As the
United States dropped its atomic bombs on
Hiroshima and Nagasaki in
August 1945, 1.6 million
Soviet troops launched a surprise attack on the
Japanese army occupying eastern
Asia.
Within days,
Emperor Hirohito's million-man army in the region had collapsed.
It was a momentous turn on the
Pacific battleground of
World War II, yet one that would be largely eclipsed in the history books by the atomic bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the same week 65 years ago. But in recent years some historians have argued that the
Soviet action served as effectively as — or possibly more than — the
A-bombs in ending the war.
Now a new history by a professor at
University of California, Santa Barbara seeks to reinforce that view, arguing that fear of
Soviet invasion persuaded the
Japanese to opt for surrender to the
Americans, who they believed would treat them more generously than the
Soviets.
Japan's forces in northeast
Asia first tangled with the
Russians in
1939 when the Japanese army tried to invade
Mongolia. Their crushing defeat at the battle of
Khalkin Gol induced
Tokyo to
sign a neutrality pact that kept the
USSR out of the
Pacific war.
Tokyo turned its focus to confronting
U.S.,
British and
Dutch forces instead, which led to the
Pearl Harbor attack on
Dec. 7,
1941.
But following the
German surrender on
May 8, 1945, and having suffered a string of defeats in the
Philippines,
Okinawa and
Iwo Jima, Japan turned to
Moscow to mediate an end to the Pacific war.
However,
Soviet leader Joseph Stalin had already secretly promised
Washington and
London that he would attack Japan within three months of
Germany's defeat. He thus ignored Tokyo's plea, and mobilized more than a million troops along
Manchuria's border.
"
The Soviet entry into the war played a much greater role than the atomic bombs in inducing Japan to surrender because it dashed any hope that Japan could terminate the war through Moscow's mediation," said
Tsuyoshi Hasegawa, whose recently published "
Racing the
Enemy" examines the conclusion of the Pacific war and is based on recently declassified Soviet archives as well as U.S. and Japanese documents
..
Despite the death toll from the atomic bombings —
140,
000 in
Hiroshima, 80,000 in
Nagasaki the
Imperial Military Command believed it could hold out against an
Allied invasion if it retained control of Manchuria and
Korea, which provided Japan with the resources for war, according to
Hasegawa and
Terry Charman, a historian of World War II at
London's Imperial War Museum.
"The Soviet attack changed all that," Charman said. "The leadership in Tokyo realized they had no hope now, and in that sense
August Storm did have a greater effect on the Japanese decision to surrender than the dropping of the A-bombs
."
In the U.S., the bombings are still widely seen as a decision of last resort against an enemy that appeared determined to fight to the death.
President Harry S. Truman and
U.S. military leaders believed an invasion of Japan would cost hundreds of thousands of
American lives.
American historian
Richard B. Frank has argued that as terrible as the atomic bombs were, they saved hundreds of thousands of American soldiers and millions of Japanese troops and civilians who would have perished if the conflict had gone on until 1946
.
"In the famous words of
Secretary of War Henry Stimson, (the bombs) were the 'least abhorrent choice' of a dreadful array of option facing American leaders," he said in an interview. "Alternatives to the atomic bombs carried no guarantee as to when they would end the war and carried a far higher price in human death and suffering."
V-J Day, the day Japan ceased fighting, came on Aug. 15 (Aug. 14 in the U.S.), and Japan's formal surrender followed on Sept. 2.
Dominic Lieven, a professor of
Russian government at the
London School of Economics, said anti-Soviet sentiment in the
West tended to minimize
Soviet military achievements.
Also, "very few Anglo-Americans saw the Soviet offensive in the
Far East with their own eyes, and Soviet archives were not open to
Western historians subsequently," he said.
More surprising, even in
Russia the campaign was largely ignored. Although the scale of the Soviet victory was unprecedented, 12,000 dead against Japan hardly compared with the life-and-death struggle against
Nazi Germany, in which 27 million Soviets died.
"The importance of the operation was huge," said retired
Gen. Makhmut Gareyev, president of the
Russian Academy of
Military Sciences, who took part in the
1945 campaign. "By entering the war with militarist Japan
... the
Soviet Union precipitated the end of World War II."
Target WW2 unknown reason military from Soviet Union lands on
Hokkaido,for more info about
WW 2 history visit site at
http://penglaichina.com as well as business video hub at http://youtube.com/user/videofilmfiles
- published: 22 Aug 2014
- views: 955