** PLEASE
NOTE: This video is owned by the
BBC and as such is unavailable in some countries. We apologise for any inconvenience this may cause. The event is available worldwide as an episode of the
Intelligence Squared podcast here: https://soundcloud.com/intelligence2/the-nuclear-deal-with-iran-won-t-make-the-world-a-safer-place. **
Filmed at the
Emmanuel Centre in
London on
2nd November 2015.
What’s not to like? The deal reached between
Iran and six world powers in July is a major diplomatic breakthrough. In exchange for
Tehran halting its nuclear weapons programme, the
West will lift the sanctions that have been crippling Iran’s economy for the last decade. The deal was hailed by
President Obama as ‘a historic understanding’ and met with cheers of approval from around the world. Of course, the agreement doesn’t guarantee that Iran will never get the bomb some time in the future. But its supporters argue that in a complex world it’s the best option going. There will be no pre-emptive strike on Iran’s nuclear facilities for at least 10 years. The freeing up of over £
100 billion of frozen assets will increase Iran’s stability, and the improved communication and trade between Iran and other countries will strengthen the hand of those
Iranians who want their nation to be part of the modern world. The deal is a major step towards making the world a safer place.
That’s the line of those who support the deal. But to others, including
Israel’s prime minister
Binyamin Netanyahu, it’s not so much a historic understanding as a terrifying historic mistake. The Iranians, they say, have a track record of wily negotiating.
Once the agreement’s restrictions expire in around 2025, what is there to stop the mullahs cranking up their nuclear programme and producing the bomb? In the meantime, relaxing sanctions will allow the Tehran to channel ever more funds to murderous regimes such as Assad’s
Syria, and the terrorist organisations Hamas and
Hezbollah. Furthermore, by cosying up to the
Shiite Iranians, the West risks alienating its
Sunni allies in the
Middle East and leaving Israel feeling even more dangerously exposed.
Will the deal avert war and give moderate Iranians the time they need to bring their country in from the cold? Or will it do no more than put a hold on Iran’s nuclear ambitions and allow the mullahs to ramp up their dangerous meddling in the region?
Alan Dershowitz, one of
America’s most formidable and celebrated lawyers, and
Emily Landau, one of Israel’s top nuclear proliferation experts, went head to head with senior politicians
Norman Lamont and
Jack Straw, both impassioned advocates of rapprochement with Iran.
- published: 07 Dec 2015
- views: 2753