DOES S400 MAKES
F 35 OBSOLETE ?
TOP 5
FACTS
The
Lockheed Martin F-35 Lightning II which is a single-seat, single-engine, all-weather stealth multirole fighters is UNDERGOING FINAL DEVELOPMENT AND TESTING by the
United States.
The fighter aircraft will be in service till 2050.
The pentagon began the f-35 program in
2001 with an aim to develop a cost effective replacement for the u.s. military’s f-15 fighters, f-16 and f-18 bombers and reconnaissance aircraft, and a-10 close air support warplanes.
Apart from United States,the primary customer and financial backer, the
United Kingdom,
Italy, the
Netherlands,
Canada,
Turkey,
Australia,
Norway and
Denmark are also part of the program.
The nine major partner nations, including the
U.S., plan to acquire over 3,
100 F-35s through 2035, which, if delivered will make the
F-35 one of the most numerous jet fighters.
The fighter aircraft will be in service till 2050.
THE
S-400 TRIUMF IS AN ANTI-AIRCRAFT
WEAPON SYSTEM DEVELOPED BY
RUSSIA'S ALMAZ CENTRAL DESIGN BUREAU IN THE 1990S AS AN
UPGRADE OF THE
S-300 FAMILY. IT HAS BEEN IN SERVICE WITH THE RUSSIAN ARMED FORCES SINCE
2007.
IT IS DESIGNED TO DEFEND AGAINST AIRCRAFTS INCLUDING 5TH GENERATION STEALTH FIGHTERS ,BOMBERS,
AWACS, CRUISE MISSILES AND BALLISTIC MISSILE.
IT IS CONSIDERED ONE OF THE MOST
POWER ANTI AIRCRAFT DEFENSE SYSTEM IN THE
WORLD.
IN THIS
VIDEO WE WILL ANALYZE THE OUTCOME WHEN F 35 IS PITTED AGAINST
S 400
Specs.
Options:
In a standalone combat environment , F 35 has the following options to defeat S 400.
OUT
RUN
OUT MANEUVER A MISSILE
STEALTH TO AVOID DETECTION
USE EW SUIT TO
JAM S 400
WE WILL ANALYZE EACH OF THESE ONE BY ONE AND RATE THE SURVIVABILITY CHANCES ON A
SCALE OF 1 TO 5.
OUT RUN OR OUT MANEUVER A MISSILE:
OUT RUN:
IN
PAST WE HAVE SEEN THIS
TACTIC BEING APPLIED SUCCESSFULLY WHEN IN APRIL
1986,
SR-71 BLACKBIRD OUTRAN
SA-2 SAM OVER
LIBYA.
BUT IN
CASE OF F 35 , THE TACTICS WILL BE USELESS SINCE IT HAS A TOP
SPEED OF ONLY 1.6
MACH AND MISSILES DEPLOYED BY S 400 HAVE HYPERSONIC SPEEDS RANGING FROM 6 MACH TO 14 MACH.
FOR EXAMPLE :48H6E3 MISSILE HAS A SPEED OF 14 MACH
OUT MANEUVER:
F 35 IS NOT DESIGNED
TO BE A
GREAT DOGFIGHTER AND LACKS AGILITY WHEN COMPARED TO FIGHTERS LIKE
F 22 OR SU 35.
THE NEED FOR THE
SMALL F-35 TO CARRY A HEAVY RANGE OF
INTERNAL ENGINES,
FUEL AND
WEAPONS HAS RESULTED IN WHAT AVIATION EXPERTS LABELS A ‘HIGH
WING LOADING’. ESSENTIALLY, THE WINGS ARE SMALL IN RELATION TO ITS WEIGHT AND THIS IMPEDES MANEUVERABILITY.
F 35 ALSO HAS A SLUGGISH RATE OF CLIMB WHEN COMPARED TO MODERN FIGHTERS
THE F 35 HAS ALSO NOT DEMONSTRATED THE ABILITY TO PULL
OFF 9 G TURNS THOUGH DESIGN AND CONTRACT SPECIFICATIONS
CALL FOR 9 GS.
TILL TESTS SHOWED THE
PILOT COULD PULL NO MORE THAN 6.5 GS IN
HARD DEFENSIVE TURNS.
THE MISSILE DEPLOYED BY S 400 ARE NOT ONLY GUIDED BY THE SYSTEM BUT ALSO HAVE HOMING CAPABILITIES,.
FOR EXAMPLE, 40N6 HAS ACTIVE
RADAR HOMING AND 48N6DM HAS SEMI-ACTIVE RADAR HOMING
HEAD.
THESE MISSILE ARE VERY
AGILE AND F 35 WILL FIND IT VERY HAD TO OUT MANEUVER THESE MISSILES.
THE ABILITY TO
TWIST,
TURN AND ACCELERATE IS A DESPERATE — BUT
VITAL — LAST-MOMENT COMPONENT OF COUNTERMEASURES TO MODERN MISSILES AND F 35 FALLS
SHORT ON THAT
COUNT
STEALTH
THE F-35’S SIMPLIFIED AIRFRAME IS
FAR LESS OF THE ‘SHAPED STEALTH’ FOUND IN THE
F-22. THIS IMPLIES A MUCH GREATER RELIANCE ON RADAR-ABSORBING MATERIALS.
AGAINST X-BAND RADARS, IT IS ONLY STEALTHY (LO) FROM FRONT AND REAR;
AGAINST S-BAND RADAR, IT IS STEALTHY FROM NARROW FRONT ASPECT,
AGAINST L-BAND RADAR. LIMITED REDUCTION IS ACHIEVED FROM
DIRECT FRONT
S 400 HAVE MULTIPLE RADARS WHICH OPERATE IN DIFFERENT BANDS.
APART FROM TRADITIONAL RADARS ,S 400 HAS RADARS THAT ARE CAPABLE OF DETECTING STEALTHY AIRCRAFT.
THE FULL LIST IS RADARS ARE AS FOLLOWS:
1.ALMAZ 92N6E GRAVE STONE ENGAGEMENT RADAR
2.REDUNDANT
NIIIP 91N6E
BIG BIRD ACQUISITION RADAR
3. LEMZ 96L6-1/96L6E ACQUISITION RADAR
4.67N6
GAMMA DE ACQUISITION RADARS IN L
BAND;
5. 59N6 PROTIVNIK GE ACQUISITION RADARS IN L BAND;
6.1L119 NEBO
SVU IN THE
VHF BAND,
7.MULTIBAND NEBO M.
THE NEBO SVU & NEBU M HAVE A CLAIMED CAPABILITY AGAINST STEALTH AIRCRAFT
EM
ALL THREE VARIANTS OF THE F-35 CARRY ACTIVE, ELECTRONICALLY SCANNED
ARRAY (
AESA) RADARS WITH SOPHISTICATED ELECTRONIC ATTACK CAPABILITIES, INCLUDING FALSE TARGETS,
NETWORK ATTACK, ADVANCED JAMMING AND ALGORITHM-PACKED
DATA STREAMS. THIS SYSTEM ALLOWS THE F-35 TO
REACH WELL-DEFENDED TARGETS AND SUPPRESS ENEMY RADARS THAT THREATEN THE F-35.
BUT S 400 HAS MANY FEATURES SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED TO OVERCOME COUNTERMEASURES AND STEALTH, SUCH AS A LARGER, MORE POWERFUL RADAR THAT IS MORE RESISTANT TO JAMMING.
THE MAIN RADAR IS A PULSE-TO-PULSE AGILE FREQUENCY HOPPER, TO MAXIMIZE COUNTERMEASURES RESISTANCE.
THE S-400 ALSO HAS TOPAZ KOLCHUGA M, KRTP-91 TAMARA / TRASH CAN, AND 85V6
ORION / VEGA EMITTER LOCATING SYSTEMS.
- published: 29 Feb 2016
- views: 179