Speaking of Ian Birchall ...
![](http://web.archive.org./web/20151025225316im_/http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/site_imagery/ian_birchall_140x140.jpg)
Cynic: A person who smells flowers and looks for the coffin
Dagenham East, frankly. A good few stops past Barking. But just for the hell of it let's examine some of the arguments she advanced in the letter and her pitch to Prospect:
* The Roman Catholic Church manipulates members' interests.
And how skilfully she does it, eh. So well in fact, that her influence on recent Nu Labour legislation is nigh on invisible to any objective observer.
* The Roman Catholic Church has a grip on parliament, the media and public sphere.
Yes, indeed. Witness its effectiveness in censoring such bold secularist voices as Venomball herself.
* There was an "outraged reaction" from the Roman Catholic Church to her original Grauniad article.
Mmm. They speak of little else in Eccleston Square. Indeed when asked for a comment on the affair no less a person than Alexander DesForges said, "Mary Honeyball, Who she? Oh yes, I know, she's that woman who does the weather forecast on the telly isn't she? Oh she's not? She's said Catholics shouldn't participate in public life? Oh well, everyone's entitled to their opinion, I suppose. Must dash, that little prat Damian Thompson is kicking off about our website again. If we don't put a press release out about the Motu Proprio we'll never hear the end of it on Holy Smoke. Byeee!"
* Conor McGinn is the Roman Catholic Church.
And he has offices scattered in strategic locations across the globe from Islington to Rome with a vast army of volunteers to do his bidding, including tampering with Google by the way.
* Conor McGinn is The Catholic League.
And he and it are out to get her, you know.
* Conor McGinn has waged a sustained media campaign against her. He intimidated her. He tried to shut her up.
He's orchestrated this, all of this, blogs and news stories, it's all been drummed up by him. All this phoney outrage - there's nothing spontaneous about it - has been manufactured by him to stop her from telling the truth. From telling the truth about the way Catholics form a dangerous fifth column in the government's ranks; from telling the truth about the sway Catholics have over the national press; from telling the truth about the way Catholics tamper with google. But she won't be put off from telling the truth by all this intimidation! No way Jose Maria. She's going to keep on telling the truth, even if it costs her her life!
* She opened issues up for debate.
And welcomed the debate. Didn't complain at all about intimidation, or one-sided press coverage. Oh no! She welcomes vigorous debate, just as long as everyone agrees with her.
* Democratic politics is all about questioning, debating, scrutinising.
Questioning, debating and scrutinising anyone but her because that's not fair or legitimate, that's intimidation and probably orchestrated from deep inside the bowels of Vatican City to boot.
Yeah, well.
Mary Honeyball
is
a
sane
balanced
rational
individual
who is an adornment to Labour politics and should be sent to campaign in Glasgow East.