DEROY MURDOCK: Victimless crimes

The Press of Atlantic City

— Scripps Howard News Service

NEW YORK So-called “D.C. madam” Deborah Jeane Palfrey will not go down without a fight. She has shared her escort service’s phone records with ABC News and inspired the April 27 resignation of State Department foreign-aid chief Randall Tobias. He admitted to meeting Palfrey’s call girls — “to give me a massage,” but he insists, no sex.

While Tobias’ wife must be steamed, why is this news? Indeed, if he were single, some might applaud Tobias for getting lucky. Meanwhile, Palfrey has hired Preston Burton, Monica Lewinsky’s former attorney, thus returning that notorious name to national prominence.

Palfrey has made headlines because she faces prostitution charges. Since money changed hands, what otherwise would be mutual assured seduction instead is, literally, a federal case.

This never should have happened. As in so many places where police and prosecutors poke their noses, this is something else that should be none of government’s damn business.

There is an argument for discouraging scantily clad streetwalkers from tarting up their surroundings. This is exactly why discreet escorts, like Palfrey’s, who perform on private property, are preferable to hookers on street corners.

 

 

Again, if Palfrey’s colleagues simply trolled Washington, swapping drinks and dinner for massages and more, no one would notice. So why, then, does trading cash for intimacy merit handcuffs and indictments? If coercion or minors are involved, please call 911. Otherwise, police, prosecutors, judges and juries have more urgent concerns than oppressing those who profit by comforting the lonely.

Prostitutes offer just one service that adults should be free to enjoy without fear of arrest. So do psychics.

Philadelphia officials should have skipped their recent crackdown on spiritual advisers. The City of Brotherly Love turned Big Brotherly when police on April 24 began padlocking psychics’ and Tarot-card-readers’ shops. A previously un-enforced third-degree misdemeanor forbade anyone to “pretend for gain or lucre to tell fortunes or predict future events,” as the Philadelphia Inquirer reported. Before defense attorneys intervened, cops hammered these occult entrepreneurs, supposedly because they bamboozled clueless clients.

Really? In trying times, many Americans see their clergymen. Others consult bartenders, barbers or bowling partners. So what if some Americans believe those who peer into crystal balls? Most folks steer away from seers, but if no one got frog-marched into a seance at gunpoint, Philadelphia authorities should have focused on those who faced gun muzzles, namely the 127 people fatally shot or otherwise killed through April 24, 17.6 percent more than the 108 killed through that date in 2006.

Speaking of dangerous thugs, thank God cops nabbed Barbara Jackson, a 71-year-old Bronx great-grandmother. Jackson is a colorectal-cancer survivor whose chemotherapy has crushed her appetite.

“My taste buds are gone, but the marijuana helps me get the food down,” she told the New York Daily News. “The marijuana has kept me alive. I wouldn’t be here if I didn’t smoke.”

Undercover officers arrested her March 13 when she bought grass near her home. They whisked her to the 46th Precinct, fingerprinted her and jailed her for five hours. Thankfully, Bronx prosecutors dropped charges after local journalists howled.

Despite claims by Jackson and others that marijuana keeps them breathing, drug warriors trivialize scientific evidence of marijuana’s health benefits. (The U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration cynically dismisses marijuana’s medical advantages while simultaneously forbidding marijuana research that might confirm such qualities.)

Again, so what?

It doesn’t matter whether marijuana clinically stimulates Jackson’s appetite. If it merely convinces her that she can eat, defeat cancer and stay healthy, isn’t that splendid? Barbara Jackson is an American adult. Provided she does not drive under its sway, she should be free to choose marijuana to battle cancer, or at least serve as a placebo.

As Boston University’s Dr. David Felson explained on the April 30 “NBC Nightly News,” taking placebos “isn’t necessarily a scientifically valid approach, but it’s a clinically helpful approach.”

Rather than torment call girls, clairvoyants and cancer patients, government officials should meditate on a few facts: Only half of black students graduate from high school on time. Murder erased 16,692 Americans in 2005. Meanwhile, Islamofascists itch to hike that death toll a thousand-fold. Ignorance, homicide and militant Islam concretely threaten this republic. Why don’t America’s hyperactive public servants go slay those dragons?

Judge to Palfrey: Stop Giving Out Phone Records

ABC News:

Washington – Thursday May 10, 2007 8:49 pm

ABC 7 News - Judge to Palfrey: Stop Giving Out Phone Records

 

A federal judge on Thursday ordered alleged Washington madam Deborah Jeane Palfrey and her attorney to stop releasing phone records from the escort service Palfrey ran.

Palfrey, 51, of Vallejo, Calif., is accused of racketeering by running an illegal prostitution ring that netted more than $2 million over 13 years, beginning in 1993. The case has drawn attention because of her threats to expose high-profile Washington officials.

U.S. District Court Judge Gladys Kessler issued a similar order in March, but Palfrey gave her phone records to ABC News before the order took effect.

Palfrey, who contends that her business was a legal escort service, hoped the network would name clients, and that they would testify that they did not have sex with the women who worked for her.

A report last week on the “20/20” newsmagazine mentioned NASA officials, military officers, chief executives and a career Justice Department prosecutor as clients. But the network did not publicly identify the individuals, saying their names were not newsworthy. After the broadcast, Palfrey’s civil attorney, Montgomery Blair Sibley, pressured Attorney General Alberto Gonzales to release the name of the prosecutor, threatening to release phone records that had not been previously given to ABC if he did not do so.

The Justice Department later said the individual had been dead for several years.

In Thursday’s order, Kessler said that Sibley had issued an ultimatum to the attorney general, and that he was threatening to violate her March order. She barred Palfrey and her attorney from distributing Palfrey’s phone records to any person or organization.

Blogs on Reproductive Justice from RH Reality Check

From RH Reality Check

 

World Bank Reproductive Health Strategy

Serra Sippel, Center for Health and Gender Equity on May 8, 2007 – 8:45am


Serra Sippel's picture

The Bush administration has gained notoriety for using women’s health as a pawn in catering to its ultra-conservative political base. Particularly noticeable is its attempts to narrow the scope in which international agreements and agencies address sexual and reproductive health and rights, such as attempting to remove references to reproductive rights and access to reproductive health services in UN documents, cutting off U.S. funding for UNFPA, and trying to restrict WHO positions on abortion and generic drugs. To this administration, women are always dispensable.

Read Full Post 

Global Impact of Anti-Prostitution Pledge

Julia Greenberg, American Jewish World Service on May 9, 2007 – 9:00am


Julia Greenberg's picture

Friday night, running late for a dinner party, I burst in and obnoxiously asked my hosts if I could turn on 20/20 for the big expose on the DC Madam. In retrospect I cannot imagine why in my wildest dreams I would have expected John Stossel, the 20/20 host known for his right wing punditry (and his unfortunate mustache) would deliver a cutting edge report that would bring down the halls of power.

Read Full Post