
By Heather Polischuk, Leader-Post October 20, 2009
REGINA — The lawyer for former university lecturer, Terrence Cecil Tremaine, referenced author George Orwell’s famed 1984 while railing against Canada’s hate laws.
Monday marked the start of Tremaine’s preliminary hearing at Regina Provincial Court on a charge of promoting hatred.
A preliminary hearing is held to determine whether the Crown has sufficient evidence to proceed to trial. Should the matter go to trial, Tremaine wishes to be tried by Court of Queen’s Bench judge and jury.
Details from the preliminary hearing can’t be reported because of a publication ban.
Outside of court, defence lawyer Doug Christie criticized anti-hate legislation when he spoke to media.
“I think (the laws are) a massive waste of police resources,” he said. “I think that they’re kind of like preventing crime by stopping people from thinking, because if you can stop people from talking, you should be able to stop them from thinking as well. As soon as we can find out what you’re thinking, we’ll be able to regulate that too. If anyone’s read 1984, you can see where that leads, and this is kind of a precursor of things to come.”
Christie called the sections “a vehicle for police to waste public money chasing political enemies.” “Ultimately, I don’t think the state should be deciding what people say,” he said. “That should be, in a free and democratic society, open to people to decide for themselves.”
Christie said he worried Canada is becoming a police state under the pretense of combatting terrorism and that it should be up to individuals to decide what to think about statements made.
The Victoria-based lawyer previously defended former First Nations leader David Ahenakew on his hate crime charge, which was inevitably thrown out.
Crown prosecutor John Stoesser declined comment outside of court.
The hearing continues today before Judge Bruce Henning.
We're not sure that Eric Arthur Blair would appreciate his novel being used to justify the very fascism he sought to condemn in 1984 by the kind of people whom he fought in Spain.
1 Comment
Close this window Jump to comment formI always find it ironic when the ultra-right references socialist Orwell in their banter. I think the constant nineteen eighty-four referencing reveals two things:
a) the novel is a cultural icon and an easy slippery slope argument to reference
b) that the schizophrenic 'EVERYBODY is out to get me' subject matter of the work identifies heavily with these people who obviously have mental health issues.
Let us all hope they get the help they need and thus no longer have to drag poor Georgie through the mud with them.
23 October 2009 at 10:04